Doubt about centrifugal force

Like Tony Stark

Homework Statement
The picture shows a block on an arm. This arm is rotating with constant angular velocity. There is friction between the block and the arm, and the block is about to slide down.
Homework Equations
Newton's equations
I know that, if my $X$ axis is aligned with the arm, there is friction pointing to $O$ and the $x$ component of the weight. Then, on the $Y$ axis, there is the normal force and the $y$ component of the weight.
Supposing that I am situated on the arm (non inertial frame), where is the centrifugal force pointing to? Because, if I think the problem as a spinning ball, the centrifugal force is aligned with the tension, so in this case this pseudo-force would be in the $x$ axis. But if I think as if I were on the arm, I think that I would feel pushed against the arm, so the centrifugal force would be in the $y$ axis.
What's the correct option?

Attachments

• 49.5 KB Views: 19
• Delta2
Related Introductory Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org

SammyS

Staff Emeritus
Homework Helper
Gold Member
Homework Statement: The picture shows a block on an arm. This arm is rotating with constant angular velocity. There is friction between the block and the arm, and the block is about to slide down.
Homework Equations: Newton's equations

I know that, if my $X$ axis is aligned with the arm, there is friction pointing to $O$ and the $x$ component of the weight. Then, on the $Y$ axis, there is the normal force and the $y$ component of the weight.
Supposing that I am situated on the arm (non inertial frame), where is the centrifugal force pointing to? Because, if I think the problem as a spinning ball, the centrifugal force is aligned with the tension, so in this case this pseudo-force would be in the $x$ axis. But if I think as if I were on the arm, I think that I would feel pushed against the arm, so the centrifugal force would be in the $y$ axis.
What's the correct option?
What is the axis of rotation?

Andrew Mason

Homework Helper
If I understand the configuration correctly, the rotation is about the vertical axis through the central point. Is that correct? If so the centipetal force is horizontal toward the axis of rotation. So there is a normal component perpendicular to the arm and a component along the arm.

AM

Like Tony Stark

If I understand the configuration correctly, the rotation is about the vertical axis through the central point. Is that correct? If so the centipetal force is horizontal toward the axis of rotation. So there is a normal component perpendicular to the arm and a component along the arm.

AM
It says that the arm rotates about a horizontal axis through $O$

Like Tony Stark

What is the axis of rotation?
It says that the arm rotates about a horizontal axis through $O$

haruspex

Homework Helper
Gold Member
2018 Award
friction pointing to O
To O?
I think that I would feel pushed against the arm, so the centrifugal force would be in the y axis.
The only reason you might feel that is because of gravity. If the rotation were in the horizontal plane the normal force would be vertical.

jbriggs444

Homework Helper
As I understand the setup, it is like a mouse-trap or a catapult (classic onager style like Wile E Coyote uses), but without angular acceleration. Just smooth rotation.

Adopting the rotating reference frame, one can identify four forces on the object: The downward force of gravity, the outward centrifugal force, the normal component of the contact force and an unknown frictional force.

Given that "the block is about to slide down", one can easily identify the direction in which the frictional force must be acting.

Like Tony Stark

As I understand the setup, it is like a mouse-trap or a catapult (classic onager style like Wile E Coyote uses), but without angular acceleration. Just smooth rotation.

Adopting the rotating reference frame, one can identify four forces on the object: The downward force of gravity, the outward centrifugal force, the normal component of the contact force and an unknown frictional force.

Given that "the block is about to slide down", one can easily identify the direction in which the frictional force must be acting.

That's my problem. If I think it as a catapult, what would be the force that doesn't allow the block to slide? Because while the catapult is moving, the thing that is in the catapult won't be thrown away until the catapult stop. And if that's the case, the centrifugal force would be in the direction of the weight, like case 2 ($f*$ is the centrifugal force)

Attachments

• 63 KB Views: 9
• 61 KB Views: 9

jbriggs444

Homework Helper
If I think it as a catapult, what would be the force that doesn't allow the block to slide?
Friction. Same as any other problem involving an inclined plane. If it is about to slide down, the rotation rate cannot be high enough to fling it outward.

Edit: Looking at your drawing, you have the weight force drawn normal to the plane. Why is that?

Last edited:

Like Tony Stark

To O?

The only reason you might feel that is because of gravity. If the rotation were in the horizontal plane the normal force would be vertical.
I see... so the pseudo-force is the centrifugal force. But if the block starts sliding, would it feel also Coriolis force? Because it would have velocity relative to the non inertial frame

haruspex

Homework Helper
Gold Member
2018 Award
I see... so the pseudo-force is the centrifugal force. But if the block starts sliding, would it feel also Coriolis force? Because it would have velocity relative to the non inertial frame
Yes, but more specifically, because its relative velocity has a component normal to the axis of rotation of the frame.

"Doubt about centrifugal force"

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving