- #1
koolraj09
- 167
- 5
Hi Guys,
What does the term Closed form solution mean?
What does the term Closed form solution mean?
The roots of the quintic equation can be expressed on closed form, thanks to the theta functions which are related to the Jacobi elliptic functions. (Very arduous)what would be a closed form of the roots of x^5 - x + 1 = 0 ?
But this illustrates one of the difficulties in answering the question. The phrase "closed-form expression" is ambiguous -- it depends on what you define as allowable elementary functions. I mean, if I'm allowed to define new functions, I can express anything in closed form -- I just define a function whose value is the solution to my problem. This sounds like cheating, but that's basically where most of our more recondite special functions come from: elliptic functions, Bessel function, Hypergeometric functions, etc. There was no closed-form expression to the problem so some old 19th century German said, "I hereby define this function to be the solution." And presto! the problem had a closed-form solution.JJacquelin said:The roots of the quintic equation can be expressed on closed form, thanks to the theta functions which are related to the Jacobi elliptic functions. (Very arduous)
http://mathworld.wolfram.com/QuinticEquation.html
I agree, but even if this way to see things is correct it is still incomplete. Of course, it should be too easy to define a new special function as the solution of a problem and then, to say : The problem as a solution which is expressed thanks to the new special function !But this illustrates one of the difficulties in answering the question. The phrase "closed-form expression" is ambiguous -- it depends on what you define as allowable elementary functions. I mean, if I'm allowed to define new functions, I can express anything in closed form -- I just define a function whose value is the solution to my problem. This sounds like cheating, but that's basically where most of our more recondite special functions come from: elliptic functions, Bessel function, Hypergeometric functions, etc. There was no closed-form expression to the problem so some old 19th century German said, "I hereby define this function to be the solution." And presto! the problem had a closed-form solution.
Yes -- I was exaggerating a bit for effect. Actually, elliptic functions are an interesting case, because, although it is true that Jacobi developed them essentially as I described, as an easy-out function to solve a particular class of problems, they're more broadly applicable. I doubt he was thinking of solving quintics.JJacquelin said:I agree, but even if this way to see things is correct it is still incomplete.
A closed form solution is a mathematical expression that can be written in a finite number of standard mathematical operations, such as addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, exponentiation, and roots. It is also known as an explicit solution or analytical solution.
A numerical solution is an approximation of the actual solution, while a closed form solution provides an exact, algebraic expression for the solution. Numerical solutions are often used when a closed form solution is not possible or is too complex to obtain.
Some common examples of problems that have closed form solutions include linear equations, quadratic equations, geometric series, and simple differential equations. These types of problems have explicit formulas that can be used to solve for the unknown variable.
Yes, there are some limitations to using closed form solutions. They may not exist for certain types of problems, such as nonlinear equations or complex systems. Additionally, closed form solutions may not be practical or efficient for problems with a large number of variables.
Closed form solutions are beneficial to scientists because they provide a clear and concise expression for the solution to a problem. This allows for a deeper understanding of the problem and can aid in making predictions and analyzing data. Closed form solutions are also useful for verifying the accuracy of numerical solutions.