Center of a black hole.

  • Thread starter cragar
  • Start date
2,538
1
if u were at the center of a black hole which way would the gravity pull u. if it pulled u at all.
what do u guys think.

Another question is temperature relative . like if i had something on earth near absolute zero
but relative to the sun its kinetic energy would be different.
And how do scientist's know were absolute zero is if they can't get to it how do they know its not further than they think.
 

HallsofIvy

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
41,682
864
If you are at the center of a uniform sphere of any density, the net gravitational force on you would be 0. That is because the force due to the mass in any direction is cancelled by equal force in exactly the opposite direction.

As far as absolute 0 is concerned, it is not to difficult to measure the volume of a fixed amount of gas at two different temperatures (at the same pressure), determine the linear function (PV= NRT) giving those two points and then solve for the T that makes V= 0.
 
2,538
1
so then would u be weightless.
 

fluidistic

Gold Member
3,605
90
so then would u be weightless.
Not really. If you could keep your body's proportions and that the black hole is larger than your body, the center of the black hole if it has a center is inside your body, then only one millimeter apart from the center of the black hole would be attracted toward the center of the black hole. It is of course a totally impossible scenario.
 
2,538
1
y is this an impossible scenario , what if a photon was at the center.
 

Danger

Gold Member
9,564
244
Since no matter can actually exist at the singularity, the question is irrelevant. For any living organism, the tidal forces alone would rip it to shreds long before contact with the centre.

edit: Oops, Cragar... I just realized that this might have been taken as a response to your last post. Not so; it was aimed at the original.
 

fluidistic

Gold Member
3,605
90
y is this an impossible scenario , what if a photon was at the center.
I was talking about a human into a black hole. I don't know enough Physics :frown: to answer your question, but I know that a human wouldn't survive, wouldn't conserve its proportions and I believe a black hole is smaller than a human body, but I'm not sure of the later.
 
2,538
1
they have super massive black holes that are like 10^6 times bigger than our sun.

can a photon exist at the singularity?
And how would time behave at the singularity taking gravitational time dialtion into effect
 
Last edited:
they have super massive black holes that are like 10^6 times bigger than our sun.
Careful.

They are 10^6 times more massive than our sun.
 
2,538
1
but certainly large enough for a photon to be in the center.
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,148
1,723
Simply put, the laws of physics as we know them break down at the singularity. We do not know what happens there. This is the only meaningful answer to your question.
 
2,538
1
ok thanks for your answer
 
740
39
cragar, you might want to take a look at rotating black holes.
 
23
0
I believe a black hole is smaller than a human body, but I'm not sure of the later.
You mean a black hole or the singularity? A black hole: the more mass it has, the more space it takes up (I think you mean how much space it takes up). For example, a black hole with the mass of our sun would be about 2 miles in radius. A typical black hole has a ten solar mass, and therefore a radius of about 12.5 miles. A million solar mass black hole (like at the center of a galaxy) would have a radius of 2,000,000 miles.

A singularity: Technically, the size of a singularity is zero, according to classical physics. It is just a point, and the laws of physics end at the event horizon. Our physics stop working when you get down to a certain length (Planck length). There is no way of knowing.
 

DaveC426913

Gold Member
18,148
1,723
You mean a black hole or the singularity? A black hole: the more mass it has, the more space it takes up (I think you mean how much space it takes up). For example, a black hole with the mass of our sun would be about 2 miles in radius. A typical black hole has a ten solar mass, and therefore a radius of about 12.5 miles. A million solar mass black hole (like at the center of a galaxy) would have a radius of 2,000,000 miles.
For further clarification: This dimension refers to the event horizon, which is merely an abstract value representing the distance from the black hole - closer than which light cannot escape.

There is no physical object that delineates this boundary.
 
1,986
5
if u were at the center of a black hole which way would the gravity pull u. if it pulled u at all.
what do u guys think.

Another question is temperature relative . like if i had something on earth near absolute zero
but relative to the sun its kinetic energy would be different.
And how do scientist's know were absolute zero is if they can't get to it how do they know its not further than they think.
A black hole has no center.
 
172
0
Just wondering: is the singularity black, when seen inside event horizon?

Does the "light cannot escape" apply only to event horizon (light from inside cannot cross the event horizon), but inside event horizon of a giant black hole we could actually see the singularity?
 
It does. All you need to have a center of mass is mass.

If you are a singularity, your center of mass (a point) is "co-pointal" with you.
 

George Jones

Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Gold Member
7,205
750
Just wondering: is the singularity black, when seen inside event horizon?
Images that we see are from the past. For example, we the Sun as it was 8 minutes ago. The singularity of a spherical black hole is in the future, so we don't an image of it.
 
778
2
Images that we see are from the past. For example, we the Sun as it was 8 minutes ago. The singularity of a spherical black hole is in the future, so we don't an image of it.
All the current work on black-hole singularities makes that idea of space being rotated into a time direction seem dubious. According to work by Igor Novikov the inner singularity, after it has formed and settled down, should be traversable with a finite impulse from the tidal forces. Even though the strength of the tide goes to infinity, the total energy a body experiences from it is probably finite. A big enough black-hole's singularity might even be survivable by a human.
 

Chronos

Science Advisor
Gold Member
11,398
734
The center of a black hole is a singularity, your body is not a singularity. The spagetti left from your transit throught the event horizon would be crushed out of existence.
 
778
2
The center of a black hole is a singularity, your body is not a singularity. The spagetti left from your transit throught the event horizon would be crushed out of existence.
As I've noted, depends on the singularity and just how its tidal forces change with radial distance.
 
1,986
5
All the current work on black-hole singularities makes that idea of space being rotated into a time direction seem dubious. According to work by Igor Novikov the inner singularity, after it has formed and settled down, should be traversable with a finite impulse from the tidal forces. Even though the strength of the tide goes to infinity, the total energy a body experiences from it is probably finite. A big enough black-hole's singularity might even be survivable by a human.
It must be me, but this sounds like complete hogwash to me.
 
All the current work on black-hole singularities makes that idea of space being rotated into a time direction seem dubious. According to work by Igor Novikov the inner singularity, after it has formed and settled down, should be traversable with a finite impulse from the tidal forces. Even though the strength of the tide goes to infinity, the total energy a body experiences from it is probably finite. A big enough black-hole's singularity might even be survivable by a human.
Anything that gets close to the singularity of a black hole is instantly torn appart beyond recognition.
 

Related Threads for: Center of a black hole.

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top