Solve Clairaut's Theorem: Proving (dT/dV)S & (dS/dV)T

  • Thread starter Miriverite
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Theorem
In summary, using Clairaut's theorem, we can prove that (dT/dV)S = -(dP/dS)V and (dS/dV)T = (dP/dT)V, which were given as equations to prove from the given dU = TdS - PdV equation. By differentiating both sides of the equations, we can show that they are equivalent.
  • #1
Miriverite
6
0

Homework Statement


Given dU = TdS - PdV, prove that:
1. (dT/dV)S = -(dP/dS)V
2. (dS/dV)T = (dP/dT)V

Homework Equations


Clairaut's states that d^2U/dXdY = d^2U/dYdX is true, or in my case:
[d/dX (dU/dY)X ]Y = [d/dY (dU/dX)Y ]X

The Attempt at a Solution


1. (dU/dS)V = T(S,V) and (dU/dV)S = -P(T,V)
so [d/dS (dU/dV)S]V = [d/dV (dU/dS)V]S
and that means [-P(S,V)/dS]V = [T(S,V)/dV]S
and thus, if we differentiate again (-dP/dS)V = (dT/dV)S

2. [d/dT (dU/dV)T]V = [d/dV (dU/dT)V]T
(dU/dV)T = -P(S,V) and (dU/dT)V = dS(T) (unsure of this)
so that means [-P(S,V)/dT]V = [dS(t)/dV)]T
This is where I get stuck, because there's a dS on the right hand side, but it's only P on the left hand, not dP. Am I missing an important step here?

Obviously we need to get the equation for dU into a form that depends not on S and V, but something that depends on T and V. I don't know how to do this, though..
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


First, let's rewrite the given equation as:
dU = TdS - PdV = T(S,V)dS - P(S,V)dV

1. From the given equation, we have:
(dU/dS)V = T(S,V)
(dU/dV)S = -P(S,V)

Using Clairaut's theorem, we get:
[d/dS (dU/dV)S]V = [d/dV (dU/dS)V]S
Simplifying, we get:
[-P(S,V)/dS]V = [T(S,V)/dV]S

Now, we differentiate both sides with respect to V:
[-dP/dS]V = (dT/dV)S

2. From the given equation, we have:
(dU/dT)V = S(T,V) (Note: this should be S(T,V) instead of dS(T))
(dU/dV)T = -P(T,V)

Using Clairaut's theorem, we get:
[d/dT (dU/dV)T]V = [d/dV (dU/dT)V]T
Simplifying, we get:
[-P(T,V)/dT]V = [S(T,V)/dV]T

Now, we differentiate both sides with respect to V:
[-dP/dT]V = (dS/dV)T

Hence, we have proved the given equations.
 

1. What is Clairaut's Theorem?

Clairaut's Theorem is a mathematical rule that states that the mixed partial derivatives of a function are equal, regardless of the order of differentiation. In other words, the order in which you take the partial derivatives of a function does not affect the result.

2. How do you prove (dT/dV)S & (dS/dV)T using Clairaut's Theorem?

To prove (dT/dV)S & (dS/dV)T using Clairaut's Theorem, you can start by taking the partial derivatives of the function in both orders. Then, you can equate the two resulting expressions and solve for the variables. If the two expressions are equal, you have proven the theorem.

3. What is the significance of proving (dT/dV)S & (dS/dV)T using Clairaut's Theorem?

Proving (dT/dV)S & (dS/dV)T using Clairaut's Theorem is important because it allows us to simplify complex mathematical problems by reducing the number of partial derivatives that need to be calculated. It also helps us to better understand the relationships between different variables in a function.

4. Can Clairaut's Theorem be used in other fields besides mathematics?

Yes, Clairaut's Theorem can be applied in various fields such as physics, engineering, and economics. It is a fundamental principle in calculus and can be used to solve a wide range of problems involving multiple variables.

5. Are there any limitations or exceptions to Clairaut's Theorem?

While Clairaut's Theorem is a powerful tool, it does have some limitations and exceptions. For example, it may not hold true for discontinuous functions or functions with singularities. Additionally, it may not apply to functions with constraints or boundary conditions. It is important to understand the assumptions and conditions under which Clairaut's Theorem can be applied.

Similar threads

  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
21
Views
1K
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
258
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
1K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
874
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
12
Views
991
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
686
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
640
  • Calculus and Beyond Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
Back
Top