Collision of a moving proton into a proton at rest (relativity)

  • #1

Homework Statement


A high speed proton collides with a proton at rest, two proton-antiproton pairs were created. That is some of the accelerated protons kinetic energy was enough to be converted into the mass of the new particles. If the proton-antiproton pairs move along together as a single particle of rest mass M=4m show that hte kinetic energy of the accelerated proton before collision is:

K=6mc2


Homework Equations



relativistic momentum: p=gamma(mv)
Relativistic kinetic energy: K=(gamma-1)mc2
energy as a function of momemtum: E2=(pc)2 + (mc2)2


The Attempt at a Solution


Heres my train of thought....So the kinetic energy of the moving proton must equal the mass energy of 2 additional particles in the product of the collision but those products ( the proton antiproton pairs) are also moving so thats additional kinetic energy. The reactancts have a mass of 2m and the products have a mass of 4m. The total momemtum must be the same since its conserved.

I tried figuring out the speed of the intital moving proton and the speed of the blob of 4 particles and got :

4u2 + v2=3c2

where u is the velocity of the proton and the v is the velocity of the 4 particle blob.

Then Iam not sure to procede from there. I am assuming that all the mass of the proton at rest was converted into energy but it doesnt really state that. It just seems wierd because the intital proton can moving at any speed greater than the least amount of speed required to create 4 particles that are moving...if that makes sense since it says that SOME of the accelerated protons kinetic energy was converted.

Thank you for your precious time.
 
Last edited:

Answers and Replies

  • #2
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831

Homework Statement


A high speed proton collides with a proton at rest, two proton-antiproton pairs were created. That is some of the accelerated protons kinetic energy was enough to be converted into the mass of the new particles. If the proton-antiproton pairs move along together as a single particle of rest mass M=4m show that hte kinetic energy of the accelerated proton before collision is:

K=6mc2
This actually can't happen because you have a total charge of +2 before the collision and a total charge of 0 after the collision. A proton-antiproton collision would work, though.
Here's my train of thought....So the kinetic energy of the moving proton must equal the mass energy of 2 additional particles in the product of the collision but those products ( the proton antiproton pairs) are also moving so that's additional kinetic energy. The reactants have a mass of 2m and the products have a mass of 4m. The total momemtum must be the same since its conserved.

I tried figuring out the speed of the intital moving proton and the speed of the blob of 4 particles and got :

4u2 + v2=3c2

where u is the velocity of the proton and the v is the velocity of the 4 particle blob.
It would help if you showed how you got this result.

Generally, when you solve this type of problem, you want to work with the particles' energy and momentum, not their velocities.

Are you familiar with working with four-vectors?
 
  • #3
Well if the proton is going fast enough to overcome the electric repulsive forces it would collide wouldnt it? thats how colliders work dont they?

And i have never heard of 4 vectors sorry =/.

And the velocities i got it from equating the total energies of the "reactancts" and "products"

E1=gamma(2mc2) 2m because theres 2 protons initially

E2=gamma(4mc2) equated both equations but obviously i used the definiition of gamma because they both have different velocities.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831
Well if the proton is going fast enough to overcome the electric repulsive forces it would collide wouldn't it? thats how colliders work don't they?
That's not the point. You can't have interactions where electric charge just simply appears or disappears.
And the velocities i got it from equating the total energies of the "reactancts" and "products"

E1=gamma(2mc2) 2m because theres 2 protons initially

E2=gamma(4mc2) equated both equations but obviously i used the definiition of gamma because they both have different velocities.
E1 isn't correct because only one proton is moving. Your expression would only be correct if both protons were moving with the same speed so they have the same gamma.

Start by writing down the equations for conservation of energy and momentum in terms of the energies and momenta of the individual protons and the blob. Square the two equations, and then make use of the third "relevant equation" to combine and simplify your results.
 
  • #5
Well you have the proton at rest: E=mc2 K=0 p=0

The moving proton E1=K1+ mc2 p=(gamma1)mu whre u is the speed of the proton

The blob: E2=K2+4mc2 p=(gamma2)mv where v is the velocity of the blob

Equating any of teh energy/momentum equations together just seems like a big mess because of the velocity that is also inside the gamma function...
 
Last edited:
  • #6
This is the only problem i have left unsolved before tomorrows test(which is verbatim from homework). Ive tried solving for the velocities using the previously mentioned equations but no luck =/.
 
  • #7
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831
To repeat...
Generally, when you solve this type of problem, you want to work with the particles' energy and momentum, not their velocities.

Start by writing down the equations for conservation of energy and momentum in terms of the energies and momenta of the individual protons and the blob. Square the two equations, and then make use of the third "relevant equation" to combine and simplify your results.
 
  • #8
Sorry vela. I thought you mean start by energies and momentum to get velcoties.
Ok i managed to obtain the mass in terms of the K1 using hte euation above and the third relavant equation.

m=(pc)2 - K12/(2K1c2) i dont know if this will help.

When you say the equations for conservation of energy and momentum are you refering to:

Conservation of energy:K2+4mc2=K1+ mc2
Conservation of momentum: p=(gamma1)mu = p=(gamma2)mv
??
 
Last edited:
  • #9
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831
The units don't work out in that equation. Stick with the total energy E and momentum p for each particle. Once you solve for the total energy of the moving proton, you can calculate its kinetic energy by subtracting out the rest energy.
 
  • #10
yes i know what your saying:

Kinetic energy energy of moving proton is K1=(gamma1-1)mc2
But this takes me back to the initial quetion i would have to solve for the velocity in the gamma to obtain the kinetic energy just in terms of mass and c2.

Iam stupid sorry, iam not understanding at all. I dont see how you can solve this problem with just using the momentum and energies.
 
  • #11
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831
E1 = energy of moving proton
E2 = energy of proton at rest
E = energy of blob

p1 = momentum of moving proton
p2 = momentum of proton at rest
p = momentum of blob

Conservation equatlons are

E1 + E2 = E
p1 + p2 = p

Plus you know p2=0 and E2=mc2.

Square the first equation. Multiply the second equation by c and then square it. Subtract the second from the first.
 
  • #12
I feel like a complete retard now.....but i still cant see it. I did what you told me and i still cant see how the momentum cancels out.
 
  • #13
vela
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Education Advisor
15,231
1,831
What is E2-(pc)2 equal to?
 
  • #14
I failed , sorry vela. The my ******* proffesor put this one test and he knew it was the only one i didnt awnser. Out of 30 homework questions he always puts 6 on the test and he puts the only one i didnt have. Oh well i will still get an A but i wanted 100% cause it makes him mad when someone gets a 100%


Thanks for helping me even though i failed :( really apreciate your time.
 

Related Threads on Collision of a moving proton into a proton at rest (relativity)

Replies
10
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
255
E
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
10
Views
12K
Replies
2
Views
4K
Top