Discussion of philosophical question

  • Thread starter kldickson
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Discussion
In summary, the conversation revolves around the difficulties of discussing philosophical questions, including defining terms and understanding different perspectives. There is criticism of philosophy in general and the lack of consideration for human limitations and defining terms. There is also a discussion on the relationship between philosophy and physics, with the understanding that they are interconnected but often separated in academia.
  • #1
kldickson
106
0
The discussion of philosophical questions can be a difficult one, from delineating terms to trying to understand the other person's worldview and taking into account the fact that we are humans who possesses rather limited perception.

There is much criticism of philosophy as a whole; I'd like to use this thread as a forum for discussion on, well, philosophical discussion.

What are your thoughts on the problems permeating the exchange of ideas between philosophers as opposed to the ideas themselves, which have no shortage of deserved criticism?

From my standpoint, there seems to be a lot of lack of consideration of human limits and a lack of defining terms; much discussion I've seen is full of misunderstanding of terms and logical fallacies and a lack of reaching out to, say, other parties who are relevant to a discussion (for example, someone who philosophizes about, say, physics may not reach out to physicists themselves - and if they don't reach out to physicists, quite frankly, in my opinion, that particular philosopher is a moron).
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2


Applied physics is a branch of science, which is an aspect of empirical philosophy. Theoretical physics is also a branch of science, but has its orgins more in rationalist philosophy. The fact philosophy and physics are generally in different departments in academia is an organization issue. It doesn't really speak to much else. Physics is a specialization, within the study of knowledge.
 
  • #3

I believe that philosophical questions are important and can provide valuable insights into understanding the world and our place in it. However, I also recognize the challenges that come with discussing these questions, particularly when it comes to communication and understanding.

One issue that I have observed in philosophical discussions is the lack of clear and agreed upon definitions. This can lead to confusion and misunderstandings, making it difficult to have a productive exchange of ideas. As scientists, we are trained to be precise and clear in our language, and I believe that this approach can also benefit philosophical discussions.

Additionally, I agree with the sentiment that there can be a lack of consideration for human limits in philosophical discussions. We are all limited by our own perspectives, biases, and cognitive abilities. It is important to acknowledge and account for these limitations in order to have a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of philosophical ideas.

I also believe that it is important for philosophers to engage with experts in other fields, such as physics or neuroscience, when discussing topics that intersect with these disciplines. This can help to ground philosophical ideas in empirical evidence and prevent them from becoming detached from reality.

In conclusion, while there may be valid criticisms of philosophy as a whole, I believe that open and respectful discussions about philosophical questions are important and can lead to valuable insights. However, it is crucial to address issues such as clear definitions, human limits, and interdisciplinary collaboration in order to have more productive and meaningful discussions.
 

Related to Discussion of philosophical question

1. What is a philosophical question?

A philosophical question is a question that deals with fundamental, abstract concepts and ideas about existence, knowledge, values, and reality. It often involves critical thinking and reflection on the nature of these concepts and their significance in our lives.

2. Why is it important to discuss philosophical questions?

Discussing philosophical questions allows us to gain a deeper understanding of ourselves and the world around us. It challenges us to think critically and reflect on our beliefs and values, leading to personal growth and intellectual development. It also helps us to navigate complex ethical, moral, and societal issues.

3. Can philosophical questions be answered?

Philosophical questions do not have definitive answers like in other scientific fields. They often lead to more questions and open-ended discussions. However, the process of discussing and contemplating these questions can lead to new insights and perspectives.

4. Are there different types of philosophical questions?

Yes, there are various types of philosophical questions, including metaphysical, epistemological, ethical, and aesthetic questions. Each type deals with different aspects of existence, knowledge, morality, and beauty.

5. How can discussing philosophical questions benefit society?

Discussing philosophical questions can help us to better understand the world and our place in it. It can also promote critical thinking, empathy, and open-mindedness, leading to more respectful and productive discussions and decision-making. In addition, it can inspire creativity and innovation in various fields, including science and technology.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
712
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • General Discussion
Replies
16
Views
1K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
3
Replies
76
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top