• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products Here!

Everyday Control Feedback

  • Thread starter phiby
  • Start date
  • #1
75
0

Homework Statement


Identify 10 feedback systems that you encounter in your everyday environment. For each system, identify the sensing mechanism, actuation mechanism and control computation. Describe the uncertainty with respect to which the feedback system provides robustness and/or the dynamics that are changed through the use of feedback.


Homework Equations


NA

The Attempt at a Solution



1) Toilet water tank
Sensing mechanism - Float
Actuation mechanism - When the water level goes down, the float goes down which it opens the fill valve. As the water fills the tank, the float goes up & at a certain point, closes the fill valve.
Control Computation - No idea
Uncertainty/robustness etc - Not sure

2) Cruise Control
Sensing mechanism - whatever measures the speed in a car.
Actuation - Solenoid driven throttle and brake?
Control Compution - ?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure

3) Elevator
Sensing mechanism - Sensors at each floor level.
Actuation - Sensors stop the elevator?
Control Compution -?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure

4) Climate Control
Sensing mechanism - thermometer
Actuation - ON/OFF of compressor.
Control Compution - ?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure


???
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
berkeman
Mentor
56,853
6,836

Homework Statement


Identify 10 feedback systems that you encounter in your everyday environment. For each system, identify the sensing mechanism, actuation mechanism and control computation. Describe the uncertainty with respect to which the feedback system provides robustness and/or the dynamics that are changed through the use of feedback.


Homework Equations


NA

The Attempt at a Solution



1) Toilet water tank
Sensing mechanism - Float
Actuation mechanism - When the water level goes down, the float goes down which it opens the fill valve. As the water fills the tank, the float goes up & at a certain point, closes the fill valve.
Control Computation - No idea
Uncertainty/robustness etc - Not sure

2) Cruise Control
Sensing mechanism - whatever measures the speed in a car.
Actuation - Solenoid driven throttle and brake?
Control Compution - ?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure

3) Elevator
Sensing mechanism - Sensors at each floor level.
Actuation - Sensors stop the elevator?
Control Compution -?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure

4) Climate Control
Sensing mechanism - thermometer
Actuation - ON/OFF of compressor.
Control Compution - ?
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure


???
That's a great start! Keep going....

Think of some that involve a human as the feedback part...

Think of more electronic examples....

You already have automotive cruise control, but how did the old steam engines control their speed...?
 
  • #3
75
0
That's a great start! Keep going....

Think of some that involve a human as the feedback part...

Think of more electronic examples....

You already have automotive cruise control, but how did the old steam engines control their speed...?
Watt's governor :-)

Anyway I have no idea what to write in the control computation, robustness etc etc.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
36
0
Hi Phiby, I will help with one of your current choices and maybe that can help with the others.

2) Cruise Control
Sensing mechanism - whatever measures the speed in a car. Tachometer/Speedometer
Actuation - Solenoid driven throttle and brake? Good but lever not solenoid
Control Compution - ? Comparison of desired set speed to actual speed
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure Makes adjustments for sudden changes in inclination (speeds up or slows down)
 
  • #5
75
0
Hi Phiby, I will help with one of your current choices and maybe that can help with the others.

2) Cruise Control
Sensing mechanism - whatever measures the speed in a car. Tachometer/Speedometer
Actuation - Solenoid driven throttle and brake? Good but lever not solenoid
Control Compution - ? Comparison of desired set speed to actual speed
Uncertainty/Robustness - not sure Makes adjustments for sudden changes in inclination (speeds up or slows down)
Thank you. In Actuation - what lever are you referring to?
 

Related Threads on Everyday Control Feedback

  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
17
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
466
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
789
Top