Dismiss Notice
Join Physics Forums Today!
The friendliest, high quality science and math community on the planet! Everyone who loves science is here!

Here's something to tickle your painstaking calculation-bone with

  1. Apr 30, 2003 #1
    I dunno if it qualifies for "funny" bone, necessarily..

    Anyway, this problem is really off the charts for me at my current 3 AM IQ level (likely 40 points below what it was four hours ago..)

    This one is just for fun, if you think you can solve it.. even if someone digs up an answer somehow, it'll only get me 70% of 5/80 points on an assignment, so don't feel like I need you (and if there's someone who really needs help soon, you oughtta move along)

    (insert picture of an arrow, then 105 cm, then a convex-on-each-side lens with a focal length of 31 cm, then 51 cm, then a concave mirror with a focal length of 41cm)

    "An optical system consists of a convex lens of focal length f1 = 31 cm and a concave mirror of focal length f2 = 41 cm. The lens and mirror are co-axial and are spaced a distance a = 51 cm apart.

    An upright object is located a distance d = 105 cm to the left of the lens. The image of this object formed by the lens serves in turn as the object for the mirror. The subsequent image formed by the mirror serves as the object for the lens as it acts on the (left moving) rays that have been reflected from the mirror. The lens forms the final image.

    (a) Calculate the location of the final image, as measured from the point where the lens cuts the optical axis.

    d' = cm
    -79.08 NO

    HELP: The second paragraph of the problem statement gives you the essential part of the overall strategy for finding the answer. What's involved is a three-step application of the imaging equation: step 1, the lens equation; step 2 the mirror equation; and step 3, the lens equation, again. The only aspects of this problem that make it more complicated than three independent imaging calculations is that you must make a coordinate change - add or subtract the spacing between two optical elements - when you convert a computed image distance from optical element into an object distance for the next optical element.
    HELP: To keep track of the coordinate changes, the orientation of images, and the reality or virtuality of images, diagrams are needed. These should be the three Principal Ray Diagrams corresponding to each optical element. Draw these sequentially after you know from step 1 what kind of image is formed and where it is located, etc. Note: the three principal rays for optical element 1 (the lens) will generally not be principal rays for optical element 2 (the mirror), etc. No problem. Just start over in each step treating the image formed by the previous step as the new object. Sometimes the object will be "virtual", but that may or may not occur in this problem.

    Computer systems used in optical design work differently. They trace rays through the entire optical system. This has many advantages including the ability to calculate image intensities and optical aberrations. Your textbook has a complete discussion of the latter very important topic. The advent of computer design tools for optical systems has contributed greatly to improvements in quality and reductions in costs."

    I dunno, I just can't get the numbers to work out right.. does anyone maybe just have some ray-tracing software? Oddly enough, I have a copy of 3dsmax, but I think that calculating the necessary index of refraction for a virtual lens that I make and the proper curvature for a virtual mirror would prove to be much more difficult than spending a few hours and working this problem out correctly
  2. jcsd
  3. Apr 30, 2003 #2
    Hey, guys, never mind about this problem

    It turns out that I was working on the regular section's homework, and the homework for the honors section (which I'm in) doesn't have this part due until next week
Share this great discussion with others via Reddit, Google+, Twitter, or Facebook