Enthalpy of Formation of Ammonia: Why is it Positive?

  • Thread starter chikis
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Formation
In summary, the standard enthalpy of formation of ammonia from its elements should be negative, but due to a possible typing error in the given question, the answer provided is a positive value. It is important to discuss this concern with the teacher if the test paper allows for it.
  • #1
chikis
237
1

Homework Statement


We already know that standard heat or enthalpy of formation of a substance is the heat change in forming one mole of the compound from its element in their standard states.
Thus in the reaction the enthalpy of formation 2 mole of NH3 is 92kJ. Therefore the standard DH of formation = 92kJ/2= 46KJmol-1. What am now asking is this: why should the standard enthalpy of formation of ammonia be positive? Because I know that standard enthalpy of NH3 is suppose to be negative not positive.
Given that for the reaction,
N2(g)+3H2(g)---->
<----2NH3(g) deltaH=92kJ. What is the enthalpy of formation of ammonia from its elements?


Homework Equations





The Attempt at a Solution



We already know that standard heat or enthalpy of formation of a substance is the heat change in forming one mole of the compound from its element in their standard states.
Thus in the reaction the enthalpy of formation 2 mole of NH3 is 92kJ. Therefore the standard DH of formation = 92kJ/2= 46KJmol-1. What am now asking is this: why should the standard enthalpy of formation of ammonia be positive? Because I know that standard enthalpy of NH3 is suppose to be negative not positive.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
So you are having problem with sign convention?

Well, it is negative sign. You might have been given the absolute value. Sign just shows whether the reaction would be is endothermic or exothermic.
 
  • #3
AGNuke said:
So you are having problem with sign convention?

Well, it is negative sign. You might have been given the absolute value. Sign just shows whether the reaction would be is endothermic or exothermic.

But atleast, the sign for enthalpy of formatation of 2 mole of NH3 is suppose to be -92, so that when we get the standard enthalpy of formation for just 1 mole of NH3, it will become -46kJ/mol instead of +46KJ/mol. This is because the reaction leading to the formation of NH3 is exothermic. There must have been an error (typo) by the authors of problem as they wrote +92kJ as the enthalpy of formation of 2 mole of NH3 instead of -92kJ. Do you agree with me on that?
 
  • #4
The authors might have given the absolute value of enthalpy of formation. So, it might be the case.
 
  • #5
So then what is the meaning of the word "absolute value" as it relates to this concept?
 
  • #6
Value without sign convention used.
 
  • #7
I think Is important at this juncture that I post the choices:
A. -46kJmol-1 B. -184kJmol-1 C. -92kJmol-1 D. 184kJmol-1 E. +46kJmol-1
If you were in my shoe, what option will you choose?
 
  • #8
Given that for the reaction,
N2(g)+3H2(g)---->
<----2NH3(g) deltaH=92kJ. What is the enthalpy of formation of ammonia from its elements?

If these are the exact terms that the question was expressed in, then you have no choice but to put down option (E.) even though you know it to be wrong/unrealistic. The teacher cannot mark this (wrong) answer wrong. If the test paper is not strict multiple choice, then you should qualify your answer by briefly writing your concerns about a misprint in the question, because you are quite right.

I am a retired university teacher. As a student I always found multiple choice tests very unfair for just this sort of reason. Often an answer to a question must be qualified, not only for a misprint. For example, if no temperature is given, am I supposed to assume 0°C, 25°C, or 0 K? Or if, for whatever reason, none of the answers offered is close to the one I get and I think I can see where an unjustified approximation has been used. As a teacher I tried to avoid them.

Dealing with multiple choice papers is often more a matter of game tactics than science. My advice to you in terms of game tactics is to choose the answer (E.) and to discuss your problem with it if the paper allows for that possibility.
 
  • #9
JohnRC said:
If these are the exact terms that the question was expressed in, then you have no choice but to put down option (E.) even though you know it to be wrong/unrealistic. The teacher cannot mark this (wrong) answer wrong. If the test paper is not strict multiple choice, then you should qualify your answer by briefly writing your concerns about a misprint in the question, because you are quite right.

I am a retired university teacher. As a student I always found multiple choice tests very unfair for just this sort of reason. Often an answer to a question must be qualified, not only for a misprint. For example, if no temperature is given, am I supposed to assume 0°C, 25°C, or 0 K? Or if, for whatever reason, none of the answers offered is close to the one I get and I think I can see where an unjustified approximation has been used. As a teacher I tried to avoid them.

Dealing with multiple choice papers is often more a matter of game tactics than science. My advice to you in terms of game tactics is to choose the answer (E.) and to discuss your problem with it if the paper allows for that possibility.

You know what? This question is actually a worked question with answers. I was actually trying my hands on it to test my knowledge. The funny thing about the question, is that the answer that was provided for the question is choice A. -46kJ/mol which the correct answer. But if you work strictly with the data given, you are going to have E. +46KJ/mol instead of -46kJ/mol.
 
  • #10
Most probably a typing error in the question on their part, nothing to beat the bush around.
 
  • #11
AGNuke said:
Most probably a typing error in the question on their part, nothing to beat the bush around.

Thanks for helping!
 

1. What is enthalpy of formation?

The enthalpy of formation is the amount of energy required to form one mole of a substance from its constituent elements in their standard states.

2. Why is the enthalpy of formation of ammonia positive?

The enthalpy of formation of ammonia is positive because it requires energy to break the bonds between the constituent elements (nitrogen and hydrogen) and form new bonds to create ammonia. This process is endothermic, meaning it absorbs heat.

3. What factors affect the enthalpy of formation of ammonia?

The enthalpy of formation of ammonia is affected by the bond energies of the constituent elements, the temperature and pressure at which the reaction occurs, and the presence of any catalysts or inhibitors.

4. How is the enthalpy of formation of ammonia determined experimentally?

The enthalpy of formation of ammonia can be determined experimentally by measuring the amount of heat released or absorbed during the formation of ammonia using a calorimeter. This value can then be compared to the theoretical enthalpy of formation calculated using bond energies.

5. What are the applications of knowing the enthalpy of formation of ammonia?

Knowing the enthalpy of formation of ammonia is important for understanding the thermodynamics of the reaction and predicting its feasibility. It also has practical applications in industries such as fertilizer production, where ammonia is a key component, and in research and development of new energy sources such as ammonia-based fuel cells.

Similar threads

  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
13K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
14K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Biology and Chemistry Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
10K
Back
Top