Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conductor?

  1. Dec 25, 2009 #1
    In my experience, seems you can't get something for nothing (or little) but was just curious. What is the difference in conventional generator power and power generated simply by passing a conductor through a stationary magnetic field.
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Dec 25, 2009 #2

    OmCheeto

    User Avatar
    Gold Member
    2016 Award

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    There is no difference.
     
  4. Dec 25, 2009 #3
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    If less resistance is required if the magnetic fields do not interact why don't conventional generators use this setup?
     
  5. Dec 25, 2009 #4

    OmCheeto

    User Avatar
    Gold Member
    2016 Award

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Conventional often implies that it is cheaper to do it that way.
     
  6. Dec 25, 2009 #5
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    How can it be cheaper to generate electricity when more resistance is encountered with conventional setups? Maybe has something to do with size and/or magnetic density?
     
    Last edited: Dec 25, 2009
  7. Dec 25, 2009 #6

    uart

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Because it's not true. You just made that up and have presented no evidence as to why it's true. You are working under a false assumption.
     
  8. Dec 25, 2009 #7

    OmCheeto

    User Avatar
    Gold Member
    2016 Award

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    I do not understand your question.

    Are you submitting your questions through a language translator? The syntax of your questions seem to not conform to the standards of the English language as I have been taught.

    Where are you from?

    hmmm..... Are you a friend of the Devil's Avacado?

     
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 24, 2017
  9. Dec 25, 2009 #8
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Review the theory of homopolar generators. See
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homopolar_generator
    Look in particular at the photograph of the flywheel in the 500 MJ homopolar generator (color) picture, which rotated in a stationary magnetic field. This generator ran successfully for a few years at the Australian National University. Thie difference is that the homopolar generator works on the Lorentz force principle, while conventional generators run on the Faraday Induction Law principle. See also
    http://www.animations.physics.unsw.edu.au/jw/homopolar.htm
    Bob S
     
  10. Dec 25, 2009 #9
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Evidently, I'm not a friend of DA, but I will rework my original question to see if I can make myself clearer. If I'm not mistaken, when conventional generators are turned faster, more resistance is encountered due to the design that creates interaction in the internal magnetic fields. In the other design I was referring to, two or more pairs of magnets are placed in close proximity and conductors are then passed through the gap between the magnets, thus creating a current. Also, as I understand el gen theory, the more conductors that pass per given unit of time, the more current is generated. Since the magnets in this case are stationary in reference to each and the conductors are not magnetic there should not be and increase in resistance in reference to an increase in the speed of the passing conductors. Sorry for the misunderstanding. RS
     
  11. Dec 25, 2009 #10
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Take a look at Faradays Law. You are referring to an Axial Flux design. Two rotors of magnets rotating around a stator of coils. The answer is yes. The problem lies in generating the power to spin it. The real question is what ammount is "usefull"? Home made axial flux designs are CAPAPABLE of 1000W. That is at MAX RPM. The entire principle of electricity generation involves moving magnets around a coil or vice versa. It IS how electricity is produced. Nuclear, Coal, Hydro, wind. All are forms of creating the power to move one of the objects around the other. What resistance are you referring to? Internal reisitance of the wire? Resistance of rotation? Also keeping the magnets stationary in this design creates more work, and also adds losses due to commutators.
     
    Last edited: Dec 25, 2009
  12. Dec 25, 2009 #11
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Thanks, You got it! RS
     
  13. Dec 25, 2009 #12
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Your question about what resistance, in conventional generators and alternators, there is a design inherent that creates more resistance to turning with increase in speed due to interaction of internal magnet fields which increase the power output. With the other design I refer to, seems the only limitation to power output would be structural design limitations and size limitations. Bearing friction, air flow restricion, etc. should be minimal.
     
  14. Dec 26, 2009 #13

    uart

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Complete nonsense.

    Yeah I think that's the aspect of the discussion that you should really be concentrating on right now.
     
