Electrons and Photons

  • Thread starter nuby
  • Start date
329
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

Are electrons actually just photons that are stuck in the orbit of an atom's nucleus?

Both photons and electrons are considered wave like particles, both are attracted to the nucleus of an atom, when an atom absorbs a photons energy it interacts with electrons,

Would a photon under centripetal force have more mass, like electrons?
 

Answers and Replies

Are electrons actually just photons
No. There are several differences between photons and electrons, though high energy photons can produce an electron and positron.

that are stuck in the orbit of an atom's nucleus?
Electrons DO NOT ORBIT the nucleus. If they orbited, the acceleration of the charge would produce photons making the electrons lose energy and fall to the nucleus.
 
1,899
45
Are electrons actually just photons that are stuck in the orbit of an atom's nucleus?
Not at all. Why do they give them a different name, then? Do you think that they wouldn't have noticed in almost a century? And what about electrons outside the atom?
Both photons and electrons are considered wave like particles, both are attracted to the nucleus of an atom
Not at all, photons are NOT attracted to the nucleus, they are not attracted to anything.
, when an atom absorbs a photons energy it interacts with electrons,

Would a photon under centripetal force have more mass, like electrons?
A photon cannot be under centripetal force but nontheless can be confined inside a finite region of space; then that region of space do really acquire a mass, equal to E/c^2 where E = photon's energy.
 
329
0
No. There are several differences between photons and electrons, though high energy photons can produce an electron and positron.

Electrons DO NOT ORBIT the nucleus. If they orbited, the acceleration of the charge would produce photons making the electrons lose energy and fall to the nucleus.

Interesting ... How does a high energy photon create an electron and positron, do you have a link?


How would you describe an electrons movement around an atoms nucleus? (in 2 sentences)
 
979
1
How would you describe an electrons movement around an atoms nucleus? (in 2 sentences)
The electrons are in stationary states --- there is no change in their probability distribution with time. Motion, especially trajectory, is not a defined concept in quantum mechanics.
 
jtbell
Mentor
15,404
3,198
Motion, especially trajectory, is not a defined concept in quantum mechanics.
At least not for a stationary state. For something like a non-stationary wave packet, you can think of d<x>/dt as corresponding to the classical velocity. I think I remember once calculating m d<x>/dt and <p> explicitly for a Gaussian wave packet to show that they're the same.

But even that only describes the motion of the packet as a whole, not the "actual" motion of the particle "inside" the packet.
 

Related Threads for: Electrons and Photons

  • Last Post
2
Replies
30
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
11
Views
846
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
1K
Replies
18
Views
2K
Top