# Complex series

1. Homework Statement
Investigate the behavior (convergence or divergence) of $\sum_n 1/(1+z^n)$ where z is complex.

2. Homework Equations

3. The Attempt at a Solution
If the modulus of z is less than 1, it is not hard to show that the limit of the sequence is not 0 (it is actually not finite) and thus the series cannot converge. But if the modulus of z is greater than or equal to 1, I don't what to apply. The root test? The ratio test? The comparison test?

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org
Would you care to show how the series diverges if |z| < 1?

I determined that if |z| > 1, then series converges. I did this by comparing |zn| and |1 + zn| and using the comparison test.

Would you care to show how the series diverges if |z| < 1?

I determined that if |z| > 1, then series converges. I did this by comparing |zn| and |1 + zn| and using the comparison test.
I highly doubt that would work because I used that comparison to show it diverges when |z| < 1. Please explain exactly how you compared the two series.

I highly doubt that would work because I used that comparison to show it diverges when |z| < 1. Please explain exactly how you compared the two series.
why don't you show us what you did? it converges for |z| > 1

I highly doubt that would work because I used that comparison to show it diverges when |z| < 1. Please explain exactly how you compared the two series.
I will, once I see exactly how you showed that it diverges for |z| < 1.

$$|\frac{1}{1+z^n}| \geq \frac{1}{1+|z|^n} \geq 1/|z|^n$$

So the sequence of terms doesn't even go to 0 when |z| < 1

Last edited:
$$|\frac{1}{1+z^n}| \geq \frac{1}{1+|z|^n} \geq 1/|z|^n$$

So the sequence of terms doesn't even go to 0 when |z| < 1
this is wrong 1/(1 + |z|^n) >= 1/|z|^n

for |z| > 1, |1/(1 + z^n)| <= |1/z^n| = |1/z|^n and |1/z| < 1, so we have convergence

for |z| <= 1, suppose we had convergence, then lim n-> inf |1/(1 + z^n)| = 0, so lim 1/lim |1 + z^n| = 0, so lim |1 + z^n| = inf, but |1 + z^n| <= 1 + 1 = 2, a contradiction, so it cannot converge for |z| <= 1

I'm confused now. If Re(zn) < 0, then |zn| > |1 + zn| right? If Re(zn) >= 0, then |zn| < |1 + zn|. I think we have to consider both cases.

I'm confused now. If Re(zn) < 0, then |zn| > |1 + zn| right? If Re(zn) >= 0, then |zn| < |1 + zn|. I think we have to consider both cases.

edit: you're right in that I made a mistake. Take n = 1, z = -1 + i, then |z| = sqrt(2) and |1 + z| = 1, so |z| > |1 + z|, i forgot these are complex numbers here

Last edited:
for |z| <= 1, suppose we had convergence, then lim n-> inf |1/(1 + z^n)| = 0, so lim 1/lim |1 + z^n| = 0, so lim |1 + z^n| = inf, but |1 + z^n| <= 1 + 1 = 2, a contradiction, so it cannot converge for |z| <= 1
By the triangle inequality, |1 + zn| <= 1 + |z|n so

$$\frac{1}{1 + |z|^n} \le \frac{1}{|1 + z^n|} = \left|\frac{1}{1 + z^n}\right|$$

and furthermore

$$\sum_{n=0}^\infty \frac{1}{1 + |z|^n} \le \sum_{n=0}^\infty \left|\frac{1}{1 + z^n}\right|$$

So by the comparison test, if the LHS diverges, then so does the RHS. Now if |z| <= 1, then 1/2 <= 1/(1 + |z|n) <= 1 for all n and so the limit lies in [1/2, 1] and by the zero-test, the LHS diverges. Thus, so does the RHS.

The problem is this doesn't tell us if the original series of 1/(1 + zn) diverges.