  15. Dec 26, 2009 #14
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Its not complete nonsense. With the design in question, low RPM is used. Yes, The generated current does create its own field around the wire, and when a magnet approaches that is of opposite polarity, it does encounter resistance. This unfortunately is the draw back to power generation. This is about all I know about this aspect. Check out some graphs of generator output vs RPM. Most will rise, level out, and then degrate. The degration I believe is due to this. (amongst other things)
     
  16. Dec 27, 2009 #15
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    This sounds like the engine in my car; the horsepower rises to about 5500 RPM, then "degrates". Have you ever heard of back emf?
    Bob S
     
  17. Dec 27, 2009 #16
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    My background is Electrical Engineering. I am uncertain if these two things are related, but I am assuming that the mechnical forces at work in an engine play a much larger role as to reversing the direction of a piston at high rpm. Interesting to see if the "stregnth" of the fields in the axial flux can compare linearly to the degration of the engine HP??
     
  18. Dec 28, 2009 #17

    vk6kro

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conductor?

    My local power station has been moving wires through a stationary magnetic field for as long as I can remember. It works just as well as moving a magnetic field past a stationary wire.
    Both methods generate a voltage across the wire.

    If people turn on their big-screen TVs then the generator gets harder to turn so they have to provide more power by pressing the accellerator pedal on the driving engine a little more. This uses more diesel, so the extra power comes at a price.

    As you say, you can't get something for nothing. Whichever way you generate power, as soon as the current starts to flow, you have to supply mechanical power to get electrical power out and also to overcome friction losses etc in the generating equipment.
     
    Last edited: Dec 28, 2009
  19. Dec 28, 2009 #18
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc



    Thanks guys for the helpful info. Follow up questions:Do you know any significant factors that would adversely affect grid tie in with the homopolar design?Advantages/disadvantages of a dc compared to ac homopolar design. As far as the other question at hand, having done a lot of mechanical work on engines, I believe the power curve in int. comb. engines has to do with inherent limitations of the fuel delivery sys. and the configuration of the intake, combustion chamber, exhaust, airflow through the system, each design favoring peak, etc. at different points. Electrical I imagine is basically the same in that each design has different inherent limitations in the various components. Please continue. I am still interested in persuing the differences in the "back pressures" encountered by a generator when more load is applied. Would this be the same in homopolar V conventional? I realize that homopolar design is not front and center in current study, so if it's too much research for the time you have, I understand. It's not life and death that I figure this out.
    Referring back to a prior response, the picture is getting clearer, I didn't know about the field created around a conductor so that explains a lot esp. resistance to load. ...RS
     
    Last edited: Dec 28, 2009
  20. Dec 29, 2009 #19
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Homopolar generators are for very high current (meg-amp) unipolar pulses .They cannot generate ac power (50 Hz, 60 Hz). I don't know how the current could be regulated. Normal generators (alternators etc.) have feedback loops. I have heard that homopolar generators are dangerous to use; someone was blinded while using liquid sodium jets to make low-resistance electrical contact with the rim of the flywheel.
    Bob S
     
  21. Dec 29, 2009 #20
    Re: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conduc

    Bob,
    Thanks for the concern, you're a real sweetheart. Don't worry I'm not gay. Not that I have anything against them. "To each it's own, it's all unknown, if dogs run free"...Bob Dylan. Anyway, I had the same thoughts regarding the homopolar design in that if the current generated was not being bled off somehow, I could see how a large charge could be built up and would eventually find ground (equilibrium). I thought that the homopolar design might have potential in low tech home grown power generation, but the more I find out about it, the more it seem prudent to let the more high tech folks pursue this technology. Looks like Parker Kinetic Design is hard at work on something to do with it. Unfortunately, it seems their line of research has to do with war machinery. My original line of thought was to find something that second,third, or maybe even first world could use to generate inexpensive, low tech elect. power. Maybe even using man or beast of burden as source of input power.
    Pipe dream probably, but sometimes the diamonds get left lying in the sand. Thanks again.

    ...RS
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook




Similar Discussions: Can you generate useful power with just stationary magnets and moving wire conductor?
Loading...