1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data I was able to come up with an answer but I am not sure if its right. I get the value of 3.668 in for diameter and my friend gets 2.117 in. I get that value because I subtracted 1500 lb from 6000lb to get my force while he used 6000lb as his Force Who is right and why? Thank you 2. Relevant equations S= F L / A E 3. The attempt at a solution First I calculated the deflection in SAB and I got 0.00189 in. then I calculate SBS I rearrange the formula to solve for A For my Force I take 1500lb and subtract 6000 At the end I get a Diameter of 3.668 in.