Bottle on paper

1. Jan 5, 2016

Sonntag

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
There is an empty bottle described as an hollow cylinder, that lies on a paper. Now the paper is pulled with an acceleration a, so that the bottle starts rolling perfectly on the paper. (Have a look at the figure.)

2. Relevant equations
Calculate the acceleration of the center of mass.

3. The attempt at a solution
Moment of inertia in the center of mass: ${I_C = 1/2 M R^2}$
Moment of inertia in the center of mass on the surface: ${I_S = 3/2 M R^2}$
Torque: ${|\bf{M}| = |\bf{R}| |\bf{F}|}$
Angular acceleration: ${\alpha = \dfrac{M}{I_S} = \dfrac{F}{3/2 M R}}$
acceleration of the center of mass: ${a_s = \alpha R = 2/3 \dfrac{F}{M}}$

I have the feeling that my answer isn't the intended of the question. Mistakes? More to do? I hope on your answers and thoughts.

File size:
6.3 KB
Views:
34
2. Jan 5, 2016

Staff: Mentor

Hint: Look at things from the (non-inertial) frame of the paper. (Note also that it's a hollow cylinder, so correct your formula for moment of inertia.)

3. Jan 5, 2016

haruspex

I don't understand the expression "Moment of inertia in the center of mass on the surface"
i assume you mean
Moment of inertia about the center of mass: ${I_C = 1/2 M R^2}$
Moment of inertia about a point on the surface: ${I_S = 3/2 M R^2}$​
That would be true, as Doc Al points out, for a solid cylinder. But leaving that aside, your method still gave the wrong answer. The reason is that your expression for torque gives the torque about the mass centre. You cannot divide the torque about one axis by the MoI about a different axis to get the angular acceleration.
You can use Doc Al's method, or just be consistent about axes.