- #1
ƒ(x)
- 328
- 0
People I know seem fairly polarized between whether or not it's acceptable to celebrate bin Laden's death. Any thoughts?
I see it as a means of closure for thousands of grieving families, and a significant blow to the realm of terror he started.ƒ(x) said:People I know seem fairly polarized between whether or not it's acceptable to celebrate bin Laden's death. Any thoughts?
ƒ(x) said:People I know seem fairly polarized between whether or not it's acceptable to celebrate bin Laden's death. Any thoughts?
lisab said:It's been a tough decade. Seemingly endless wars, draining our spirit and blowing up the deficit. Still almost 10% unemployment, stagnant wages.
chiro said:killed many hundreds of thousands of people
I had heard speculative reports in the past, but this is the first time our president has DNA evidence from his body in military possession. It's about as reliable as can be.AlephZero said:In any case, isn't this the third time the US have told the world they killed OBL?
JaredJames said:Is it really that high?
jobyts said:Unfortunately, yes. It is very high.
A year 2008 article in Guardian estimates the number of deaths in Iraq is in between 100,000 and 1 million.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2008/mar/19/iraq
JaredJames said:I'm just happy justice is served. I couldn't care whether he was alive or dead. Either way, we got him.
DanP said:The US Navy got him, not "we". Give credit where credit is due.
AlephZero said:The chanting flag wavers in the US only goes to show that the mentality of gun law and the lynch mob is still alive and kicking...
rootX said:On morality grounds, we can argue forever in circles and still not reach anywhere. Nonetheless from my personal perspective, I would not cherish anyone's death. I would be happy about consequences resulting from the death if there are some positive consequences.
Only thing I really felt really sad about was that Osama was killed in front of his 13 years old daughter.
ryan_m_b said:Celebrating the death of a guy
physics girl phd said:But I'll add that I do also feel upset that people "celebrated" in front off the Capital, etc. That kind of behavior fuels embers of hatred.
ƒ(x) said:People I know seem fairly polarized between whether or not it's acceptable to celebrate bin Laden's death. Any thoughts?
micromass said:Personally, I'm quite sad that he died. Don't get me wrong, he was an extremely evil man, but I value life too much to wish death to anybody. Also, I would think justice would be better served if we actually brought him to trial, where he had to answer for his crimes. Killing him was the easy way out, and now people in the middle-east can begin worshipping him as martyr...
micromass said:Personally, I'm quite sad that he died.
ryan_m_b said:I agree. I would much rather see justice dispensed by a judge than a soldier. However if there was no other way then there was no other way
cobalt124 said:I understand this sentiment, but OBL put himself in this position. His actions had consequences (justified IMO). Taking him alive would have been a much more dangerous operation IMO, and I don't see how any criticism can be levelled at the U.S. for the way the operation was carried out (I'm not sayng you are being critical bere, that is more aimed at what I have been reading in general.
ryan_m_b said:Exactly. If it was possible for his capture but they went for the kill I would be far more critical.
hypatia said:I think it is sad when anyone dies.
There are several ethical implications to consider when discussing the celebration of Bin Laden's death. Some may argue that celebrating the death of any individual goes against moral values and human decency. Others may argue that Bin Laden's actions and involvement in terrorism justify the celebration. It is important to consider the impact of celebrating violence and death on society and the message it sends to others.
This is a complex and subjective question. Some may argue that celebrating the death of someone who caused harm and suffering is justified, while others may believe that celebrating any death goes against moral values. It is important to consider the impact of celebrating violence and death on society and the message it sends to others.
Celebrating Bin Laden's death may have several consequences. It could lead to further acts of violence and retaliation from those who support him or his cause. It could also perpetuate a cycle of violence and revenge. Additionally, celebrating death may desensitize individuals to violence and dehumanize the person who was killed.
The celebration of Bin Laden's death may have both positive and negative impacts on global relations. It could potentially bring a sense of closure and justice to those who were affected by his actions. However, it may also create tensions and resentment among those who view the celebration as disrespectful or unjustified. It is important to consider the potential impact on diplomatic relationships and international perceptions.
Instead of celebrating Bin Laden's death, some may choose to reflect on the impact of his actions and the lives lost as a result. Others may choose to focus on promoting peace and understanding, rather than perpetuating a cycle of violence. Some may also choose to advocate for justice through legal and political means. Ultimately, the way individuals react to Bin Laden's death may vary and should be respected as a personal choice.