Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Dividing by 1 is impossible

  1. Oct 21, 2007 #1
    Oddly enough I came across this on Uncyclopedia.
    Can you really divide by 1?
    I know that it can be mathematically done with ease, but physically can it be done?
    Imagine a pie, and your dividing tool is your knife. If you want to divide the pie in 2 you can do that just cut the pie down the middle. If you want to divide it by 4 just cut it down the middle then do it again perpendicular to the original cut. But if you want to divide by 1 you end up not using your knife at all. You therefore don't divide the pie and do not divide by 1.

    I hope this is the right forum.
     
  2. jcsd
  3. Oct 21, 2007 #2

    TMM

    User Avatar

    By your same logic, you can only divide by integers.
     
  4. Oct 22, 2007 #3

    Hurkyl

    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Gold Member

    I think this is merely a matter of language. Natural language has evolved to include an artificial distinction between "0" and "more than 0". (or more generally, between "less than 0", "0", "1", and "more than 1") While this is efficient for everyday communication, it has the unfortunate side-effect of constraining our thought -- we have a habit of excluding special cases when we really ought not to do so.


    And another thing -- don't make a fallacy of equivocation. There are at least two distinct meanings for the word "divide" in your post: the English verb meaning a particular arithmetic calculation, and the English verb meaning to separate into parts. That they use the same word does not mean they are the same thing.
     
    Last edited: Oct 22, 2007
  5. Oct 22, 2007 #4
    what do you get, when you want to divide a pie by 1? The entire pie itself.

    what do you get when you want to divide a number by 1? The number itself.
     
  6. Oct 22, 2007 #5
    Yes so you don't actually divide the pie or the number. If you want to say oh I wonder what 7/1 is. You already have the answer before you divide. And your not even dividing it up.
     
  7. Oct 22, 2007 #6
    You're confusing yourself. Of course dividing by 1 is possible. If it was impossible, you'd have no answer.
     
  8. Oct 22, 2007 #7
    I mean its impossible because you don't actually do any dividing. The answer is already there and you do not divide it.
     
  9. Oct 22, 2007 #8
    It's like a limit, sin(x)/x never gets to 0, but you know that it would be 1. You don't actually divide by 1 you just know that like 7/1.00000001 is roughly 7.

    maybe thats a bad example.
     
  10. Oct 22, 2007 #9
    So you're saying it's a tautology? That still doesn't make dividing by 1 impossible.
     
  11. Oct 22, 2007 #10
    It's not a totally trivial observation. It's interesting that there exist certain mathematical operations which are equivalent to doing nothing at all. Maybe the OP is going to grow up to be a group theorist!
     
  12. Oct 24, 2007 #11
    For those of you still debating this you need to read this again:

     
  13. Oct 24, 2007 #12
    Dividing by one is basicly the 'do nothing' operation from group theory. It is the same as the 'add zero' operation under addition. The denominator tells how many pieces are left of the whole after you use the knife on the pie. So division by 2 is 'make one slice across the pie and leave 2 pieces', division by three is 'make 2 slices with the knife and leave three pieces,' etc. It is easy to see that on this incremental basis division by 1 is 'make no slices with the knife and leave one whole piece.' This would also go towards explaining why division by 0 is impossible as it is -1 slices with the knife and the command would be 'take away a slice that does not exist made by the knife and make the entire pie disappear (0 pieces).'
     
  14. Oct 24, 2007 #13
    Ya the pie metaphor doesn't explain negative pie.
     
  15. Oct 24, 2007 #14

    arildno

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    Please not think your kindergarten maths has anything to do with the concept of division.
     
  16. Oct 24, 2007 #15
    What's the OP?
     
  17. Oct 24, 2007 #16
    Original poster
     
  18. Oct 25, 2007 #17
    Is this topic over yet? If it is then I need someone to explain why I cannot add 0 to my pie... :biggrin:
     
  19. Oct 27, 2007 #18
    Now all we need to do is learn how to physically divide the pie by a half, and never go hungry again :)
     
  20. Oct 28, 2007 #19

    JasonRox

    User Avatar
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member

    That's you. :)
     
  21. Oct 29, 2007 #20
    There are much better examples, especially since if x=pi then sin(x)/x is, in fact, equal to zero.
     
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?
Similar Discussions: Dividing by 1 is impossible
  1. Impossible materials (Replies: 6)

  2. What is impossible? (Replies: 60)

  3. Is infinity impossible? (Replies: 17)

Loading...