hey all,(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

in this link :http://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k7258/f122.image

The equation 2b is not correct I believe. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

Here we go :

The equation mentioned reads : R^{αβλ}_{μ}R_{αβλρ}= 2 * 1/8 * R^{αβλμ}R_{αβλμ}g_{μρ}

Now multiply out by g^{μρ}on both sides and elevate the μ index on the LHS, we would end up having :

R^{αβλε}g_{με}R_{αβλρ}g^{μρ}=

2 * 1/8 * R^{αβλμ}R_{αβλμ}g_{μρ}g^{μρ}

This becomes :

R^{αβλε}δ_{ε}^{ρ}R_{αβλρ}=

2 * 1/8 * R^{αβλμ}R_{αβλμ}g_{μρ}g^{μρ}

which leads to :

R^{αβλρ}R_{αβλρ}= 2 * 1/8 * R^{αβλμ}R_{αβλμ}g_{μρ}g^{μρ}

On the RHS, do we agree that the indices on the g's are not to be summed over since they are fixed ones ? This means that the product of the g's is 1 (if they were summation indices, we would get 4 and not 1) , which results in :

R^{αβλρ}R_{αβλρ}= 2 * 1/8 * R^{αβλμ}R_{αβλμ}

But THIS IS WRONG ! the μ on the LHS of the equation should not be the same μ as on the RHS since it is a fixed index I believe.

thank you,

Cheers,

PS: I have seen the referenced Lanczos paper but there is no way you can tell how Bel ended up with that one !

PS: Here :http://arxiv.org/pdf/1006.3168v4

in the first paragraph, the author is referring to another variant of the Lanczos formula ! and this is correct I think

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**

Join Physics Forums Today!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

# Error in Bel's 1958 article ? Lanczos formula incorrectly reported

Loading...

Similar Threads for Error Bel's article | Date |
---|---|

B Error about the twin paradox in Einstein's biography? | May 18, 2017 |

I Lorentz invariant integration - where is the error? | Mar 2, 2017 |

I Complex number 'isomorphism' error | Nov 20, 2016 |

B Error in laws of motion | Apr 10, 2016 |

Bel decomposition in 6-d | Mar 18, 2011 |

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**