Does Earth's Rotation Affect Our Perception of Weight?

In summary: Earth's surface. It has nothing to do with the true g of Earth's interior.So while you could deduce the spin of the Earth by traveling North and South and noting the difference in gravity as you did so, and this difference would be easier to measure as the speed of rotation increased, you still wouldn't be able to "feel" it when standing in one spot.In summary, the Earth would have to rotate extremely fast for us to feel the effect of rotation and have no doubt of its rotation.
  • #1
Thecla
131
10
In the early 17 th century people argued that the Earth can't be rotating because the don't feel any movement. How fast would the Earth have to rotate for us to feel the effect of rotation and have no doubt of its rotation?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
This is a question of how sensitive you are to rotation. An ordinary person is not sensitive to Earth's rotation because it is 'always there', just as he is not sensitive to his heart beat. That is if you wan to feel it directly with your senses. However, the object of science is not to rely on our subjective sensual feelings but to look for objective evidences. In the case of the Earth rotation, one could look at the pattern of a hurricanes - swirling around instead of radially converging. Another example of sensing the Earth rotation if Foulcault's pendulum.
 
  • Like
Likes Ralph Dratman
  • #3
Let's put it this way: If the Earth was spinning fast enough so that it attained orbital speed at the equator, then objects at the equator would be "weightless". However this still only results in the Earth making 1 rotation in roughly 90 min. Could you easily detect that you were rotating that slow?.
So while you could deduce the spin of the Earth by traveling North and South and noting the difference in gravity as you did so, and this difference would be easier to measure as the speed of rotation increased, you still wouldn't be able to "feel" it when standing in one spot.
 
  • Like
Likes Ralph Dratman
  • #4
Thecla said:
How fast would the Earth have to rotate for us to feel the effect of rotation and have no doubt of its rotation?

Were you thinking of physical effects such as inner ear confusion when you asked? In that case, you can use SpinCalc to determine at what point the Earth's rotation falls outside 'comfort zone'.
 
  • Like
Likes mfb and symbolipoint
  • #5
Thecla said:
How fast would the Earth have to rotate for us to feel the effect of rotation and have no doubt of its rotation?
There is a possible way of estimating this - or at least putting a lower limit on it. Consider life on a ship. The crew (even on a very small one) very soon get used to the curved courses that ships take and they easily cancel it out in their brains. The rate of turn on a large tanker is a lot faster than the Earth's motion and, more importantly, it is not uniform over time but I wouldn't mind betting that experienced crew would be able to detect some very slight course adjustments. To put a figure on it, perhaps 360°/hour would be too slow to be detectable (compared with 24hours we all experience).
But I like to bring these questions down to good old Evolution and ask what would be the point in being excessively sensitive to rotation. According to lore, we tend to walk in circles when left with no obvious direction reference so that implies we are actually not very sensitive at all to this sort of thing. Perhaps that's not a fair test, in view of all the other clues (moss on N side of trees etc.) but those are 'intellectual' clues and not innate. Migrating animals have to make use of the Earth's Magnetic field and not (afaik) Coriolis force.
 
  • #6
This question has much to do with human physiology and little to do with physics.

Human perception of acceleration has a big deadband. Flight simulators take advantage of that to give pilot trainees the illusion of unlimited motion even though the actual motion of the simulator is limited.
242023
 
  • Like
Likes symbolipoint, russ_watters and Nik_2213
  • #7
Janus said:
Let's put it this way: If the Earth was spinning fast enough so that it attained orbital speed at the equator, then objects at the equator would be "weightless". However this still only results in the Earth making 1 rotation in roughly 90 min. Could you easily detect that you were rotating that slow?.
So while you could deduce the spin of the Earth by traveling North and South and noting the difference in gravity as you did so, and this difference would be easier to measure as the speed of rotation increased, you still wouldn't be able to "feel" it when standing in one spot.
Right: there is nothing to "feel" except the magnitude of the acceleration and there is no way to tell the difference between gravitational and rotational. If you're on a different planet with a 10% different apparent g, you might notice, but there's no way to tell by "feel" how much of that is gravity and how much is rotation.

(Note: oblate sphereoid = uniform apparent g).
 
  • #8
russ_watters said:
(Note: oblate sphereoid = uniform apparent g).
What do you mean?
 
