Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter

In summary: Sitter) but they were all turned down because they seemed to bring up unphysical concepts like "negative energy".Since 1998 with the accelerated expansion surprise and "dark energy" there is more going in that direction.Wouldn't that leave you with a completely new stress-energy tensor with two components(simplifying a lot): one negative "dark" energy (pressure) and one "gravitational" positive energy pressure?No, I don't think so.
  • #1
Ranku
410
18
Cosmological constant dark energy has equation of state parameter = -1. What is the equation of state parameter of gravitational energy?
 
Space news on Phys.org
  • #2
Ranku said:
Cosmological constant dark energy has equation of state parameter = -1. What is the equation of state parameter of gravitational energy?
There isn't one. In the standard formulation of General Relativity, there is no such thing as gravitational energy.
 
  • #3
Chalnoth said:
There isn't one. In the standard formulation of General Relativity, there is no such thing as gravitational energy.

Since dark energy density is related to negative pressure, is there no way to construct a relation between 'positive pressure' and 'gravitational energy density', even though gravitational energy does not occur in general relativity?
 
  • #4
Ranku said:
Since dark energy density is related to negative pressure, is there no way to construct a relation between 'positive pressure' and 'gravitational energy density', even though gravitational energy does not occur in general relativity?
No, I don't think so.

One way you could do it, though, is through the conservation of the stress-energy tensor. The stress-energy tensor is a 2nd-rank tensor (sort of like a matrix) that includes components such as energy, momentum, pressure, and shear (shear includes things like twisting forces). This tensor is always conserved in a very particular way: its so-called covariant derivative is zero.

If you examine this conservation law in flat space-time, you get an energy transport equation: the time rate of change of energy in a region of space is equal to the flow of energy into/out of that region.

However, in curved space-time things get a little bit more complicated. What you could do is make up a new "total energy density" which is always conserved: as in the flat space-time example, the total energy density within a region of space-time only changes if it flows from one place to another. You could do this by adding an extra term to the equations that exactly cancels the extra terms you get from curved space-time, and call this your gravitational potential energy.
 
  • #5
Chalnoth said:
No, I don't think so.

One way you could do it, though, is through the conservation of the stress-energy tensor. The stress-energy tensor is a 2nd-rank tensor (sort of like a matrix) that includes components such as energy, momentum, pressure, and shear (shear includes things like twisting forces). This tensor is always conserved in a very particular way: its so-called covariant derivative is zero.

If you examine this conservation law in flat space-time, you get an energy transport equation: the time rate of change of energy in a region of space is equal to the flow of energy into/out of that region.

However, in curved space-time things get a little bit more complicated. What you could do is make up a new "total energy density" which is always conserved: as in the flat space-time example, the total energy density within a region of space-time only changes if it flows from one place to another. You could do this by adding an extra term to the equations that exactly cancels the extra terms you get from curved space-time, and call this your gravitational potential energy.

Hmm...interesting. Well it's good to know that a positive pressure:gravitational energy relation could at least be considered, whether it works or not.
Thanks.
 
  • #6
Would't that leave you with a completely new stress-energy tensor with two components(simplifying a lot): one negative "dark" energy (pressure) and one "gravitational" positive energy pressure?
It's interesting, if a bit radical. In the past there have been attempts along those lines with negative and positive gravity or with inertia versus gravity(de Sitter) but they were all turned down because they seemed to bring up unphysical concepts like "negative energy".Since 1998 with the accelerated expansion surprise and "dark energy" there is more going in that direction.
 
  • #7
AWA said:
Would't that leave you with a completely new stress-energy tensor with two components(simplifying a lot): one negative "dark" energy (pressure) and one "gravitational" positive energy pressure?
Hmm, that's not what I was talking about. The basic idea is this. If we have massless particles in flat space-time, we can write energy conservation as:

[tex]\frac{d\rho}{dt} = -\bigtriangledown \vec{p}c[/tex]

That is, for the energy density in a region of space can only change if some of that energy flows into or out of the region. When we have curved space-time, we instead have:

[tex]\frac{d\rho}{dt} = -\bigtriangledown \vec{p}c + [/tex]curvature-related terms

I won't bother to look up the precise form of the curvature-related terms on the right hand side. But suffice it to say it's always possible to write energy conservation in this way. So I could simply make up "gravitational potential energy" and set it to the negative of those curvature-related terms. Then I would have conservation of total energy again.

This has nothing to do with making up a new tensor, just making up a new quantity.

AWA said:
It's interesting, if a bit radical. In the past there have been attempts along those lines with negative and positive gravity or with inertia versus gravity(de Sitter) but they were all turned down because they seemed to bring up unphysical concepts like "negative energy".Since 1998 with the accelerated expansion surprise and "dark energy" there is more going in that direction.
Er, dark energy must have a positive energy density to produce an accelerated expansion.
 
  • #8
Ok, and wouldn't adding that new made up quantity change anything in the tensor,at least conceptually?
About dark energy sign, I know itis supposed to have conventionally positive density to attain
accelaration, but as the OP spoke in terms of negative pressure and we were calling "gravitational energy" positive I switched the signs,but I coul have made the gravitational energy negative and dark energy positive since the point seeemed to be that they are opposite and cancel each other out. Let's not get hung up about the signs here.
 
  • #9
AWA said:
Ok, and wouldn't adding that new made up quantity change anything in the tensor,at least conceptually?
No, the tensor remains exactly the same. This would just be a way of talking about gravitational potential energy.
 

1. What is the Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter?

The Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter, also known as the Gravitational Energy Density Ratio, is a measure of the ratio between the energy density of the universe and the critical energy density required for the universe to have a flat geometry. It is denoted by the symbol ΩΛ.

2. How is the Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter calculated?

The Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter is calculated by dividing the observed energy density of the universe by the critical energy density. The critical energy density is determined by the Hubble constant, which is a measure of the expansion rate of the universe.

3. What does a value of ΩΛ greater than 1 mean?

If the Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter is greater than 1, it indicates that the energy density of the universe is higher than the critical energy density. This suggests that the universe has a positive curvature and will continue to expand forever.

4. What does a value of ΩΛ less than 1 mean?

If the Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter is less than 1, it means that the energy density of the universe is lower than the critical energy density. This indicates that the universe has a negative curvature and will eventually collapse in a "big crunch" scenario.

5. Why is the Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter important?

The Gravitational Energy Equation of State Parameter is an important measure in cosmology as it helps us understand the overall geometry and fate of the universe. It also plays a crucial role in determining the expansion rate of the universe and the amount of dark energy present. A precise measurement of this parameter can provide valuable insights into the fundamental nature of our universe.

Similar threads

Replies
7
Views
650
Replies
6
Views
1K
  • Cosmology
Replies
3
Views
987
Replies
3
Views
856
Replies
19
Views
378
  • Cosmology
Replies
9
Views
364
Replies
1
Views
784
Replies
2
Views
413
Replies
2
Views
653
Back
Top