Friction and Rolling of a disk

In summary, the ball will not go up a frictionless ramp. Without friction, the ball will be spinning and reach lower height. With friction, the ball will stop spinning and reach a higher height.
  • #1
joej24
78
0

Homework Statement


Disk a and b are identical and roll across a floor with equal speeds. Disk a rolls up an incline, reaching a max height h, and disk B moves up an incline that is identical except that it is frctionless. Is the max height reached by disk b greater than, less than, or equal to h?


Homework Equations


Conservation of Energy


The Attempt at a Solution


Both disks have the same initial kinetic energies. When they go up the ramp, wouldn't friction oppose the way of motion for the wheels? I don't understand how friction would help the wheel move up higher.

I also thought that energy of disk a would be spent in heat from the friction too, making it have a max height less than that of disk b.

The answer is that disk b reaches a max height less than that of disk a
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Take a vertical disk that's rotating:

Set it down on a frictionless surface. What happens? It keeps rotating but doesn't move.

Set it down on a surface with some friction. What happens? It starts rolling & its rate of rotation decreases.
 
  • #3
There is static friction when the disk rolls. Static friction do not cause loss of mechanical energy, but it means torque that changes angular speed. When the disk rolls upward, the speed of its CM is equal to the angular speed times the radius. When the kinetic energy decreases with height, both the angular speed and the translational speed decrease.
Without friction, there is no torque so the angular speed does not change. The rotational energy stays the same. When the disk does not travel further, it is still rotating. So it reaches lower height.

ehild
 
  • #4
So, the ball won't go up the frictionless ramp. In a way, friction pushes the ball up then. How can this be explained with conservation of energy? Shouldn't the ball have more energy if it went up a frictionless ramp?
 
  • #5
What does Cm stand for?
 
  • #6
Center of mass

ehild
 
  • #7
hi joej24! :smile:
joej24 said:
So, the ball won't go up the frictionless ramp.

no, it will

friction on rolling things is needed to accelerate them …

friction is not needed to keep them at the same speed

a car moving at 30 mph and going onto a patch of ice will stay at 30 mph …

if it meets a hill of ice, it will move up the hill exactly as if it had no wheels and was just sliding on its chassis …

if the ice ran out half-way up the hill, the car would keep going, but the wheels would start to take up some of the energy …

basically this whole problem is about how much of the energy goes into the linear motion of the disc, and how much into the rotational motion :wink:

btw, note the careful wording of the question …
Disk a rolls up an incline, reaching a max height h, and disk B moves up an incline that is identical except that it is frctionless​
… A rolls, but B "moves" (ie, doesn't roll)!
 
  • #8
The ball loses a lot more energy while rolling up a frictionless ramp, than when it actually rolls up a ramp.
If you use the equation mgh=1/2mv2+1/2I(omega)2 where I equals the moment of inertia of the ball and omega equals (v2/r2)

and if you use just mgh=1/2mv2, the ball that is rolling has its rotational inertia, so It will roll further up the ramp than the ball that just slides.
 
  • #9
Yes, if there's no friction, the ball will still be spinning when it reaches maximum height,

but if there is friction, the the ball will be stationary when it reaches maximum height, so more kinetic energy will have been lost by the ball, and so it will have more potential energy (ie height). :smile:
 
  • #10
So the friction makes the ball lose angular speed. Eventually, the ball will stop spinning. No torque is acted upon the ball going up the frictionless ramp, so it keeps on spinning. So since more kinetic energy is used up by the one going to ramp with friction, the more energy is converted to potential energy (higher height). And since the other ball keeps its rotational kinetic energy, less energy was converted to potential then.

Is this right?
 
  • #11
Yes.

ehild
 

1. What is friction and how does it affect the rolling of a disk?

Friction is the resistance to motion between two surfaces in contact. In the case of a rolling disk, friction occurs between the disk and the surface it is rolling on. Friction can either help or hinder the rolling motion, depending on the surface and other factors such as weight and speed of the disk.

2. How does the shape of a disk affect its rolling motion?

The shape of a disk can greatly impact its rolling motion. A disk with a larger diameter will have a larger surface area in contact with the ground, resulting in more friction and slower rolling. A disk with a smaller diameter will have less surface area and therefore less friction, allowing it to roll faster.

3. What is the difference between sliding friction and rolling friction?

Sliding friction occurs when two surfaces are in contact and one is sliding over the other, creating resistance and slowing down the motion. Rolling friction, on the other hand, occurs when a round object, such as a disk, is moving across a surface, with only a small portion of its surface in contact with the ground, resulting in less friction and allowing for faster rolling.

4. How does the surface material affect the friction and rolling of a disk?

The surface material can have a significant impact on the friction and rolling of a disk. A rougher surface will result in more friction and slower rolling, while a smoother surface will have less friction and allow for faster rolling. Additionally, the material of the disk itself can also affect the friction, as different materials have different levels of friction with certain surfaces.

5. What factors can affect the amount of friction and rolling of a disk?

The amount of friction and rolling of a disk can be affected by various factors, including the weight and shape of the disk, the surface it is rolling on, the speed at which it is rolling, and the material of both the disk and the surface. Additionally, external forces such as wind and inclines can also impact the friction and rolling of a disk.

Similar threads

Replies
24
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
32
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
18
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
18
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
30
Views
2K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
14
Views
2K
Back
Top