Duality of Light

eextreme · Nov 13, 2011

Is there a possibility that light can be a particle and wave at the same time? If so then there is the proof that there exists a physical manifestation of 4D space.

DaveC426913 · Nov 13, 2011

eextreme said: ↑

Is there a possibility that light can be a particle and wave at the same time? If so then there is the proof that there exists a physical manifestation of 4D space.

I'm almost afraid to ask but, what makes you think one leads to the other?

eextreme · Nov 13, 2011

Well, if there was 4D space that means that there is a chance that two events can happen at the exact same time. Thus, what if light as a wave and particle are two events happening at the same time? (wave properties being the first event and particle properties being the second event)

phinds · Nov 14, 2011

eextreme said: ↑

Well, if there was 4D space that means that there is a chance that two events can happen at the exact same time. Thus, what if light as a wave and particle are two events happening at the same time? (wave properties being the first event and particle properties being the second event)

Your logic escapes me. Even if there WERE a 4th spacial dimenision (which I dispute) it does NOT follow that two events could happen at the same time AND why would "two events could happen at the same time" follow from the duality of light?

Light IS a particle and a wave at the same time in 3D; why do you need a 4th?

eextreme · Nov 14, 2011

phinds said: ↑

Your logic escapes me. Even if there WERE a 4th spacial dimension (which I dispute) it does NOT follow that two events could happen at the same time AND why would "two events could happen at the same time" follow from the duality of light?

Light IS a particle and a wave at the same time in 3D; why do you need a 4th?

Your first paragraph and second paragraph contradicts each other.

Light acting as a wave is an event and light acting as a particle is another event. Recently, I've watched a video that described shapes in 4D space and the hypercube's "shadow" is a cube and that is what we perceive in the real world.

Light as a wave and light as a particle are "shadows" of "Light" which exists in 4D space.

phinds · Nov 14, 2011

eextreme said: ↑

Light as a wave and light as a particle are "shadows" of "Light" which exists in 4D space.

Riiiigghht ......

BruceW · Nov 14, 2011

Quantum mechanics does perfectly well without introducing a 4th spatial dimension, as far as I know...

DaveC426913 · Nov 14, 2011

eextreme said: ↑

Light acting as a wave is an event and light acting as a particle is another event.

No, they are not.

eextreme said: ↑

Light as a wave and light as a particle are "shadows" of "Light" which exists in 4D space.

This sounds suspiciously like an assertion based upon a personal or otherwise unpublished theory. PF expressly forbids personal theories, as you will have read in the rules when you signed up. If you pursue this assertion further this thread will be locked.

You may ask questions as to why it is not so, but you may not make unfounded assertions. Consider yourself given fair warning.

phinds · Nov 15, 2011

DaveC426913 said: ↑

This sounds suspiciously like an assertion based upon a personal or otherwise unpublished theory.

Dave, you said that SO much more elegantly than I did. But I was briefer

ZapperZ · Nov 15, 2011

eextreme said: ↑

Your first paragraph and second paragraph contradicts each other.

Light acting as a wave is an event and light acting as a particle is another event. Recently, I've watched a video that described shapes in 4D space and the hypercube's "shadow" is a cube and that is what we perceive in the real world.

Light as a wave and light as a particle are "shadows" of "Light" which exists in 4D space.

Please read the FAQ subforum as a start.

If you wish to propose your own idea, rather than learn what we know about QM and light, then you've found the wrong forum. Please review the https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=414380" that you had agreed to.

Zz.

Log in or Sign up

Duality of Light

eextreme

DaveC426913

eextreme

phinds

eextreme

phinds

BruceW

DaveC426913

phinds

ZapperZ

Wave/Particle Duality in Light Quanta (Replies: 15)

Particle / wave duality on a scale of light frequencies. (Replies: 194)

Light questions (not wave/particle duality!) (Replies: 2)

Light is known to have a wave-particle duality (Replies: 9)

Physics Faq clarifiaction - light duality (Replies: 2)