1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data Silicon crystalises in a cubic structure whose lattice is face-centred, with a basis ,[1/4,1/4,1/4]. How many optic/acoustic modes are to be found in the phonon dispersion diagram for silicon. How many distinct branches would you expect along the  direction? 2. Relevant equations 3. The attempt at a solution 2 atoms in the primitive unit cell, therefore expect 3N degrees of freedom, so a total of 6 modes. I also have it on good authority that you expect 3(N-1) optical modes and N acoustic modes, but I do not see why. So a total of 3 of each modes For distinct modes, imagining looking at a lattice of atoms joined with springs down the x direction, I would imagine the modes that vibrate in the x-direction would be invisible, whereas the ones in y and z would be visible (so 1 acoustic and 1 optical invisible). I think this because when looking at dipole radiation from an electron in a magnetic field the mode identified with linear motion in the direction of the B field (delta Mz = 0), you cannot see it when looking along the B field. I don't get this either. None of this really makes sense to me! Many thanks for any help.