Doubt with Newton's 3rd law

  • #1

Main Question or Discussion Point

I understand that if for an instance one object pushes another with a determinate force, the other object acelerates with that force, and the pushing object acelerates in oposite direction with the oposite force as well.

However if I punch a piece of paper I don't feel the same oposite force from my punch than with a heavier object like a furniture, shouldn´t it be the same?

I've google this and I saw this response:
49580ef61041d9175d63b26c87fe7cde.png


It considers a1=a2

According to Newton's law F2,1=-F, right? then the block 1 wouldn´t move at all (f-f=0) and the object 2 would accelerate with an F force. I'm so confused.. Where does this F1,2 , F2,1 and F come in the first place, shouldn't F transform into F2,1 and F1,2? How come are they added in F=ma if they don't coexist.

thanks in advance
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Nugatory
Mentor
12,533
5,037
Try googling for "horse cart problem newton's third law" and you'll find a number of good explanations.

The key here is that the two forces that make up a third-law equal-and-opposite pair are acting on different objects. When you push on the block you are applying a force to the block and accelerating. The block is exerting an equal and opposite force on you. You would slide backwards if you were standing on a slippery floor; more often the friction between the soles of your shoes and the floor acts against the force the block exerts on you so the net force on you is zero and you stay put.
 
  • #3
Doc Al
Mentor
44,877
1,129
However if I punch a piece of paper I don't feel the same oposite force from my punch than with a heavier object like a furniture, shouldn´t it be the same?
You can easily punch a heavy object with more force than you can punch a piece of paper. But either way, whatever force you exert on the object (whether paper or furniture) will be equal and opposite to the force that that object exerts back on you.

According to Newton's law F2,1=-F, right?
No, not right. F is an applied force. The correct third law pair here is F2,1 & F1,2: They are equal and opposite.
 
  • #4
jtbell
Mentor
15,500
3,296
However if I punch a piece of paper I don't feel the same oposite force from my punch than with a heavier object like a furniture, shouldn´t it be the same?
It takes less force to give the same acceleration to a piece of paper than to a sofa. Therefore the reaction force from the piece of paper is also less.
 
  • #5
Andrew Mason
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
7,562
325
....

According to Newton's law F2,1=-F, right?
The force of a punch depends on what it is hitting. If you punch the air, you don't apply much force to the air and the air does not apply much force to your fist. But if you punch a cement wall, the wall will apply a very large force to your fist. Your fist will stop in a very short time so its momentum change per unit of time (F = dp/dt) is very large. The air will just slow your fist down by a very small amount in a very long time, so the force = dp/dt is very small.

AM
 
  • #6
Sanky123
One think is there

newtons 3rd law needed particular medium(ex.air)to be apply

so in vaccume( Space) How it apply to rocket,as there is no medium
 
  • #7
Danger
Gold Member
9,608
244
How it apply to rocket,as there is no medium
The force upon the motor is opposite to the force that the exhaust experiences in its escape from the motor.
 
  • #8
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,714
4,415
One think is there

newtons 3rd law needed particular medium(ex.air)to be apply

so in vaccume( Space) How it apply to rocket,as there is no medium
The rocket engine pushes against the fuel exhaust to accelerate it out of the nozzle. Therefor there is also a force pushing back against the rocket engine, which is what accelerates the rocket.
 
  • #9
Sanky123
The rocket engine pushes against the fuel exhaust to accelerate it out of the nozzle. Therefor there is also a force pushing back against the rocket engine, which is what accelerates the rocket.
Ok thanks..

one more thing , what happend to that exhausts from rocket engine in vaccume ( Space )
 
  • #10
Drakkith
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
20,714
4,415
Ok thanks..

one more thing , what happend to that exhausts from rocket engine in vaccume ( Space )
It just keeps going.
 
  • #11
Sanky123
Ok
 

Related Threads for: Doubt with Newton's 3rd law

  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
10
Views
4K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
3K
Top