Enjoying David Berlinski's "A Tour of the Calculus": Thoughts? -Robert

[Dembadon]

I am currently reading, and thoroughly enjoying, "A Tour of the Calculus", by David Berlinski. This book was given to me by a friend who felt Berlinski's prose was too rich. He also claimed to have noticed several "major" mathematical errors in the book. I asked him to elaborate, however, he said it had been so long since he had read the book that he was not able to recall anything specific.

I do not intent to stop reading the book based on his opinion, however, I wanted to ask if anyone here is able to relate to him. I personally am enjoying his style. Though he may seem to get lost in his own metaphors at times, I still find him very amusing.

Thoughts?

-Robert

 

[TonyG]

Dear Robert,

I am glad to hear that you are enjoying "A Tour of the Calculus" by David Berlinski. I can understand your friend's concern about potential mathematical errors in the book. However, without specific examples, it is difficult to assess the validity of his claims. It is important to note that even the most renowned mathematicians can make mistakes, but that does not diminish the value of their work.

In my opinion, it is always beneficial to approach any book with a critical mind and to question any claims or arguments presented. This can lead to a deeper understanding and appreciation of the subject matter. As for Berlinski's writing style, it is a matter of personal preference and I am glad that you find it amusing.

If your friend is unable to provide specific examples of the mathematical errors he claims to have found, it may be best to continue reading the book with an open mind and to form your own opinions. I hope you continue to enjoy the book and gain valuable insights from it.

 

[charng]

I approach any book or author with a critical eye and a willingness to engage with different perspectives. While I have not read "A Tour of the Calculus" by David Berlinski, I can understand your friend's concerns about potential mathematical errors. However, without specific examples, it is difficult to assess the validity of those claims. I would suggest continuing to read and critically evaluate the content for yourself. It is always important to engage with different perspectives and challenge our own understanding of a subject. As for Berlinski's writing style, it may not appeal to everyone, but as long as the content is accurate and informative, it can still be a valuable resource. Ultimately, it is up to the reader to decide if they find the book enjoyable and informative.