Which Materials Are Good Electron-Hole Conductors and Affordable?

  • Thread starter Stanley514
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Conductor
In summary, the conversation is about materials that exhibit good electron and hole conductivity simultaneously, as well as being cheap and available. Silicon is mentioned as meeting these requirements, as well as tungsten which has a negative Hall coefficient indicating hole conductivity. Other materials suggested include semimetals such as arsenic, antimony, and bismuth, as well as narrow gap semiconductors like grey tin and graphite. The concept of semimetals and semiconductors is discussed, with grey tin being a possible example of a material with both electronic band structure and semimetallic properties. The conversation also touches on the maximum voltage that p-type semiconductors can withstand.
  • #1
Stanley514
411
2
Which materials exhibit good electron and hole conductivity in the same time?
And which of them are cheap and available?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Silicon meets all of the requirements you have listed.
 
  • #3
Silicon meets all of the requirements you have listed.
Something much better than intrinsic semiconductors?I need hole conductivity comparable to electron conductivity in metals.And electronic conductivity too.
 
  • #4
sure. Tungsten conducts electricity through holes and this is shown through the Hall coefficient being negative.
 
  • #5
Tungsten conducts electricity through holes and this is shown through the Hall coefficient being negative.
Seem to be wrong.
The negative Hall coefficient indicates that electrons are the charge carriers
www.phys.utk.edu/labs/modphys/Hall Effect.pdf
I was not able to find any mention in In-et that Tungsten is hole conductor.
Could you give any link about it? I need some material that is electrone-hole conductor at room temperature and could conduct holes in all directions under usual circumstances.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
Probably all the semi-metals, e.g. Bismuth.
 
  • #7
what do you need this for? Understanding the question better will (hopefully) result in better answers...
 
  • #8
what do you need this for? Understanding the question better will (hopefully) result in better answers...
New concepts are not allowed to reveal and discuss here.
But I phrased my question clear enough.
 
  • #9
Stanley514 said:
Which materials exhibit good electron and hole conductivity in the same time?
And which of them are cheap and available?
You may be looking for a semimetal.

Arsenic, antimony, and bismuth are semimetals that are cheap and available.
Be very careful working with that arsenic.

Graphite is usually found in multicrystal form. I don't think the multicrystal form is a good conductor. Single crystal graphite are quite expensive. However, graphite would be safe.

Alpha-tin may be interesting. There may be a temperature issue.

Here is a link and quote on semimetals.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semimetal
“The semimetallic state is similar to the metallic state but in semimetals both holes and electrons contribute to electrical conduction. With some semimetals, like arsenic and antimony, there is a temperature-independent carrier density below room temperature (as in metals) while, in bismuth, this is true at very low temperatures but at higher temperatures the carrier density increases with temperature giving rise to a semimetal-semiconductor transition.

The classic semimetallic elements are arsenic, antimony, bismuth, α-tin (gray tin) and graphite, an allotrope of carbon.”
 
  • #10
Stanley514 said:
Which materials exhibit good electron and hole conductivity in the same time?
And which of them are cheap and available?

You may also find some “narrow gap semiconductors” that are useful in their intrinsic (nearly pure) form.

A narrow gap semiconductor would be an insulator at absolute zero. However, the band gap is small. If the band gap is small enough, thermal excitations will produce both electrons and holes even at room temperature. Therefore, a narrow band semiconductor would be a lot like a semimetal.

I made a mistake in another post. Grey tin is a narrow gap semiconductor, not a semimetal. For your purposes, they may be the same. After all, both narrow gap semiconductors and semimetals have both conduction-electrons and valence-holes at room temperature.

Other narrow gap semiconductors include PbS, InAs,, HgCdSe, PbSe. A bigger list is found in the following link.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narrow-gap_semiconductor
“Narrow gap semiconductors are semiconducting materials with a band gap that is comparatively small compared to silicon. They are used as infrared detectors or thermoelectrics.”

I discussed semimetals in a separate post.
 
  • #11
Darwin123 said:
Grey tin is a narrow gap semiconductor, not a semimetal.

Are you sure?
 
