News How long to take baghdad?

  • Thread starter Viper
  • Start date
53
0
How long do you think it will take us to take baghdad (us I mean the coalittion. Do you think the republican gaurd will offer much fight?
 
9
0
I would go for about three weeks. In the previous three weeks, things have gone well for the 'Coalition', now they have their hardest part.
In three weeks time I will look back to see how wrong I was.
 
53
0
I think the republican gaurd will put up quite a fight. I feel that saddams airport will be an important capture.
 
54
1
What's kinda freaky is that Saddam is now saying that victory is nearer thatn ever (for his regime)
 
53
0
Im not siding with him but I suppose he has to say something to keep his remaining troops moral up.

But is he dead?
 

russ_watters

Mentor
18,866
5,050
Initially I had said this whole war would take two weeks (oops). Toward the end of week two, I said two more - so I'll go with one more week now. The army and marine corps have sliced through the few republican guard divisions they have faced like a hot knife through butter.
 

N_Quire

I hope the Republican Guard turns out to be all smoke and bluster when compared with superior coalition forces. Within two weeks, Baghdad should be under coalition control even though sporadic fighting might continue. There is now no doubt that the war has been won.
 

drag

Science Advisor
1,055
0
Greetings !

It is extremely difficult to estimate this.
First of all, because we have little data
avalible to us and because we are not military
stratagists... :wink:

Further more, the ease of the coalition's advance
is somewhat "fishy". It is possible that seeing
they have no real chances many forces were pulled
back to defend Baghdad itself. It is also possible
that the regime is falling apart and will soon
disappear all by itself - where are the hundreds
of phousands of soldiers if there are 10,000 PoWs
and hardly so little forces seemingly left.
It is also possible that Saddam will use WMDs,
in which case the war probably won't be slowed
down but many civilians will die.

In short, I have no idea...:wink:

Live long and prosper.
 

damgo

The Republican Guard is putting up virtually no fight, to the point where I'm half-worried. Where the heck are they? Apparently I'm not the only one:
"This is weird," said Col. William F. Grimsley, commander of the division's First Brigade, whose troops led the assault on the airport, about 10 miles from the heart of Baghdad. "It's like spooky weird." His forces had faced only light resistance at dusk and then later virtually no resistance at all.

Colonel Grimsley and other officers speculated that the Iraqi soldiers had deserted or had died after more than two weeks of aerial bombardment, including intense strikes on the airport itself in the last 48 hours. Others were at a loss. "I'm flabbergasted," said Capt. Michael J. MacKinnon, a staff officer with the brigade's tactical command post.

In at least one case it created an acute edginess. "They're there," Sgt. Maj. Gary J. Coker, an engineer, said as he arrived Thursday night, gesturing into the blackness. "They're out there right now."
http://www.nytimes.com/2003/04/04/international/worldspecial/04INFA.html?pagewanted=1&ei=1&en=29ff3e54b0cd4a63&ex=1050433911

I'm guessing 2 weeks - 2 months to take Baghdad, depending on how they go about it. Maybe a month past that for the rest of the war, assuming all goes well.
 
53
0
Good post, they just seem to have dissapeared
 

Zargawee

Duhh !

I wonder how did you judge that War will end in two weeks or less ... this is not afghanistan , this is iraq ... and remember Iraqies make their weapons by their own , so they can make more weapons in order to face the allies forces .

Baghdad is the city that cannot be entered this easy , if would take very long time to enter Baghdad .


I Have something to tell , If the war didn't end in two weeks , allies forves might end up loosing forves because of the heat and sand there , Our area is a very hot one ... Your troops might not bear it.
 

Alias

Re: Duhh !

Originally posted by Zargawee
I wonder how did you judge that War will end in two weeks or less ... this is not afghanistan , this is iraq ... and remember Iraqies make their weapons by their own , so they can make more weapons in order to face the allies forces .

Baghdad is the city that cannot be entered this easy , if would take very long time to enter Baghdad .
We've been driving in and out of Baghdad for the last 24 hours at will.
 
53
0
Im not sure what youve been told in America but in England at the time of posting they say that there are coallition troops walking around baghdad!!
 

damgo

The "we can move around Baghdad at will" line isn't really IMO accurate... we do have the airport, and made one lightning raid through the city. It's not like troops are just driving downtown and hanging out... there are enough defensive forces in the city that they'd get massacred. A BBC correspondent there referred to the raid (somewhat tactlessly) as the "world's biggest drive-by shooting" which is sorta accurate.

