• Support PF! Buy your school textbooks, materials and every day products via PF Here!

Explain this to me

  • Thread starter tnutty
  • Start date
327
1
1. Homework Statement

A 55kg mass is tied to a massless rope wrapped around a solid cylindrical drum. The drum is mounted on a frictionless horizontal axle. When the mass is released, it falls with acceleration 1.0m/s^2 .

Find the tension in the rope.

my answer : 484N

the way I got is by doing this : 55(9.8-1.0).

I did this because my friend told me this but am confused on
why I have to subtract g from acceleration. Please explain in details.
 

LowlyPion

Homework Helper
3,079
4
1. Homework Statement

A 55kg mass is tied to a massless rope wrapped around a solid cylindrical drum. The drum is mounted on a frictionless horizontal axle. When the mass is released, it falls with acceleration 1.0m/s^2 .

Find the tension in the rope.

my answer : 484N

the way I got is by doing this : 55(9.8-1.0).

I did this because my friend told me this but am confused on
why I have to subtract g from acceleration. Please explain in details.
If there was no retarding force then the acceleration from gravity would have been unaffected. So for acceleration to be just 1, then there must be a counteracting force that relates to 9.8 - 1 ... in order to end with 1 as your acceleration.
 
327
1
This statement confuses me :
When the mass is released, it falls with acceleration 1.0m/s^2 .

Its falling down at 1 meters per second per second. This makes me think that
with gravity counted, it falls at 1 m/s/s.
 

LowlyPion

Homework Helper
3,079
4
This statement confuses me :
When the mass is released, it falls with acceleration 1.0m/s^2 .

Its falling down at 1 meters per second per second. This makes me think that
with gravity counted, it falls at 1 m/s/s.
Right it does mean that.

It means that gravity is accelerating it at 9.8 and the drum is decelerating it at 8.8. The 8.8 then is the Tension in the cable.

Otherwise if it was free falling it would be slack.
 
327
1
Why should it not be decelerating at 1m/s/s instead of accelerating at 1m/s/s.
It seems like if if its accelerating then we should add 1.0 instead of subtract.
 

tiny-tim

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
25,790
246
Ftotal = ma …

and Ftotal = mg - T :wink:
 
327
1
Ya but why is tension m*8.8 instead of m*10.8. After all it is falling 1.0m/s/s with the
gravity? It just seems counter intuitive to me.
 

LowlyPion

Homework Helper
3,079
4
Ya but why is tension m*8.8 instead of m*10.8. After all it is falling 1.0m/s/s with the
gravity? It just seems counter intuitive to me.
No. It's not falling 1m/s2 faster than gravity.

It's falling at just 1m/s2

If it was static what would the Tension be? m*g right? And it's not moving.

So as TinyTim pointed out the tension will be m*g less the net acceleration of 1 m/s2
 
327
1
So the net acceleration is 1m/s/s.

If so then why isn't m*a = m*(1). Isn't a the net acceleration?
 

tiny-tim

Science Advisor
Homework Helper
25,790
246

Related Threads for: Explain this to me

  • Posted
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
412
Replies
2
Views
4K
Replies
3
Views
2K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top