- #1

- 55

- 4

## Main Question or Discussion Point

Physics could be fundamentally discrete. Are their any notable theories that have discrete mathematics at its core and have QM, GR and differential equations in general as emergent features?

- I
- Thread starter waves and change
- Start date

- #1

- 55

- 4

Physics could be fundamentally discrete. Are their any notable theories that have discrete mathematics at its core and have QM, GR and differential equations in general as emergent features?

- #2

fresh_42

Mentor

- 12,650

- 9,168

Here's a discrete part: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lattice_gauge_theoryPhysics could be fundamentally discrete. Are their any notable theories that have discrete mathematics at its core..,

Here's one for that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_difference_method... and have QM, GR and differential equations...

I didn't know there is one in a continusous set-up.... in general as emergent features?

- #3

- 55

- 4

Thank you !

- #4

- 55

- 4

Finite difference method is just a discrete method to approximate a diff. Equation. That doesn’t really give any insight into my question as posing discreteness as the underlying fundamental feature. Same can be said for Lattice gauge theory which just serves as a tool to approximation continuityThank you !

- #5

fresh_42

Mentor

- 12,650

- 9,168

I knew a professor who saw it the other way around: "Since there is nothing really continuous in the world out there, differentiabilty is an approximation of the discrete things which happen!" O.k. he mainly meant it to motivate the drawings of vector fields, but anyhow, there is some truth in it.Finite difference method is just a discrete method to approximate a diff. Equation.

P.s.: I mentioned this as a contradictory possible statement, not to start a discussion upon. This belongs into philosophy and will not be dealt with on PF. However, I couldn't let stand this extreme claim as only possible truth. It is not.

- #6

phyzguy

Science Advisor

- 4,394

- 1,369

Many people are working along these lines, but it is not simple. If spacetime is discrete, for example, it cannot simply be pixelized like the pixels on your display screen, because this would not be Lorentz invariant and would be observer dependent. An attempt to formulate a discrete model of spacetime, which I personally believe is in the right direction, is to use non-commutative geometry. This draws on the idea of quantum phase space, where the coordinates (x and px, ...) do not commute and the volume of quantum phase space is basically discrete in units of (2 π ħ)^3. An example that helped me to understand these ideas is that of the "fuzzy sphere", where the area of the sphere is discretized into N units (where N can be any integer from 2 on up) in a way that is observer independent. As N goes to infinity, one recovers the usual continuous spherical surface.Physics could be fundamentally discrete. Are their any notable theories that have discrete mathematics at its core and have QM, GR and differential equations in general as emergent features?

- #7

- 55

- 4

Thank you. I will look into this!Many people are working along these lines, but it is not simple. If spacetime is discrete, for example, it cannot simply be pixelized like the pixels on your display screen, because this would not be Lorentz invariant and would be observer dependent. An attempt to formulate a discrete model of spacetime, which I personally believe is in the right direction, is to use non-commutative geometry. This draws on the idea of quantum phase space, where the coordinates (x and px, ...) do not commute and the volume of quantum phase space is basically discrete in units of (2 π ħ)^3. An example that helped me to understand these ideas is that of the "fuzzy sphere", where the area of the sphere is discretized into N units (where N can be any integer from 2 on up) in a way that is observer independent. As N goes to infinity, one recovers the usual continuous spherical surface.