Discuss, prove or disprove: winners & losers in oil production

  • Thread starter EnumaElish
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Oil
In summary, the government is holding an auction for the right to explore and exploit oil on a tract of land. The rules state that there is no reserve price and the highest bidder will win and must pay. Even if only one bidder shows up and bids zero, the sale will still proceed. All potential bidders have an equal chance of the net present value (NPV) of the oil being accessible from the tract, with a mean of M. This is confirmed by independent engineering studies. The auction is expected to have at least 30 potential bidders. A newspaper editor has claimed that the winner of the auction will actually be a loser, which is a topic for discussion and debate.
  • #1
EnumaElish
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
2,350
124
Government holds an auction to sell the right for oil exploration (and exploitation, if any found) on a tract of land to the highest bidder. Rules are: no reserve price; highest price wins and is paid; there will be a sale even if a single bidder shows up and bids zero.

All potential bidders have the same probability distribution for the net present value (NPV) of the oil accessible from the tract. Suppose it is a symmetric distribution with mean M. (Assume that a number of independent engineering studies have confirmed that the likelihood of NPV > M is equal to that of NPV < M.)

At least 30 potential bidders are expected to bid.

A day before the auction, a hot shot newspaper editor claims that "the winner will be a loser."

Discuss, prove or disprove.
 
Mathematics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Homework problem?
 
  • #3
rachmaninoff said:
Homework problem?
It can be. I intended it as a fun & games kind of problem.
 

1. What factors determine who the winners and losers are in oil production?

The winners and losers in oil production are determined by various factors such as the availability of resources, technology and infrastructure, government policies, geopolitical stability, and market demand. Countries with large reserves of oil, advanced technologies, and stable political environments tend to be the winners, while those with limited resources, outdated technology, and political instability may struggle to compete in the global market.

2. Is there a direct correlation between a country's wealth and its oil production?

While oil production can contribute significantly to a country's wealth, it is not always a direct correlation. Factors such as population size, economic diversification, and government policies all play a role in a country's overall wealth. Additionally, a country's success in managing and investing its oil revenues can also impact its overall wealth.

3. Are there any environmental impacts of oil production on the winners and losers?

Yes, there are environmental impacts of oil production on both the winners and losers. The extraction and refining process can result in air and water pollution, as well as habitat destruction. The winners, who have more resources and advanced technologies, may be better equipped to mitigate these impacts, while the losers may struggle to do so.

4. Can the winners and losers in oil production change over time?

Yes, the winners and losers in oil production can change over time. Factors such as new discoveries of oil reserves, technological advancements, and shifts in global demand can all impact a country's position in the oil market. Additionally, political and economic changes in a country can also affect its ability to compete in the industry.

5. Is there a way to ensure a fair distribution of wealth among the winners and losers in oil production?

There is no guaranteed way to ensure a fair distribution of wealth among the winners and losers in oil production. Government policies and regulations play a significant role in determining how oil revenues are distributed and invested. However, corruption and unequal power dynamics can also impact the distribution of wealth. Some argue that greater transparency and accountability measures can help promote a more equitable distribution of oil wealth.

Similar threads

MHB Decisions in Managerial Economics
    • General Math
Replies
1
Views
2K
Optimum strategy for eBay bidding (game theory of auctions)
    • General Discussion
Replies
21
Views
17K

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top