# Dividing Functions Questions

Hi there,
Quick question. For F(X)= X/Sin(X), is there a hole at X=0?

Thanks.

Related Calculus and Beyond Homework Help News on Phys.org
What do you get when plugging 0 into F(X) ?

tiny-tim
Homework Helper
Hi there,
Quick question. For F(X)= X/Sin(X), is there a hole at X=0?

Thanks.
Hi CanadianEh! At x = 0, obviously, it's 0/0, which is undefined (it's known as an "indeterminate form"), so yes in that sense there's a hole …

of course, F(x) does tend to a limit at as x -> 0 0/Sin 0 = undefined.

So basically, there's my answer. There is a hole at x=0. There is also an oblique asymptote of f(x)=x, correct?

Hi CanadianEh! At x = 0, obviously, it's 0/0, which is undefined (it's known as an "indeterminate form"), so yes in that sense there's a hole …

of course, F(x) does tend to a limit at as x -> 0 Thanks so much! Can you help me explain why there is an oblique asymptote?

tiny-tim
Homework Helper
Thanks so much! Can you help me explain why there is an oblique asymptote?
uhh? wot's an oblique asymptote? When a linear asymptote is not parallel to the x- or y-axis, it is called either an oblique asymptote or equivalently a slant asymptote.

In the graph of X/Sin(X), there appears to be an asymptote at y=x

chroot
Staff Emeritus
Gold Member
The function continues to have a defined value as you get arbitrarily close to zero, thus the limit as x->0 is defined. The function itself is undefined only exactly at zero.

- Warren

Try graphing x/sin(x) and you'll only see vertical asymptotes when the denominator, or sin(x), is 0.
As far as I know, a rational function P(x)/Q(x) where P and Q are polynomials has an oblique asymptote only when the degree of the numerator is one larger than that of the denominator. In x/sin(x) you have a transcendental function in the denominator.

Ok, so NO oblique asymptote, correct?

tiny-tim
Homework Helper
When a linear asymptote is not parallel to the x- or y-axis, it is called either an oblique asymptote or equivalently a slant asymptote.

In the graph of X/Sin(X), there appears to be an asymptote at y=x
Still totally confused as to why this is called an asymptote instead of a tangent. Anyway I can't see how it's slanting ……

what is limx -> 0 x/sinx ? Ok, so NO oblique asymptote, correct?
That's right.

uhh? wot's an oblique asymptote? A slant asymptote
http://home.att.net/~srschmitt/precalc/precalc-fig12-03.gif [Broken]

Last edited by a moderator:
tiny-tim
Homework Helper
A slant asymptote
So that's only at infinity? and also negative infinity if the domain goes there too.

HallsofIvy