1. Not finding help here? Sign up for a free 30min tutor trial with Chegg Tutors
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Find the acceleration

  1. Mar 28, 2015 #1
    What is the initial acceleration of mass 5M .The pulleys are ideal and the string inextensible.


    My attempt-

    2Mg-T=2Ma (for 2M)
    T=Ma (for M)

    Solving we get T=2Mg/3

    T-N=5MA (for 5M)
    N=2MA (for 2M)

    Solving we get A=2g/21
    but the given ans. is 2g/23
  2. jcsd
  3. Mar 28, 2015 #2

    Simon Bridge

    User Avatar
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper
    Gold Member
    2016 Award

    Welcome to PF;
    You should always post the reasoning you used for your working otherwise it's just a bunch of letters and numbers.

    Note, there are three forces on the 2M mass.
    What is T and N for the 5M mass? Presumably that is not the same T as for the 1M and 2M masses.
    Last edited: Mar 28, 2015
  4. Mar 28, 2015 #3
    Hi Himanshu

    Yes 2g/23 is the correct acceleration. I think the main reason you are getting a wrong answer is because you are using Newton's laws which become very complicated when you have systems which have moving parts (moving relative to each other) because then, in addition to reaction forces (i.e. contact forces such as normal reaction) you also need to consider the so called "pseudo/inertial forces" since relative accelerations are computed in non-inertial frames e.g. forces on the smaller blocks w.r.t 5M block. But instead if you write down the lagrangian, the correct expression pops out in a two lines of algebra/calculus. This is how I solved this problem:

    Let X(t) is the position of the left end of the 5M block from some fixed inertial frame origin of coordinates, say O. Let x(t) be the position of the block of mass M (sitting atop of 5M) wrt to the left pully/left edge of 5M block. And let L be distance of the 2M mass block from the left edge of the 5M block (L remains unchanged as 2m block always remains in contact with 5M). This means with respect to the inertial frame origin, O

    a) the x-axis coordinate of top mass (M) block is XM = x(t)+X(t) while
    b) the horizontal coordinate of 2M mass block is "X2M =X(t)+L", and
    c) the vertical/y coordinate of 2M mass block is "Y2M = x(t)" (because top block and 2M block are connected by an inextensible string, so horizontal displacement of top block on 5M mass by x means 2M block gets pulled up by equal amount x).

    Now we can write down the lagrangian, which is difference of kinetic and potential energies,
    L= 1/2 (5M) (V2)+ 1/2 (M) (dxM/dt)2 + 1/2 (2M) (dX2M/dt+dY2M/dt 2)

    = 1/2 (5M) (V2) + 1/2 (M) (V+v)^2+ 1/2 (2M) (V2+v2) - 2M g x

    where V= dX/dt, v= dx/dt and we have used, Y2M = x(t). So the lagrangian is a function of x,v,V.

    The lagrange's equations are then,
    d(∂L/∂v)/dt = ∂L/∂x,
    d(∂L/∂V)/dt = ∂L/∂X.

    The first equation simply gives, acceleration of the top box is, a = -2g/3 -A/3 while the second equation gives, 8 A + a =0. Substituting expression for a from the first into the second, I get, A = 2g/23!

    Lagrangian method is very straightforward compared to Newton's laws where you have to first make free body diagrams WITH all contact reaction forces and pseudoforces. Students inevitably make mistakes when doing that second step, like you did. All you have to do is just write down the lagrangian and then take derivatives and wallah! the result stares at you.

    Of course I am assuming that you know what derivatives/ differential calculus is and that the velocity is first derivative of position/dispalcement while acceleration is the second derivative of displacement/position. V =dX/dt, A = dV/dt
    Last edited: Mar 28, 2015
  5. Mar 28, 2015 #4


    User Avatar
    Staff Emeritus
    Science Advisor
    Homework Helper

    Homework and HW type problems should be posted in the appropriate HW forum after filling out the HW template.
  6. Mar 28, 2015 #5
    Of course if you are unfamiliar with lagrangian or differential calc. and are forced to work with Newton's laws, then you have to proceed with Newton's laws. In that case I would point out the mistake in your steps.

    "T=Ma (for M)"

    is incorrect, you forgot to add the pseudo force, M A to the right. This is needed because "a" being the acceleration of the 2M block sliding down is the "acceleration of top block, M relative to the 5M". Since it is relative to 5M which is an non-inertial frame we need to add a pseudo force. If 5M is moving with an acceleration, A to the left then the pseudo force of the top block, is M A to the right (while the pseudo force on the sliding down 2M block is 2M A to the right). So the correct equation is,

    T - MA = Ma.

    This corrected equation plus your first equation (i.e. 2Mg-T=2Ma) gives,

    a = 2g/3 - A/3.
    while, T = 2M (g+A)/3.

    Now your second mistake is in the fourth equation for the horizontal motion of the mass 2M block. You wrote:
    N=2MA (for 2M)

    But, the Normal force from the 5M block pushes 2M to the right, i.e. N is acting to the right while the pseudo force is ALSO acting to the right. So the correct equation is, N + 2MA= 0.

    Combine this with your third equation, i.e. N - T = 5MA, you get,

    T = - 7 MA, which then combined with previous expression for T, gives.

    A = -2g/23.

    So the block actually moves to the RIGHT.
  7. Apr 16, 2015 #6


    User Avatar
    Science Advisor

    wallah: a native or inhabitant of a specified place, or a person concerned or involved with a specified thing or business. "a rickshaw-wallah".

    voila: an exclamation meaning “there it is” or “there you are”. From the French voilà = "here it is!"
Know someone interested in this topic? Share this thread via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook

Have something to add?
Draft saved Draft deleted

Similar Discussions: Find the acceleration
  1. Finding Acceleration (Replies: 3)

  2. Find the Acceleration (Replies: 11)

  3. Find acceleration (Replies: 4)

  4. Finding acceleration (Replies: 18)