What is the Cusan transformation and its significance in the history of physics?

In summary, the conversation discusses the concept of covariance in physics and the emergence of this idea in the writings of Nicholas of Cusa. The Cusan transformation is described as a shift or change in position in space and is seen as a precursor to the ideas of relativity and the cosmological principle. The conversation ends with a reference to a specific section in The Routledge History of Philosophy where the concept of covariance is discussed in more detail.
  • #1
matheinste
1,068
0
Hello all.

The following is a quote from The Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol IX, Pages 219-220.

By the end of the nineteenth century, however, it had become clear that there was a transformation under which the laws of electromagnetism were covariant. This was the Lorentz transformation. The situation had now become very interesting. The Maxwell laws of electromagnetism are covariant with respect to the transformation of Lorentz but not with respect to that of Galileo. The laws of mechanics are covariant with respect to the transformation of Galileo but not with respect to that of Lorentz. Both are covariant with respect to the Cusan trnsformation, but this was taken to be so obvious as not to be worth remarking.

What is the Cusan transformation.

Matheinste
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
I never heard of the Cusan transformations...
but a Google book search turned up...

Einstein Meets Magritte By Diederik Aerts said:
from p. 116
http://books.google.com/books?id=ZlTl3UPEoT4C&pg=PA113&dq=cusa+relativity&lr=#PPA116,M1

From Cusa we have a principle of the indifference of the unfolding of
material processes to the place or moment at which they occur. From
Galileo we have a principle of the indifference of the unfolding of mechanical
processes to their velocity relative to any unobservable background,
of which absolute space, time and space-time would be cases. Finally
from Einstein we have a conceptual demonstration of the indifference of
all physical processes, mechanical and electromagnetic, to their relative
velocity to some alleged absolute material background, the aether.

Each level of indifference can be expressed as a principle of covariance,
in that the laws of nature describing physical processes take the
same form under progressively more restrictive coordinate transformations.
Displaying the development of relativistic physics as a progressively
more stringent application of the covariance requirement involves,
in a queer way, the retention of the absolutist concepts for the exposition
of relativity. We set up the progressively tighter relativity 'theories' by
affirming, step by step, 'No change in the laws of nature with respect to
changes in absolute positions, moments or motions, in an imagined
basic manifold or set of manifolds.' Expressing the laws of nature in such
forms as meet the covariance conditions for each level of stringency we
can then safely ignore such absolutes in physics. We can throw away
the ladder once we have ascended it! Making the totality of the laws
of physics, mechanics, electromagnetism, quantum mechanics and so on
covariant under the Lorentz transformation, is just to make them independent
of the most general candidate for an absolute spatio-temporal
manifold, the Minkowski space-time.

Mould said:
Mould, Basic Relativity makes reference to Nicholas of Cusa on p.3.

Relativity as a general philosophical idea can be found wherever one
finds philosophy. Probably the first to express it as a physical idea
in the Christian Era was Nicholas of Cusa, a cardinal of the Roman
Catholic Church and contemporary of Leonardo da Vinci. Unlike Aristotle,
Cusa accepted the idea of relativity of motion and rejected the
medieval notion that there are special directions in space such as up to
Heaven or down to Hell. Cusa's universe was an endless homogeneous
and isotropic space occupied only by many beautiful stars in relative
motion. He believed that an observer looking at the Earth from the
Sun would see it as another shining star.' Not only did Cusa's ideas
foreshadow relativity, but the cosmological principle as well.
 
  • #3
Thanks for your reply robphy.

I found references to the cardinal but none to the transform. It is strange that, although the quote from the Routledge History of Philosophy seems to assume that the reader requires no explanation because he or she will have some knowledge of it, it turns out to be so elusive.

Matheinste.
 
  • #4
Hello all.

For anyone interested i think i can answer my own question. Re reading part of the quoted book i found that it implies, without exactly stating, that the Cusan transformation is merely a change of position in space, a shift.

Matheinste.
 
  • #5
matheinste said:
Hello all.

For anyone interested i think i can answer my own question. Re reading part of the quoted book i found that it implies, without exactly stating, that the Cusan transformation is merely a change of position in space, a shift.

Matheinste.

Can you specify a particular section in that reference?
 
  • #6
Hello robphy

Here is the reference. I have copied out the relevant paragraph in full for anyone interested who does not have access to the book.

The Routledge History of Philosophy, Vol IX, Chapter 6-The Philosophy of Physics. Page 218.

:- If a law of physics has the same form before and after the transformation is applied to the coordinates, we say that it is 'covariant under the transformation'. However, the technical idea is a version of a more fundamental conception. It expresses the idea that the forms of the laws of nature are indifferent to (that is unaffected by ) changes in location, epoch or relative velocity of the frame with respect to which they are studied. We can detect the very beginnings of the covariance or indifference to location idea in the writings of Nicholas of Cusa. Contrary to the Aristotleans, who believed that space and time had intrinsic structures, the laws of nature differing with the location in which they are studied within the structure, Cusa introduced a general principle of indifference. His elegant epigram ran as follows:- 'the centre and circumference of the universe are the same', or in other words, physical laws are indifferent to their location in space and also, he believed, in time.

Matheinste.
 

What is Cusan Transformation?

Cusan Transformation is a mathematical technique developed by German philosopher and mathematician Nicholas of Cusa in the 15th century. It involves transforming a geometrical figure into another figure with the same area, but with a different shape.

What are the applications of Cusan Transformation?

Cusan Transformation has been used in various fields such as engineering, architecture, and computer graphics for creating visually appealing and symmetrical designs. It has also been applied in calculus for solving problems related to area and volume.

How does Cusan Transformation work?

The technique involves dividing a geometrical figure into smaller parts and then rearranging them to form a different figure with the same area. This is done by rotating, flipping, or scaling the smaller parts while maintaining their relative positions and orientations.

What are the advantages of using Cusan Transformation?

Cusan Transformation allows for the creation of complex and aesthetically pleasing designs with ease. It also has practical applications in fields such as architecture, where symmetrical designs are desired. Additionally, it can help in solving mathematical problems related to area and volume.

Are there any limitations to Cusan Transformation?

One limitation of Cusan Transformation is that it only works for figures with a finite number of sides. It also does not take into account the thickness of the lines used to create the figure, which can affect the accuracy of the transformation. Additionally, it may not be suitable for certain types of figures, such as irregular shapes.

Similar threads

  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
32
Views
5K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
18
Views
3K
  • Special and General Relativity
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Feedback and Announcements
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
69
Views
9K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
1
Views
3K
Back
Top