Not to downplay the raid though... it was damn impressive, they just ran straight down the highway, through heavy fire at 30-40 kph, blowing the **** out of every target in sight. Look at http://www.gomemphis.com/mca/america_at_war/article/0,1426,MCA_945_1868008,00.html .
 
53
0
Aparetnly this morning they killed a thousand Iraqis, can you imagine it. Another thing in ww1 we lost 40.00 a day at the somme. We lose 1,2,3 a day in Iraq pandermonium.
Funny
 
54
1
Re: Duhh !

Originally posted by Zargawee
I wonder how did you judge that War will end in two weeks or less ... this is not afghanistan , this is iraq ... and remember Iraqies make their weapons by their own , so they can make more weapons in order to face the allies forces .

Baghdad is the city that cannot be entered this easy , if would take very long time to enter Baghdad .


I Have something to tell , If the war didn't end in two weeks , allies forves might end up loosing forves because of the heat and sand there , Our area is a very hot one ... Your troops might not bear it.
Like Alias said.

By the way, I believe the severe temperature would cause more problems for equipment than the troops.
 

BoulderHead

I think the lack of effective opposition to the advancement of the invading army ought to make people think twice about all the pro-war hype they were/are fed...or not, haha
 

kat

12
0
I think the issue with the heat is also that it's impossible to wear the chem suits once it reaches a certain tempature, which is why the rush to start before the mid april heat waves.


Boulder-my suspicion is that it's a mixture of hype and Saddam's own hands on mismanagement. There were firsthand reports of how Saddam enforced loyalty by it's top officers by planting camera's within their homes, tapped their phones and took movies of their daughters being raped and then used them to threaten humiliation to the families. I would think this wouldn't make for very loyal troops.
 
53
0
Ian says it will all be over soon. Ian is the keeper of all knowlege and buddha in his spare time
 
54
1
Originally posted by BoulderHead
I think the lack of effective opposition to the advancement of the invading army
Yeah we killed them all on the run in to Baghdad.

Not long now folks - Saddam's time is nearly up. The people of Baghdad will soon be celebrating like the people of Basra.
 
53
0
Did you see the pictures, celebrate good times come on etc
 

N_Quire

Zargawee, the Middle-East doesn't have a monopoly on desert and hot weather. Have you ever been to Phoenix, Arizona in the summer? America has plenty of sand and sunshine. Come to California and find out. Death Valley or Malibu, take you pick.
 

BoulderHead

I actually thought taking Bagdad might prove difficult, but from what I've seen it may fall rather easily.
 

Zargawee

We've been driving in and out of Baghdad for the last 24 hours at will.
I have pictures denys this ... every viachle tried to enter Baghdad is destroyed , want to see them ? try this link but the language is arabic www.aljazeera.net


Zargawee, the Middle-East doesn't have a monopoly on desert and hot weather. Have you ever been to Phoenix, Arizona in the summer? America has plenty of sand and sunshine. Come to California and find out. Death Valley or Malibu, take you pick.
I didn't say so .. But our weather is badly hot , White-skined soldiers might see it unbearable , but others might accept it .
add to that that our air is polluted , it's ( in industrial areas ) like living in China's Capital .
And what is worse than that , the sand storms that happens everyday .

I Never been to America , but i Know that CA is very hot , also Arezona .

I actually thought taking Bagdad might prove difficult, but from what I've seen it may fall rather easily.
Wait , and the days will tell you ...
 

Alias

Originally posted by Zargawee
I have pictures denys this ... every viachle tried to enter Baghdad is destroyed , want to see them ? try this link but the language is arabic www.aljazeera.net
Regardless of what any press report says, the families of the US volunteer soldiers will validate our reported losses in the War.

Also, Zargawee, the US has many 'embedded' reporters within our military. The fact that we currently have soldiers within Baghdad is very difficult to dispute.

I am sure that you will try.:frown:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Related Threads for: How long to take baghdad?

  • Posted
2
Replies
45
Views
12K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
544
Replies
17
Views
3K
  • Posted
Replies
13
Views
2K
  • Posted
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Posted
2 3
Replies
73
Views
6K

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving

Hot Threads

Top