# Easy tensor question

Another trivial question from me.

## Homework Statement

Which (if any) of the following are valid tensor expressions:
(a)$A^\alpha+B_\alpha$
(b)$R^\alpha{}_\beta A^\beta+B^\alpha=0$
(c)$R_{\alpha\beta}=T_\gamma$
(d)$A_{\alpha\beta}=B_{\beta\alpha}$

## Homework Equations

Nothing relevant - these are generic tensors.

## The Attempt at a Solution

(a) and (c) are not valid because the indices don't match up. (d) is valid - in matrix notation, A=BT.

I'm not sure about (b), though. The left hand side is valid; summing over the dummy index makes it a sum of two vectors. I'm not quite sure how to interpret the equality, though. I can see it as a vector equaling a scalar - which is not valid. Alternatively, I can read an implicit $\forall \alpha$ - in other words, that each element of the vector on the left hand side is identically zero.

I lean towards the first interpretation - but I'm not sure.

## The Attempt at a Solution

Related Advanced Physics Homework Help News on Phys.org
TSny
Homework Helper
Gold Member
For an equation like (b), the zero on the right would normally be interpreted as the zero vector (rather than the zero scalar); or more precisely, it would be the ##\alpha## component of the zero vector (which would of course have a value of 0 in any coordinate system and any reference frame). So, I think your second interpretation is better.

• 1 person