Calculating the current

Homework Statement

Through a fluorescent tube of a diameter of 3cm cross the transversal secion per second 2x10^18 electrons and 0.5x10^18 positive ions (with charge +e) What is the current that goes through the tube?

I=Vd*n*e*A

The Attempt at a Solution

I have Vd*n for the electrons that is 2x10^18
I have Vd*n for the electrons that is 0.5x10^18
I calculate the area as 2pi(3/2)^2
And I have the charge of an electron
I know that talking about current you don't have to make a distinction between positive and negative charges, but that's theroy. In practice I don't know whether to add the current generated by the positive charges with the other one, to substract them, or what?
How am I supposed to proceed in this cases?

Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org
Conventionally, the flow of current is the flow of positive charges. If you have negative charges flowing against them then, of course, you will need to subtract to get the net current. Try drawing a quick diagram to see if that helps your understanding.

Ok. But no, that's wrong. You have to take the absolute value of the charge, so both currents will add. At least that's what Sears and Semansky say.

Defennder
Homework Helper
Are you sure that's what they say? If the electrons are flowing in the same direction as the positive ions, then some of it will cancel out.

Redbelly98
Staff Emeritus
Homework Helper
In an electrical discharge like this, the electric field will cause the positive and negative charges to flow in opposite directions. So add the currents, don't subtract them.

What? Are you sure? That doesn't make any sense.

$$I=\int \mathbf{J} \cdot d\mathbf{a}$$

and

$$\mathbf{J} = \rho \mathbf{v}$$

The current densities will create two currents that we can, more or less, think of as vectors. Vectors add, sure, but one of them is negative.

I don't even want to think about the electric field because SR will make it a mess. I could be convinced otherwise, but it just doesn't seem right.

Defennder
Homework Helper
I think he meant to say was that because although you have 2 charge carriers, electrons and positive ions, the presence of an electric field in one direction only will cause their respective current contributions to add up. My earlier post was directed at #3 which wasn't a clear explanation.

Redbelly98
Staff Emeritus