Electrons and protons

  • Thread starter hetanshu
  • Start date
  • #1
2
0

Main Question or Discussion Point

why do electrons revolve around the nucleus?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
Doug Huffman
Gold Member
804
110
They do not. The revolution was a simple analogy to describe the probability distribution of an electron near a nucleon.
 
  • #3
2
0
so are they stationary?
 
  • #4
704
151
Nor that :)
Electrons, just like any other atomic particle, don't just exist in one specific point in space. They exist as a "cloud", and it's that cloud that envelops the nucleus.
Also note that the shapes of the clouds aren't spherical in most cases. Only the first "orbital" (i.e. the orbital of the electron in a hydrogen atom) is spherical. The more electrons around a nucleus, the more elaborate those shapes get. (e.g. http://chemwiki.ucdavis.edu/@api/deki/files/8855/Single_electron_orbitals.jpg )
 
Last edited:
  • #5
mathman
Science Advisor
7,771
419
A classical analogy (although a poor one) is the solar system. The planets go around the sun becaue the sun is much heavier. Electrons are much lighter than nuclei.
 
  • #6
jtbell
Mentor
15,523
3,374
The nature of quantum mechanics is that it doesn't say anything about what the electrons in an atom are "really doing" in terms of anything resembling a classical trajectory, when we are not "looking at" (i.e. measuring) them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cgk
  • #7
jfizzix
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
753
346
so are they stationary?
Quantum mechanics is only really prepared to tell us what we are likely to find if we measure something. What is really going on underneath it all is quantum metaphysics, which, though interesting, is far from being resolved.

The best we can do to describe what an electron is doing is to know what its wavefunction is. That will give us the probability of any outcome of any measurement we could to to look at the electron.

Oddly, enough, we can have wavefunctions of electrons which orbit the nucleus like planets in a solar system. These are highly excited states, where the electrons can be described classically. Hydrogen atoms in such highly excited states are known as Rydberg atoms.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cgk
  • #8
Electrons are stationary wave
They are not noving
 
  • #9
TeethWhitener
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,700
1,021
Electrons are stationary wave
They are not noving
Not true in general. You can see this by calculating the expectation value of the momentum of the electron from its wavefunction, and finding that the momentum is in general nonzero.
 
  • #10
jfizzix
Science Advisor
Insights Author
Gold Member
753
346
Electrons are stationary wave
They are not noving
The expectation value of the momentum [itex]\langle p \rangle[/itex] of an electron in a single orbital [itex](n, \ell, m_{\ell})[/itex] is indeed zero. This can be seen from Ehrenfest's theorem, and that the expectation value of the position is a constant for one of these eigenstates.

However, the variance of the momentum [itex]\sigma_{p}^{2}[/itex] is nonzero even in these states, which means that you are very likely to find the electron having a nonzero momentum if you actually measure it (it's only zero "on average").

Also, most electrons (I would think) exist in a superposition of different orbitals (i.e., their wavefunctions are not stationary, even if they are still concentrated around the nucleus). In this case, the expectation value of the momentum may change in time all sorts of ways.
 
  • #11
TeethWhitener
Science Advisor
Gold Member
1,700
1,021
The expectation value of the momentum [itex]\langle p \rangle[/itex] of an electron in a single orbital [itex](n, \ell, m_{\ell})[/itex] is indeed zero. This can be seen from Ehrenfest's theorem, and that the expectation value of the position is a constant for one of these eigenstates.

However, the variance of the momentum [itex]\sigma_{p}^{2}[/itex] is nonzero even in these states, which means that you are very likely to find the electron having a nonzero momentum if you actually measure it (it's only zero "on average").

Also, most electrons (I would think) exist in a superposition of different orbitals (i.e., their wavefunctions are not stationary, even if they are still concentrated around the nucleus). In this case, the expectation value of the momentum may change in time all sorts of ways.
Thank you for the clarification.
 
  • #12
Okk
Not true in general. You can see this by calculating the expectation value of the momentum of the electron from its wavefunction, and finding that the momentum is in general nonzero.
i will check
But your question is really awesom
 
  • #13
cgk
Science Advisor
521
42
The expectation value of the momentum [itex]\langle p \rangle[/itex] of an electron in a single orbital [itex](n, \ell, m_{\ell})[/itex] is indeed zero. This can be seen from Ehrenfest's theorem, and that the expectation value of the position is a constant for one of these eigenstates.
This may be nitpicking, but even in eigenstates [itex]\langle p \rangle[/itex] is only zero in one inertial frame---the one in which the nuclear core to which the electron belongs is at rest. If the entire atom is moving (core and all), the electrons have non-zero expectation values of momentum, too.

This is of course not very enlightening: In classical mechanics, the expectation value of momentum of an electron revolving around an stationary infinite mass is zero, too (both in the time-average and statistical average sense momentum averages to zero). This does not mean that there is no instantaneous movement. But, unlike classical mechanics, quantum mechanics does not actually tell us anything beyond expectation values. Thus, the best answer to the question of "does the quantum mechanical electron move?" was given in post #6 (jtbell) ND #7 (jfizzix): This question cannot be answered within the model of quantum mechanics.
 

Related Threads on Electrons and protons

  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
6
Views
4K
Replies
10
Views
15K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
10K
Replies
1
Views
3K
Top