Good or Evil - Which is the better investment?

  • Thread starter BobG
  • Start date
In summary, the author believes that corporate America is amoral and that true democracy can be enacted by backing up one's beliefs with one's own money. The author prefers to invest in funds that are not endorsed by the Catholic Advisory Board. The author feels that both vice and traditional investing are sound options, but believes that porn addiction is not a serious issue.
  • #1
BobG
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
352
86
I thought the article, http://slate.msn.com/id/2123644/ [Broken], was an interesting take on investing.

For the most part, corporate America is amoral. Investment decisions are made on expected returns, not how good or evil the companies might be. Now, you can customize your investments by buying funds and investments endorsed by the Catholic Advisory Board (no companies dealing in pornography, abortion, or benefits for same sex domestic partners, etc) or by buying funds that specialize in vice (casinos, tobacco companies, beer companies, etc).

While it seems kind of humorous at first glance, it's actually a valid idea. True democracy in action by backing up your beliefs with your own money - a weapon that has more influence on corporate behavior than a "nice" or "mean" image.

Which would you choose:

http://www.avemariafund.com/avemx.htm [Broken]?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
The good, I don't like dirty money.

I know people barely 20 who have their own porn website. I would have never guessed a moral person would set up something like that, but they do it just for the money: it's big bussiness. I would never invest any time or money into that.
 
  • #3
Vice looks like its the better investment at the moment. That said, I doubt either of these constitutes a sound long-term investment. I'd have to go the traditional 'amoral' route.

By the way, I fail to see what's wrong with owning a porn website. As long as the people are consenting - and if your site is legal, they are - who cares? I don't exactly like the idea of investing in the "human failings" business, though, profiting from alcohol and cigarette addiction and gambling and all that. Then again, I suppose many people are addicted to porn. Of course, a porn addiction doesn't physically damage your brain/body or drain the family bank account and the kids' college funds.
 

1. What is the definition of "good" and "evil" in this context?

In this context, "good" refers to actions or behaviors that are considered morally right or beneficial, while "evil" refers to actions or behaviors that are considered morally wrong or harmful.

2. Can "good" and "evil" be objectively measured and compared?

As a scientist, I believe that everything can be measured and compared, including abstract concepts like "good" and "evil". However, the way in which they are measured and compared may vary depending on individual beliefs and values.

3. Is there a clear answer to which is the better investment?

It is difficult to determine a definitive answer to which is the better investment, as it ultimately depends on the individual's personal beliefs and values. Some may argue that investing in "good" actions brings more long-term benefits and creates a better world, while others may argue that investing in "evil" actions can bring immediate gratification and success.

4. How does investing in "good" or "evil" affect the individual and society?

Investing in "good" actions can lead to personal fulfillment and contribute to a more positive and compassionate society. On the other hand, investing in "evil" actions can lead to feelings of guilt and contribute to a more negative and harmful society.

5. Are there any scientific studies or evidence to support the benefits of investing in "good" over "evil"?

There have been numerous scientific studies that have shown the positive effects of "good" actions, such as volunteering and helping others, on mental and physical well-being. These actions have also been shown to create a ripple effect, inspiring others to do good as well. On the other hand, there is also evidence of the negative effects of "evil" actions, such as aggression and violence, on individuals and society.

Similar threads

  • Atomic and Condensed Matter
Replies
4
Views
6K
Replies
3
Views
3K
Back
Top