  • #12
As I know the best hole mobility among pure semiconductors has Grmanium.But it still not too high.Do not know about semimetals.Maybe you could give link with exact data?I know that excellent hole conductivity is expected for graphene,but it is rare and expensive.What would be approx. price of one-crystall graphite?Is it brittle?I need material with hole conductivity which would be comparable to at least electron conductivity in carbon.Also graphite as I know,doesn't conduct current in all directions.Only in one of them it seems.I was not able to find any clear mentioning in In-et about hole conductivity in graphite.
One more question: what is the max. voltage that p-type semiconductors are able to withstand?
 
Last edited:
  • #13
DrDu said:
Are you sure?

No.

I am doing a search on it. However, I get answers that vary with the reference.

Here is on link and quote on the subject of grey tin. I don’t know what the author is talking about. I had thought that the electronic structure determines whether a material is a semiconductor or semimetal.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metalloid
“Grey tin has the same crystalline structure as that of the diamond allotrope of carbon. It behaves as if it was a semiconductor (with a band gap of 0.08 eV) but has the electronic band structure of a semimetal.[361] It is sometimes referred to as a metalloid.”


The author here implies that there is a definition for semimetal that does not incorporate electronic structure.

Now I am curious. Could someone help me out here? How should grey tin be classified, exactly?

Regardless, grey tin is a material which at higher temperatures has both electrons and holes. However, grey tin is unstable at room temperature. Therefore, grey tin probably doesn't satisfy the requirements of the original poster (OP).
 
  • #14
Darwin123 said:
No.

“Grey tin has the same crystalline structure as that of the diamond allotrope of carbon. It behaves as if it was a semiconductor (with a band gap of 0.08 eV) but has the electronic band structure of a semimetal.[361] It is sometimes referred to as a metalloid.”

I think he is maybe referring to a direct band gap of 0.08 eV . Semimetals often have a vanishing indirect band gap but a non-vanishing direct band gap, i.e. there are electron and hole pockets.
These band structures are lately of great interest as spin orbit coupling may lead to topological insulators.
 
  • #15
It is claimed that some metals (such as Iron) have positive Hall coeficient.But it seems that Hall effect is observed in strong magnetic fields only.Does it mean that in absence of strong fields Iron will have very small hole conductivity?
 
  • #16
No, the type of charge carriers is independent of the field. You only need the field for diagnostic purposes. However I would be careful with the interpretation of the Hall coefficient in terms of nature of the charge carriers.
 
  • #17
You need to look for a conductor which has the value of (carrier conc. x avg. mobility) same for both electrons and holes. I don't think such thing naturally exists.
 
  • #18
[STRIKE]I think you need a conductor for which (carrier conc. x avg. mobility) is same for both electrons and holes. That kind of thing does not exist naturally[/STRIKE]

EDIT: Damn forgetful mind.
 
  • #19
DrDu said:
No, the type of charge carriers is independent of the field. You only need the field for diagnostic purposes. However I would be careful with the interpretation of the Hall coefficient in terms of nature of the charge carriers.

Especially in ferromagnetic materials. Magnetic fields don't penetrate ferromagnetic materials very well. So the "anomalous Hall effect" in iron may be caused by something other than the charge of the carrier. It may have something to do with the ferromagnetism.
 
  • #20
Probably there should be some metal alloy with anomalously low effective mass of holes.
 

1. What is a good electron-hole conductor?

A good electron-hole conductor is a material that is able to conduct both electrons and holes, which are the two types of charge carriers in a semiconductor. It should have a high electrical conductivity and low resistance in order to efficiently transport charges.

2. How does a material become a good electron-hole conductor?

A material becomes a good electron-hole conductor when it has a balanced number of electrons and holes, as well as a low band gap energy. This allows for efficient movement of charges through the material.

3. What are some examples of good electron-hole conductors?

Silicon, germanium, and gallium arsenide are all examples of good electron-hole conductors commonly used in electronic devices. Other examples include indium phosphide and cadmium telluride.

4. What are the applications of good electron-hole conductors?

Good electron-hole conductors are essential for electronic devices such as transistors, solar cells, and LEDs. They are also used in optoelectronic devices, sensors, and integrated circuits.

5. How is the efficiency of a good electron-hole conductor measured?

The efficiency of a good electron-hole conductor is measured by its carrier mobility, which is the ability of the material to transport charges. It is also measured by its conductivity, band gap energy, and other properties such as thermal stability and reliability.

Similar threads

  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
14
Views
4K
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
7
Views
1K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
647
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
2
Views
4K
  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
5
Views
4K
Back
Top