Fluid Dynamics question -- compressibily of brake fluids "oil"

In summary, the difference between the two fluids is a 25% difference, and it is plausible to tell the difference between the street and the two racing fluids.
  • #1
zanick
383
23
As part of a racing community, there is a discussion going on that talks about compressibility of brake fluid. the Street car versions have a value of 6.5E-05 and the racing stuff is 4.5E-05 both at a pressure of near 5000psi. there is talk about the difference of the racing fluids which compare two for example , with a 25% difference between the two.. 4.6E-05 vs 4.5E-05.
is it possible that someone could feel the difference in brake pedal pressure, in a car with the two different fluids in the system , comprised of fluid lines, calipers , and actuation systems (master cylinders made up of springs and seals along with brake pedals attached to long levers)?
intuitively, we are talking about a very very small difference in compressibility for fluid in general, and the difference of the two , even if 25% greater is a very very small value as well. for those familiar with automobile braking systems there is a knowledge that the fluid also can absorb water which boils at above 100C and the fluid itself which can boil at temps in the 280C range certainly when it boils under extreme racing conditions, the pedal does feel much softer until the fluid is replaced or the water or brake fluid , condenses back to fluid again.

as far as compressibility of the fluid,, could the compresibility of the fluid actually be felt before any of the heat based factors take effect? keep in mind that the braking system is comprised of :
50ft of 2mm diameter brake lines, calipers with reserviors and pistons/seals, and a master cylinder with a plunger (like a 10mm syringe) and a foot long pedal

thanks for reviewing my quesiton
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
If we assume that the system holds one liter of brake fluid in the high pressure circuit (that's high, but it's also a round number and since I'm doing the arithmetic in my head and .1 liter feels a bit low, we'll go with it) the the difference in compressibility works out to be ##2\times{10}^{-2}## cc. 10mm for the master cylinder diameter feels low (maybe not for a race application), but if we go with that value one centimeter of piston travel will displace about 3/4 of a cc. So the compressibility difference will yield an extra .3 millimeters or so of piston travel. Assume a 30ish to one multiplier from the pedal (that's high) and you might get something on the order of one centimeter of additional pedal travel.

One centimeter? I can imagine a world-class driver looking for a thousandth of a second as he enters a turn noticing this. (Me, flopping around the autocross course? I have bigger problems - I just blew a full second trying to miss that cone and everyone is laughing at me).

And note that every number in the back of the envelope calculation was chosen in the direction of maximum effect: high volume of fluid, small master cylinder, high leverage from the pedal. I wouldn't be surprised to find that in a real design we're only talking about a few millimeters of pedal travel from the extra compressibility.
 
  • Like
Likes 256bits
  • #3
A very well described and thought out reply.
 
  • #4
+1
 
  • #5
zanick said:
As part of a racing community, there is a discussion going on that talks about compressibility of brake fluid. the Street car versions have a value of 6.5E-05 and the racing stuff is 4.5E-05 both at a pressure of near 5000psi. there is talk about the difference of the racing fluids which compare two for example , with a 25% difference between the two.. 4.6E-05 vs 4.5E-05.

Your math needs checking here. There is only a 2% difference between 4.5E-5 and 4.6E-5.
 
  • #6
SteamKing said:
Your math needs checking here. There is only a 2% difference between 4.5E-5 and 4.6E-5.
I was referring to the difference between the street fluid and the racing type being near 25%...so the real question is it plausible to tell the difference between the street and the two racing fluids... 4.6 vs 6.4 or 4.6 vs 6.5E-5
 

1. What is the compressibility of brake fluid?

The compressibility of brake fluid is a measure of how much the volume of the fluid changes when pressure is applied. It is typically very low, meaning that brake fluid is not easily compressed and is able to maintain a consistent volume under varying pressures.

2. Why is the compressibility of brake fluid important?

The compressibility of brake fluid is important because it affects the performance of a vehicle's braking system. If the fluid is too compressible, it can lead to a spongy or soft brake pedal, making it more difficult to stop the vehicle quickly and safely.

3. How is the compressibility of brake fluid measured?

The compressibility of brake fluid is typically measured using a bulk modulus test. This test involves subjecting a sample of the fluid to increasing pressure and measuring the change in volume. The higher the bulk modulus, the lower the compressibility of the fluid.

4. Are all brake fluids equally compressible?

No, not all brake fluids are equally compressible. DOT 3 and DOT 4 brake fluids are typically less compressible than DOT 5 and DOT 5.1 fluids. The latter two are silicone-based and have higher compressibility, which is why they are not recommended for vehicles with anti-lock braking systems (ABS).

5. How does the compressibility of brake fluid change with temperature?

The compressibility of brake fluid can increase with higher temperatures. This is because heat causes the molecules of the fluid to move more quickly, making it easier for them to be compressed. This is why it is important to choose a brake fluid with a low compressibility and a high boiling point to ensure optimal performance under varying temperatures.

Similar threads

Replies
48
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • General Engineering
Replies
15
Views
2K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
14
Views
1K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
12
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
6K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
3
Views
1K
  • Sci-Fi Writing and World Building
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
14
Views
3K
Back
Top