Could you kill a man?

  • Thread starter maximus
  • Start date

could you kill a person?

  • yes, i could do it easily. (in cold blood)

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • yes, but i would only do it for specific reasons (hot blood)

    Votes: 7 53.8%
  • no, i could never kill a person

    Votes: 3 23.1%
  • other, please explain

    Votes: 3 23.1%

  • Total voters
    13
477
4
do you think that you are capable of killing another person?

...have you?
 
Last edited:

Eh

671
1
Certain people, in a different time perhaps.

It's like the saying on a t-shirt I saw. "Some people are only alive because it's illegal to kill them". :wink:
 
2,224
0
Yes, I could probably do it, but only because it was necessary, for instance in the case of war or, in self-defense. This I believe you call jutifiable homicide, which you would have to classify as "other" in your poll.
 
597
0
Originally posted by Eh
It's like the saying on a t-shirt I saw. "Some people are only alive because it's illegal to kill them". :wink:
Good one!

Actually, my past is strewn with "dead bodies" ...the victims of wishful thinking on my part.

However -- and this might be one of those times I shouldn't answer a question at all, let alone truthfully -- I could kill someone with pleasure if they ticked me off enough.

Just remember, as my signature says: "We are what we DO" ...not what we think about doing. Living a decent life is NOT about "controlling our emotions"; its about controlling the actions we may or may not want to take as a result of our emotions.
 
Last edited:
462
0
Originally posted by maximus
do you think that you are capable of killing another person?
I don't know. Who did you have in mind?
 

selfAdjoint

Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
Dearly Missed
6,764
5
I think that if I were in combat I could learn to do this. I can't think of any other occasion in which I could manage to go through with it.
 

mouseman

As the great rap-artist Scarface once wrote,
"Ah got this killuh up-inside a me. I cain't talk to mah mutha so I talk to mah diary."

If I could get away with it, yes I would be able to kill someone, but I would be the folkhero-type vigilante. I'd go after the rapists, murderers and all-around evil-doers.
 
732
2
I think deep down everyone is capable of it under the right circumstances. It's simply a question of extremes, and what would push you to do something like that. If someone killed the person you love most in the world, and you could kill them, wouldn't you?

For those of you who saw the movie "Seven" it's like that. He took them out there knowing that he would do it. For the rest of you, sorry I ruined the ending.. hehe. Or the movie "A time to kill". What paren't wouldn't want to do what he did?

When dealing with primal instincts of the human phsyche, anyone could be pushed to do it if they had no other choice. If you had to defend yourself? Kill or be killed? 99.9 percent would.
 
50
9
Yes i could kill someone if i needed to, are there any people who have served with the armed forces here, who might have killed someone in combat? Would be interesting to hear there views on this.
 

I, Brian

Theoretically I imagine each of us is capable of anything. In hard reality, though, it's different. Thinking about killing someone would be easy - but actually getting down to it - my body would try and do everything to prevent me. Maybe film and media has desensitised us to precisely what an incredible powerful emotional experience killing someone would be. I know it wouldn't be a natural action for myself, no matter what theoretical provocation surrounded any given situation.
 
12
0
I can kill a person in a situation of self-defense...I think...
But I don't think this could be answered without facing a likely situation.
It is too difficult to imagine smt like it! To end another human being's life by your own hands...to do something which cannot be taken back, ever... Ok I don't know what to say exactly...
 

Kerrie

Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
818
14
i would have to be in a situation where i felt severely threatened...
 
I kill you like my lobster.
 

Dal

59
0
I couldn't even kill a chicken. But if I see a rape, chances are that I'll kill the rapist.
 
477
4
am i the only person here who has ever fantisized about killing another person? i find myself sometimes walking through how i'd do it. usually it's only if the person is annoying me, but sometimes it's just a complete stranger or a friend. should i be worried?
 
What if I told you everyone you kill goes to heaven. Or better yet, lol, er, what Arthur Kay says about his father.
He hated the fact that we had to kill chickens in order to eat them. He felt God has gotten it all wrong when it came to chickens. They should be, my father would say, like peaches, unfeeling and edible. Grown in chicken orchards, and picked at their ripest and plumpest. Or, he would also say, chickens should have the magical ability to be eaten, but immediately reappear, alive and well, pecking away and no worse for the wear.
 

BoulderHead

Originally posted by M. Gaspar
Good one!

Actually, my past is strewn with "dead bodies" ...the victims of wishful thinking on my part.

However -- and this might be one of those times I shouldn't answer a question at all, let alone truthfully -- I could kill someone with pleasure if they ticked me off enough.
Damn, Hell hath no fury like M. Gaspar scorned!?

I'll try to stay on your good side from now on :smile:
 

Zero

Originally posted by maximus
do you think that you are capable of killing another person?

...have you?
Yes.
 
50
9
Was that a yes to the "have you" question? if so what where the circumstances for you killing th person(s)?
 

megashawn

Science Advisor
435
0
Maximus:
am i the only person here who has ever fantisized about killing another person? i find myself sometimes walking through how i'd do it. usually it's only if the person is annoying me, but sometimes it's just a complete stranger or a friend. should i be worried?
I can't say I've ever thought about killing someone who annoyed me. I go by a simple philosphy, "Don't get mad, get even" And if a person is annoying me, I'd rather get them even better, and have them around to laugh at, then maybe do it again.

See, this way, instead of killing people, you let them live for your own personal entertainment.
 

Related Threads for: Could you kill a man?

  • Posted
Replies
22
Views
6K
Replies
11
Views
2K
  • Posted
2 3
Replies
57
Views
7K
Replies
22
Views
4K
Replies
20
Views
3K
  • Posted
2
Replies
35
Views
2K
  • Posted
2
Replies
25
Views
3K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
1K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top