Can I get some help with my investigation?

In summary: You should try using the simplified form of Newton's Second Law of Motion. It's a little more complicated, but it will give you a more accurate value for g. You can also use the Kater's Pendulum to get an even more accurate value for g.In summary, this is an investigation of gravity and the various methods that can be used to calculate it. The user is trying to find a more accurate equation to combine with gravity, and is also looking for a Kater's Pendulum to complete their project.
  • #1
aragonaut
1
0
Fist off, this isn't homework, so...

I'm doing an investigation, calculating gravity, and I have 2 experiments ready, with everything accounted for. However, I do not know some variables for my other 2 experiments.

1. Ball on a Slope.

I am rolling a ball on a slope through 2 light gates, and calculating the final velocity and time it took for the ball to pass through. However, I understand how friction would be a factor, and so I tried to derive an equation that combined gravity with friction, but I couldn't get one that worked.

Could anybody help?2. Secondly, I wanted to use a Kater's Pendulum, but I can't find any experiments that I could do using one online, and I have no idea how it works. I was just told by my teacher that it is the most accurate method.

Thank you for any help you provide!

aragonaut

Edit:

I am doing an SQA Advanced Higher

I am rolling it down a slope, because it is a part of my required investigation; I need to use it as an integral part (The introduction.) I need to have an investigation that isn't very accurate, as to provide something for my discussion section to reflect on.

Secondly, I have got a Simple Pendulum and a Compound Pendulum already, and I need a Kater's Pendulum Experiment.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Hi and welcome to PF

I do not know what your level of Physics is but, assuming it is not too advanced:

1. Is there a reason for preferring a ball rolling down a slope to a ball simply falling between two light gates? A slope will involve friction but air friction at low speeds can be neglected.
2. A simple pendulum (mass on steel wire) will give a pretty good value for g if you eliminate draughts and the temperature does not vary the length of the wire. Before you use Kater's method, you should be in a position to understand it; I think your teacher should have avoided telling you about it unless he / she knew you could cope with the Maths and be fully conversant with Moment of Inertia.

Once you have obtained results by the above simple methods then you could progress further. But, the way college and school projects go, you will probably find that the allocated time would be taken up with the simple versions.
 
Last edited:
  • #3
If the ball falls rather than rolls you also eliminate any issue with the moment of inertia of the ball.
 
  • #4
You can account for the moment of inertia of the ball. It's more complicated, but not too much more. There's a frictional force pointing uphill which is just strong enough to enforce the no-slip condition.
 
  • #5
aragonaut said:
Fist off, this isn't homework, so...

I'm doing an investigation, calculating gravity, and I have 2 experiments ready, with everything accounted for. However, I do not know some variables for my other 2 experiments.

1. Ball on a Slope.

I am rolling a ball on a slope through 2 light gates, and calculating the final velocity and time it took for the ball to pass through. However, I understand how friction would be a factor, and so I tried to derive an equation that combined gravity with friction, but I couldn't get one that worked.

Could anybody help?


2. Secondly, I wanted to use a Kater's Pendulum, but I can't find any experiments that I could do using one online, and I have no idea how it works. I was just told by my teacher that it is the most accurate method.

Thank you for any help you provide!

aragonaut

Edit:

I am doing an SQA Advanced Higher

I am rolling it down a slope, because it is a part of my required investigation; I need to use it as an integral part (The introduction.) I need to have an investigation that isn't very accurate, as to provide something for my discussion section to reflect on.

Secondly, I have got a Simple Pendulum and a Compound Pendulum already, and I need a Kater's Pendulum Experiment.

Welcome to the PF. I've moved your thread to the Homework Help forums, where all posts about schoolwork belong. :smile:

Now, what equations are you using in these experiments to calculate the acceleration of gravity? Finding those equations is part of your project, and we need you to show the effort of finding those equations.
 

1. Can you provide me with any resources or tools for my investigation?

Yes, as a scientist, I have access to various resources and tools that could assist you with your investigation. This could include databases, equipment, or specialized software. Let me know what you specifically need and I can point you in the right direction.

2. How can I ensure the accuracy and validity of my investigation?

To ensure accuracy and validity, it's important to follow the scientific method. This includes identifying a clear research question, conducting thorough research, designing a proper methodology, collecting and analyzing data, and drawing conclusions based on evidence. It's also important to properly document and report your findings.

3. Can you review my methods and data for any potential errors?

Yes, I would be happy to review your methods and data for any potential errors. As scientists, rigorous review and replication of experiments is crucial in ensuring the validity of our findings. I can offer constructive feedback and suggestions to help improve your investigation.

4. How do I handle unexpected or conflicting results in my investigation?

In science, unexpected or conflicting results are common and can often lead to new discoveries. It's important to carefully analyze and consider possible explanations for these results. You may need to revise your methods or conduct further research. It's also important to be transparent and report all results, including unexpected ones, in your findings.

5. Can you help me with statistical analysis for my investigation?

Yes, I am knowledgeable in statistical analysis and can assist you with analyzing your data. It's important to choose the appropriate statistical tests based on your research question and type of data. I can help you interpret the results and determine if they are statistically significant.

Similar threads

  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
499
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
22
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
685
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
192
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
7
Views
409
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
22
Views
2K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
30
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
788
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
13
Views
1K
Back
Top