1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data Here is the problem: http://img413.imageshack.us/img413/748/64my8.th.jpg [Broken] 3. The attempt at a solution I got the effective mass. That's trivial. My question is, what are these graphs actually of? The horizontal and vertical axes are not labeled. Is it an energy dispersion? If so, how come some of the curves are negative? All throughout the book, there is not a single energy dispersion curve with negative branches! It can't be the effective mass vs K, because the second derivative of E with respect to k is not a parabola. And besides, the question "which band has the higher effective mass" would not make much sense. I know that on the dispersion curve, the narrower bands have lower effective mass. But the negative bands are just throwing me off. I'm really frustrated. Please help if you can! Much thanks!