  • #9
A.T. said:
What do you mean?
Earth's surface is equipotential to the extent it fits the theoretical geoid. The g you measure with an accelerometer while sitting on Earth's surface does not vary with latitude:
https://www.e-education.psu.edu/geog862/node/1820
Earth's shape is caused by that g.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Likes anorlunda and sophiecentaur
  • #10
russ_watters said:
Earth's surface is equipotential to the extent it fits the theoretical geoid. The g you measure with an accelerometer while sitting on Earth's surface does not vary with latitude:
Wait a minute. Potential does not change with latitude. But the g you measure with an accelerometer is not potential. It is the [magnitude of the] gradient of the potential.

The g you measure with an acceleometer while sitting on the Earth's surface most certainly does vary with latitude.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_of_Earth#Latitude
Earth's shape is caused by that g.
Yes. The geoid will always be at right angles to the local direction of ##\vec g##. That's not the same thing as saying that it is a surface where local ##\vec g## has a fixed magnitude.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #11
  • Like
Likes phinds and jbriggs444
  • #12
russ_watters said:
If you're on a different planet with a 10% different apparent g, you might notice,
Definitely - you notice very small slopes when cycling (and running) because of the different rate you have to work at.
 
  • #13
sophiecentaur said:
Definitely - you notice very small slopes when cycling (and running) because of the different rate you have to work at.
But we are not talking about any slopes. Just an equipotential surface -- flat and level.
 
  • #14
jbriggs444 said:
But we are not talking about any slopes. Just an equipotential surface -- flat and level.
I was thinking that mgh (Work) would be noticeable when lifting and climbing. Going up a slope is the equivalent of a bigger g. (I think that must be right) I wouldn't just be Weight Force that counts in general 'getting around' in a different g. But it al depends what the rules are to this particular game, I think.
 
  • #15
sophiecentaur said:
Going up a slope is the equivalent of a bigger g.
When cycling, the bicycle takes care of the vertical load. Bigger g is irrelevant. Slope and wind resistance are the enemies. Good wheel bearings and properly inflated tires make rolling resistance (which can scale with g) largely irrelevant.

Agree that we're likely quibbling about rules :-)
 
  • #16
jbriggs444 said:
Bigger g is irrelevant
I see what you mean - I shouldn't compare flat cycling with cycling up a slope. But two different slopes would be a valid analogue with the broader experience in different g conditions but we would have to define more precisely what we are comparing with what (before it's handbags at dawn time). Power is actually what counts in getting you exhausted and mg dh/dt has contributions from g and dh/dt. Or, if you carry extra weight up hill, of course. I know from my limited cycling experience that changes in slope are very noticeable, even when you are fit.
The suggested 10% would definitely be noticeable. I was at the gym today and 10% extra load is very noticeable after a set of 12 reps.
 
  • Like
Likes jbriggs444
  • #17
Great answer! What a fascinating thought.
 
  • #18
Is there a change of velocity for us circuling the sun? (as small as it might be, since we are talking about lack of changes of velocity being detected of us on the Earth as far as rotation).
the Earth rotates the sun every 365ish days, at a velocity near 66,000mph. because we spin a the equator at near 1000mph, does this mean we have a 1000mph change of velocity around the sun as viewed from the surface of the Earth relative to the sun? (i.e. 67,000mph at night and 65,000mph at night). Is this another case of the percentage of velocity change being so small that we can't feel it?
 
  • #19
zanick said:
Is this another case of the percentage of velocity change being so small that we can't feel it?
Percentage velocity change is neither well defined nor observable. That's basic Galilean relativity.
 
  • Like
Likes russ_watters
  • #20
jbriggs444 said:
Percentage velocity change is neither well defined nor observable. That's basic Galilean relativity.
True... so the change of velocity of 1000mph, over 12 hours I so slight of an acceleration that we couldn't feel it. is that better? (1.3mph per min, ave rate of change)
 
  • #21
zanick said:
True... so the change of velocity of 1000mph, over 12 hours I so slight of an acceleration that we couldn't feel it. is that better? (1.3mph per min, ave rate of change)
Yes, that is better.

Back of the envelope: 1.3 miles per hour per minute is around 1.5 feet per second per minute. 1.5 feet per second per second would be about 1/20 of a gee. We are talking about 60 times less than that. So about one tenth of one percent of a gee.

