# Basic Set Theory Question

1. Oct 30, 2013

### isabelle york

how do I go about doing 3(a) and 3(b)?

I'm guessing that for 3(a), it is true, since we have for LHS:

P((A or B) and C)

we can consider the case P(A and C) by excluding B, and this is a subset of the RHS when we also exclude B: (P(A) and P(C)).

We can consider excluding B because it's in an OR function.

Thanks x
isabelle

#### Attached Files:

• ###### mathsprob2.png
File size:
27.6 KB
Views:
78
2. Oct 30, 2013

### Office_Shredder

Staff Emeritus
When you exclude B from the left hand side you make the left hand side smaller - So the question is asking you to show that X is a subset of Y, and you showed that W is a subset of Y where W is a smaller set than X is.

3. Oct 30, 2013

### isabelle york

I've managed to do 3(a), it is false. I used the counter example: A= a, B= b, C = a, b.

How do I do 3(b)? 3(b) is 3(a) reversed.

I'm pretty sure 3(b) is true since the RHS will always end up being 'larger', but i dont know how to go about proving it.

EDIT: ignore my reasoning in the OP, I was confused then.

Draft saved Draft deleted

Similar Threads - Basic Theory Question Date
Basic Group Theory Question Jun 6, 2014
Basic Measure Theory Question May 8, 2012
Limit problem, theory very basic question Aug 15, 2011
Basic Number theory question: Sep 23, 2010
Basic Group Theory Question Aug 5, 2008