- #1
newTonn
- 106
- 0
Dear all,
I have a simple question.
Consider a long railway station. Say 2 km’s long. Station master put two synchronized clocks at each end of the platform. These clocks are showing as well shouting the time. Synchronization of time was done by seeing the clock but not hearing the clock.
A similar third clock was fixed inside the last compartment of the train. This was also synchronized by the station master by the same way (say yesterday when the train halted at the station).
Now consider a blind man is sitting inside the last compartment. Train is crossing the station almost with a uniform speed(say,80% speed of sound).Blind man can only hear the time. When the last compartment crosses the first clock, he can hear that clock and the clock inside the train is telling same time, but the clock at the other end of the platform is telling a time in the past.
As he approaches the other clock, he can hear that clock is moving fast(telling the time faster ) and finally when he reaches the other clock, he can hear the clock inside the train and the far end clock are telling same time, but the rear clock become slower and is telling a time in the past.
As a mathematician or physics expert, what you will do?
You will make appropriate corrections to the normal formula, incorporating the speed of train, speed of sound and the position of blind man at that instance.
But what the blind man will think if he doesn't know this explanation.He will of course deduce that the law's of physics are violated and the clocks will move faster when you approaches it and will move slower when you receedes from it.
If we establish the position of the observer at the instance,and incorporate the data to result,you can see that No fundamental laws are violated even in the case of of an accelerated frame.
Somebody please tell me with a simple example,how the fundamental laws are violated in an accelerated frame
I have a simple question.
Consider a long railway station. Say 2 km’s long. Station master put two synchronized clocks at each end of the platform. These clocks are showing as well shouting the time. Synchronization of time was done by seeing the clock but not hearing the clock.
A similar third clock was fixed inside the last compartment of the train. This was also synchronized by the station master by the same way (say yesterday when the train halted at the station).
Now consider a blind man is sitting inside the last compartment. Train is crossing the station almost with a uniform speed(say,80% speed of sound).Blind man can only hear the time. When the last compartment crosses the first clock, he can hear that clock and the clock inside the train is telling same time, but the clock at the other end of the platform is telling a time in the past.
As he approaches the other clock, he can hear that clock is moving fast(telling the time faster ) and finally when he reaches the other clock, he can hear the clock inside the train and the far end clock are telling same time, but the rear clock become slower and is telling a time in the past.
As a mathematician or physics expert, what you will do?
You will make appropriate corrections to the normal formula, incorporating the speed of train, speed of sound and the position of blind man at that instance.
But what the blind man will think if he doesn't know this explanation.He will of course deduce that the law's of physics are violated and the clocks will move faster when you approaches it and will move slower when you receedes from it.
If we establish the position of the observer at the instance,and incorporate the data to result,you can see that No fundamental laws are violated even in the case of of an accelerated frame.
Somebody please tell me with a simple example,how the fundamental laws are violated in an accelerated frame