Sorry for the length of the post, the problem I've included is not difficult but I wanted to have an example to help illustrate my question.(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});

solve:

[tex]\sqrt{x}-\sqrt[4]{x} -2=0 [/tex]

.

.

.

[tex](x-16)(x-1)=0[/tex]

The roots are 16 and 1, however when one puts them back into the original equation, 1 is found to be extraneous leaving 16 as the only solution. My question is, why do extraneous roots arise?

I attempted to answer the question myself by reversing the above process and putting 1 in for x at each step to see when the equation becomes "invalid" for the extraneous root.

[tex](x-16)(x-1)=0[/tex]

[tex]x^{2}-17x+16=0[/tex]

[tex]x^{2}-17x+16+25x=25x[/tex]

[tex]x^{2}+8x+16=25x[/tex]

[tex](x+4)^{2}=25x[/tex]

[tex]x+4=5\sqrt{x}[/tex]

[tex]x+4-4\sqrt{x}=5\sqrt{x}-4\sqrt{x}[/tex]

[tex]x+4-4\sqrt{x}=\sqrt{x}[/tex]

[tex](\sqrt{x}-2)^{2}=\sqrt{x}[/tex]

[tex](\sqrt{x}-2)^{2}=\sqrt{x}[/tex] equation A

[tex]\sqrt{x}-2=\sqrt[4]{x}[/tex] equation B

[tex]\sqrt{x}-\sqrt[4]{x}-2=0[/tex]

Putting 1 in for x in equation A works but B does not. It seems that going from A to B creates the problem. When one takes the square root of equation A the left side becomes

[tex]((\sqrt{x}-2)^{2})^{\frac{1}{2}}[/tex]

If I understood CompuChip's answer correctly to one of my previous posts, the inner to outer priority is not followed. If 1 is in for x, then -1 is the value in the first set of parenthesis and then -1 squared is 1, and then the square root is also 1. However if 1 is not in for x , since the roots are not known when one first goes through the problem, the squared to the 1/2 power gives what's in the parenthesis to the first power, which is just what's in the parenthesis. Then when 1 is in for x, we have -1 to the first power which is -1. The order of operations makes a difference for x=1 but does not for x=16.

Is it true then, that extraneous roots arise because some mathematical operation is violated for that root?

Thanks for any answers.

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**

# Extraneous roots

Know someone interested in this topic? Share a link to this question via email,
Google+,
Twitter, or
Facebook

Have something to add?

- Similar discussions for: Extraneous roots

Loading...

**Physics Forums - The Fusion of Science and Community**