Artificial Clouds

  • Thread starter ANarwhal
  • Start date
  • #1
59
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

Is it possible to make a 10m^3 artificial cloud at about 1000ft in the sky?

If yes, how real does it look? Could someone tell the difference between the artificial cloud and the natural clouds simply by looking up at the sky?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Dotini
Gold Member
621
229
Is it possible to make a 10m^3 artificial cloud at about 1000ft in the sky?

If yes, how real does it look? Could someone tell the difference between the artificial cloud and the natural clouds simply by looking up at the sky?
What do you mean by the nebulous term "cloud"? A puff of smoke we can make. The mighty cumulonimbus cloud, sprouting lightning and shooting electrons from its electric and magnetic fields is one of the greatest works of nature, hard to understand and impossible to duplicate on demand.

Respectfully submitted,
Steve
 
  • #3
59
0
What do you mean by the nebulous term "cloud"? A puff of smoke we can make. The mighty cumulonimbus cloud, sprouting lightning and shooting electrons from its electric and magnetic fields is one of the greatest works of nature, hard to understand and impossible to duplicate on demand.

Respectfully submitted,
Steve
Good point, I mean this type of cloud: http://whyfiles.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/clouds.jpg

I am not interested in lightning, rain, or any other weather effects.
 
  • #4
Dotini
Gold Member
621
229
Clouds are thought (by me) to be most parsimoniously formed water, sunlight, and some kind of nucleating agent. Even cosmic rays may be involved. The process is not entirely explained at this time. Attempts have been made, either in the field or in theory, to artificially induce them. Some of these attempts border on crackpottery, so it's not an easy topic to discuss.

Respectfully,
Steve
 
Last edited:
  • #5
59
0
Clouds are thought (by me) to be formed by water, sunlight, and some kind of nucleating agent. Even cosmic rays may be involved. The process is not entirely explained at this time. Attempts have been made, either in the field or in theory, to artificially induce them. Some of these attempts border on crackpottery, so it's not an easy topic to discuss.

Respectfully,
Steve
Even with that being the case, is there not a solution that looks just as good to the naked eye?
 
  • #6
Dotini
Gold Member
621
229
Even with that being the case, is there not a solution that looks just as good to the naked eye?
Perhaps you would be visually satisfied by a rocket discharging a payload of smoke?

Yours,
Steve
 
  • #7
4,464
65
Those clouds of your picture are cumulus clouds. Nature makes them by different heating rate of the earth below. Hotter air start to rise (convection) and cools adiabatically due to expantion. If the lapse rate of the lower atmosphere is sufficient then cumulus clouds will form. So if you want to make these clouds, have a real big bonfire, boiling water on it, and hope if it works.
 
  • #8
59
0
Perhaps you would be visually satisfied by a rocket discharging a payload of smoke?

Yours,
Steve
Wouldn't the rocket be pushing the smoke away from it? How long could this effect pretend to be a cloud before it dissipated?
 
  • #9
Dotini
Gold Member
621
229
Wouldn't the rocket be pushing the smoke away from it? How long could this effect pretend to be a cloud before it dissipated?
With sufficient money and time for experimentation, you might do quite well. Perhaps a large balloon carrying a large quantity of fuel for continuous combustion and discharge of smoke could make an impressive display for quite a while. The smoke particles and weather conditions will matter.

Note: launch of a rocket over one lb will require authorization, and starting a forest fire might get you jailed - so be careful!

Yours,
Steve
 
  • #10
59
0
With sufficient money and time for experimentation, you might do quite well. Perhaps a large balloon carrying a large quantity of fuel for continuous combustion and discharge of smoke could make an impressive display for quite a while. The smoke particles and weather conditions will matter.

Note: launch of a rocket over one lb will require authorization, and starting a forest fire might get you jailed - so be careful!

Yours,
Steve
Like you suggested, it would be done via balloon, so I guess no "launch" would be required. Is there any kind of chemical that is particularly good at looking... cloud like when it comes to these things? I mean I don't want a brown cloud, that would stick out like a saw thumb.
 
  • #11
Dotini
Gold Member
621
229
Pyrotechnics are not my forte, but I found this for you: http://www.pyronfo.com/pyrotechnics/the-combustion-reactions-of-a-pyrotechnic-white-smoke-composition.html [Broken]

Have fun, be safe
Steve
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #12
166
4
Kurt Vonnegut's brother is reported to have invented the method of seeding rain clouds by blasting artillery shells filled with silver nitrate (or nitrite? can't remember).

Here's my terrible and overly expensive advice for making a large cloud: find a caldera lake. Pipe significant amounts of water out of the lake and into a moat around the base of the volcano. Use irrigation methods to spread the moat over a very large area, like rice paddies.

Wait for a sunny day. Because of the engineered bacteria you released into the lake the previous day (I mentioned that, right?) produce insulating silicon detritus, The lake will reflect heat into the air above it. This hot air creates an updraft over top the volcano. Updraft will suck in air from surrounding area, which is now more moist than usual because of whole irrigation/moat setup has evaporated water into the air above it.

Moist warm air being pushed up the slope of a mountain will form a cloud if it goes high enough (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lifted_condensation_level).

Good luck!
 
  • #13
russ_watters
Mentor
19,290
5,320
Nuclear plant cooling towers can at least augment and perhaps seed or create cumulus clouds in certain conditions.
 
  • #14
59
0
I am wondering whether something as simple as cotton or spun sugar (fairy floss) could be used as substitutes if all it needed to do was fool someone 1,000 ft away?
 
  • #15
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
24,093
4,208
It's worth while to consider the amount of Energy needed to get a cloud up there. A cumulus cloud could be 1km square in area. They are generated by the Sun's energy warming up the ground, causing convection. If it takes 1 hour to warm the ground up sufficiently over an area of 106m2, to produce the cloud (I don't know how representative that time is but it can't need more than, say 10 hours), that one hour represents (106X103X3600) J (area times solar constant times time), or about 3.612J or 1GWhr which would be quite an expensive demo.
All that potentially useful energy 'going to waste', every day over the whole country.
 
  • #16
Andy Resnick
Science Advisor
Education Advisor
Insights Author
7,348
1,782
Is it possible to make a 10m^3 artificial cloud at about 1000ft in the sky?
Oh, yes. I got to watch a 60-second shuttle main engine burn test several years ago- it looks just like any other cloud, slowly rising into the sky like a giant balloon.
 
  • #17
Bobbywhy
Gold Member
1,722
48
Is it possible to make a 10m^3 artificial cloud at about 1000ft in the sky?

If yes, how real does it look? Could someone tell the difference between the artificial cloud and the natural clouds simply by looking up at the sky?
It just may be that artificial clouds could be extremely useful to save our planet from overheating!

"Experiment would test cloud geoengineering as way to slow warming"
http://www.washington.edu/news/2012/08/20/experiment-would-test-cloud-geoengineering-as-way-to-slow-warming/

"Could man-made clouds halt global warming by reflecting sunlight? Scientist calls for experiments using ships which shoot seawater into the sky"
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2191431/Could-man-clouds-halt-global-warming-reflecting-sunlight-Scientist-urges-experiments-using-ships-shoot-seawater-sky.html#ixzz24EyoiEUf
 

Related Threads for: Artificial Clouds

  • Last Post
Replies
8
Views
589
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
6K
Top