Topology of Black Holes: Decomposing the Manifold and the Role of Knots

In summary, a black hole can be thought of topologically as a manifold, which can be decomposed. The topology of the whole space-time? The event horizon? The black hole region? The intersection of the event horizon with a space-like hypersurface?
  • #1
nateHI
146
4
Can a black hole be presented as a Heegaard decomposition or as the complement of a knot?

I'll try and elaborate: If I understand correctly, the cross section of spacetime near a black hole can be thought of topologically as a manifold. What manifold is it? Can the manifold be decomposed?
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
nateHI said:
the cross section of spacetime near a black hole

What do you mean by "cross section"?

nateHI said:
What manifold is it?

The topological manifold that describes the maximally extended Schwarzschild spacetime is ##S^2 \times R^2##. However, that spacetime is not physically reasonable. A physically reasonable spacetime that describes a black hole formed by the gravitational collapse of an ordinary object has topology ##R^4##.

These manifolds are for the entire spacetime. As above, I don't know what you mean by "cross section".
 
  • Like
Likes Orodruin
  • #3
PeterDonis said:
What do you mean by "cross section"?

I'm not sure about the physics term so maybe I should have stuck with the math. By cross section, I mean one of the boundaries of a cobordism between two 3-manifolds.
 
  • #4
nateHI said:
By cross section, I mean the boundary of a cobordism between two 3-manifolds.

AFAIK you can only have a cobordism between compact manifolds. Neither the 4-manifolds I described, nor any 3-manifold "cross sections" you could take from them, would be compact.

Also, the spacetime describing a black hole is a single manifold, not two.

It might help if you would take a step back and explain why you are interested in this.
 
  • #5
PeterDonis said:
It might help if you would take a step back and explain why you are interested in this.

I want to understand the topology of a black hole so that I can think about how (or if it's even possible) to compute its Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
nateHI said:
I want to understand the topology of a black hole so that I can think about how (or if it's even possible) to compute its Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant.

You're probably better off asking about this in the math forum. I've already given you the two relevant 4-manifolds, topologically speaking, that I know of that have anything to do with black holes: ##S^2 \times R^2## and ##R^4##. A 3-manifold cross section of these would have topology of either ##S^2 \times R## or ##R^3##. Anything beyond that would be better asked of the regulars in the math forum.
 
  • #7
Well, add the point at infinity to the real line and you are in business. I have no idea if that makes any physical sense though. The space S^2xS^1 is the complement of the unknot with no framing. The associated invariants are easy to compute. Unfortunately nothing interesting falls out as I had hoped.
 
  • #8
nateHI said:
add the point at infinity to the real line and you are in business. I have no idea if that makes any physical sense though.

It doesn't.
 
  • #9
To me it is still unclear what you mean by the black hole topology. The topology of the whole space-time? The event horizon? The black hole region? The intersection of the event horizon with a space-like hypersurface? Also do you assume that the black hole region is connected (one black hole) or not?
 
  • #10
martinbn said:
To me it is still unclear what you mean by the black hole topology.

The OP would have to say what he meant. The topologies I gave in post #2 were for the whole spacetime. In post #6 I gave possible topologies for 3-surfaces "sliced" out of the whole spacetime.

martinbn said:
do you assume that the black hole region is connected (one black hole) or not?

It depends on which spacetime you're looking at. In the maximally extended Schwarzschild spacetime, there are two "hole" regions which are disconnected; one is called the "black hole" and one is called the "white hole". But each of those regions, taken individually, is connected.

In the more realistic spacetime that describes a black hole formed by gravitational collapse, there is only one black hole region and it is connected.
 
  • #11
May guess is that he didn't mean just a Schwarzschild black hole, but was asking about black holes in general.
 
  • #12
It seems that in order to make my question less muddy I would need to study GR a bit myself first.
 
  • #13
nateHI said:
It seems that in order to make my question less muddy I would need to study GR a bit myself first.
At your shown level of mathematical sophistication, try first Wald's book then Hawking and Ellis, just for the physics part.
 

1. What is the topology of a black hole?

The topology of a black hole is a highly debated topic among scientists. Some theories suggest that the topology of a black hole is a simple spherical shape, while others propose more complex structures such as toroidal or even multi-connected topologies.

2. How is the topology of a black hole studied?

The topology of a black hole is studied through various methods, including mathematical models, simulations, and observations of black holes in space. Scientists also use gravitational waves and other astrophysical phenomena to gather information about the topology of black holes.

3. What is the significance of understanding the topology of a black hole?

Understanding the topology of a black hole is crucial for advancing our knowledge of gravity, space, and the fundamental laws of the universe. It can also provide insight into the formation and evolution of black holes and their role in the structure of the cosmos.

4. Can the topology of a black hole change?

The topology of a black hole is believed to be a stable feature that does not change over time. However, some theories suggest that under certain conditions, such as a collision with another black hole, the topology of a black hole may change.

5. How does the topology of a black hole affect its properties?

The topology of a black hole can significantly influence its physical and observable properties. For instance, the topology can affect the gravitational pull, the behavior of matter and light around the black hole, and the type of radiation emitted. Therefore, understanding the topology is crucial for comprehending the behavior and characteristics of black holes.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
4
Views
287
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
35
Views
772
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
43
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
67
Views
2K
  • Special and General Relativity
2
Replies
57
Views
1K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
8
Views
885
Replies
13
Views
534
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
34
Views
677
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
2
Views
760
Back
Top