Meanwhile you are busy standing, sitting and walking around in one gee. A tenth of a percent is in the noise. Your bathroom scale cannot detect it either.
 
  • #22
Hang on; Is there actually anything to feel here at all? The acceleration is constant and circular, not linear and reciprocating. I don't think the issue is that it's too small to be noticeable but that there is nothing to notice, not even in theory...Per post #19.

The only thing that I can see changing is due to solar tides, not the change in a person's linear speed around the sun.

I know I was wrong about g changing with latitude, but...
 
  • Like
Likes jbriggs444
  • #23
You can't feel or measure that your velocity relative to the Sun is changing without astronomical observations. That is one of the key results of physics: There is no absolute velocity. The velocity relative to X can only be measured if you have a way to compare yourself to X (e.g. use astronomical measurements).

What you can measure is a small change in the apparent gravitational acceleration (relative to the surface of Earth) during a day. At noon it is slightly smaller as you are pulled more towards the Sun than Earth, at sunset and sunrise it takes its largest values, at midnight it is slightly smaller as the Earth is pulled more towards the Sun than you. The Moon has a similar (and stronger) effect. Both together create the tides on Earth due to this.
 
  • #24
As I recall the weight difference attributed to the Earth's rotation is about 0.3% at the equator. So a man weighing 100kg weighs about 300g less at the equator due to the rotation. You don't feel that much lighter because its constant so you have nothing to compare it with. Do you feel 300g heavier after drinking a can of soda?
 
  • #25
anorlunda said:
This question has much to do with human physiology and little to do with physics.

Human perception of acceleration has a big deadband. Flight simulators take advantage of that to give pilot trainees the illusion of unlimited motion even though the actual motion of the simulator is limited.View attachment 242023

I very much agree with this. This not a physics question.

Besides, no matter how good we think our senses are, humans have a very poor and very limited range of ability as a detector of many things.

Zz.
 
  • #26
ZapperZ said:
I very much agree with this. This not a physics question.

Besides, no matter how good we think our senses are, humans have a very poor and very limited range of ability as a detector of many things.

Zz.
especially when there is nothing to detect. we don't detect velocity, but change in velocity. I think the "weight" thing is the only thing we could detect, if you could detect anything... but .3% change in weight, unless you were instantly teleported from the north pole to the equator would be near impossible too. do you feel your weight go up after eating a big steak? ;)
 
  • #27
zanick said:
do you feel your weight go up after eating a big steak? ;)

No, but I feel my volume increase. 😉
 
  • Haha
Likes anorlunda

1. What does it mean to "feel the Earth rotate"?

Feeling the Earth rotate refers to the sensation of movement or motion caused by the Earth's rotation on its axis. This rotation is what causes day and night, and can also be felt through the Earth's gravitational pull and the Coriolis effect.

2. Is it possible to physically feel the Earth rotating?

No, it is not possible to physically feel the Earth rotating. The Earth rotates at a constant speed of 1670 kilometers per hour at the equator, which is too slow for humans to feel. Additionally, our bodies are constantly moving with the Earth, so we do not perceive any movement.

3. How do scientists know that the Earth is rotating?

Scientists use a variety of methods to determine that the Earth is rotating. These include observations of the stars and sun, the Coriolis effect, and the Foucault pendulum. These experiments and observations provide evidence that the Earth is indeed rotating on its axis.

4. Does the Earth's rotation affect our daily lives?

Yes, the Earth's rotation affects our daily lives in many ways. It is responsible for the cycle of day and night, which influences our sleep patterns and daily routines. The Earth's rotation also contributes to weather patterns and the Coriolis effect, which affects ocean currents and wind patterns.

5. Is the Earth's rotation slowing down or speeding up?

The Earth's rotation is actually slowing down, but at a very gradual rate. This is due to tidal forces from the moon and the sun, as well as the Earth's own internal processes. However, the changes in rotation speed are so small that they are not noticeable to humans and do not significantly impact our daily lives.

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
820
Replies
2
Views
709
  • Classical Physics
Replies
19
Views
903
Replies
22
Views
968
Replies
24
Views
3K
Replies
22
Views
1K
Replies
38
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
683
  • Mechanics
Replies
10
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
1K
Back
Top