• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products via PF Here!

Electric Motors - Which way the force goes.

  • Thread starter Cummings
  • Start date
52
0
I uploaded the question i have to answer.

I am given a daigram of a simple DC electric motor.

I am asked to find which way the coil will spin at certain points

I have been using the right hand palm rule where my thumb points in the direction of the current and my fingers in the direction of the field. Thus the force exerted on the coil at certain poits will be in the direction of my palm.

The field always goes from North to south. and the current is shown so at point X the force should be out of the page. But the answers say its into the page.

is this right?
 

Attachments

52
0
well, your upload thingie dont work and i cant post images so i will give you a link to the question

http://cummingsiam.steven-sst.com/school/q.jpg [Broken]

may i sujest you allow images cos it makes it soooo much easyer.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
54
1
Originally posted by Cummings
The field always goes from North to south. and the current is shown so at point X the force should be out of the page. But the answers say its into the page.
Yes, into the page. I can only think that you've got your fingers the wrong way round or something. First finger field, second finger current as I remember being taught
:smile:
 
Last edited:
52
0
argh. I use the right hand palm rule where my thumb is the current through the wire, my fingers are the field(from north to south) and the force will be in the direction of my palm.

Does this way work with motors?
 
54
1
I've never heard of the right-hand palm rule as you described it [?].

I only heard of RH-rule for motors (thumb - movement, first finger - field, second finger - current), LH-rule for generators.
 

Dx

Originally posted by Cummings
argh. I use the right hand palm rule where my thumb is the current through the wire, my fingers are the field(from north to south) and the force will be in the direction of my palm.

Does this way work with motors?
Always remember current flows from negative to positive depending on your battery position. This is your curent direction (I), i see at X that the B (magnetic field)is pointing in a curling upward motion like position C. Your hand will be actually wrapped around the wire since thats the way your thumb points (think placing your hand on the wire like your grabbing it) see the direction now as the magnetic lines curl upward. Since my right hand thumb points towards the positive terminal of the battery current flows in that direction and B is fluxing in that upwardly motion as shown in your pic.

Cool pic BTW.
Later
Dx :wink:

Ask me anything about electronics, its my passion. Oh and computers!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
52
0
umm, i have been tought that electrons flow from the negative terminal to the positive terminal. As electrons are negative charges, this is the negative flow.

Current is determined by the positive flow - oposite to that of the flow of the electrons Thus going from positive to negative.

Also, the diagram states the current is in the direction of the arrow (positive to negative)

this question seems to be vert troubling. My teacher sais that my way is correct......that at X the force will be upwards
 
54
1
Yes, DX, convention current flow is positive to negative - think there's an arrow on the diagram. I think when they discovered that it really flowed in the opposite direction they'd already written too many texts with the current the 'wrong' way round they kept it as it was, lol :wink:
 
54
1
Cummings,
Fleming's Rule indicates the direction of force applied to an electric current by a magnetic field which is perpendicular to the said current; and the direction of an induced electromotive force generated in a conductor placed perpendicular to a magnetic field, when that conductor is moved perpendicular to the magnetic field. The former is governed by the left-hand rule: Using the left hand, if you point the middle finger in the direction of the current, and the index finger in the direction of the orientation of the magnetic field, the thumb will point in the direction of the force.
The latter is governed by the right-hand rule: Using the right hand, if you point the index finger in the direction of the orientation of the magnetic field, and point the thumb in the direction of the conductor's movement, the induced electromotive force generated is such that the current will be flowing in the direction indicated by the middle finger.
ie. this is LH-rule (!) Kind of alarming how I'd forgot the difference from not doing it for a few years lol.

I tapped google and also found a little on this RH palm rule - again disturbing that we were never taught this in school . Check out
http://www.bearwoodphysics.com/ph4.5.htm [Broken].

So after all that lol seems like you are right - force is out of the page.

hope that eventually helps:wink:

edit:to add some more, the RH palm rule is used to find the direction of field around a current carrying wire, you can see in the link.

Flemings left/right hand rules are when you have a conductor in a magnetic feld. LH when the wire carries a current and experiences a force due to the B-field, the RH rule to find the direction of the e.m.f induced in the conductor when it is moved perpendicular to the B-field.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
52
0
well, at least we got all that sorted out. I was looking through past examinations and my way corresponded to the correct answers so i was going to stick to it anyways.

Thanks for your help tho, this site is very, very handy.
 

Related Threads for: Electric Motors - Which way the force goes.

Replies
1
Views
665
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Posted
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
4
Views
401
  • Posted
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
7
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
782

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top