Did simplicity win in our school's technical drawing competition?

  • Thread starter Benzoate
  • Start date
In summary, I think that not having participated in science fairs or attended math and/or science camps won't have a significant impact on your performance as a physicist or scientist. However, if you're interested in science and you do your research, these activities might help you develop the skills you need.
  • #1
Benzoate
422
0
did not participate in science fairs as a child or did not attend math and/or science camps? I only started reading science literature as a preteen and physics literature as a teen. Will this affect my performance as a physics major and later a scientist?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Benzoate said:
did not participate in science fairs as a child or did not attend math and/or science camps?
I didn't attend anything like this, but then I don't think they exist in my country.
I only started reading science literature as a preteen and physics literature as a teen. Will this affect my performance as a physics major and later a scientist?
I shouldn't think it will affect you. After all, you were at least reading literature outside school, which is something that a lot of people didn't do.
 
  • #3
I never participated in science fairs at all, nor math competitions when I was younger(I now wish that I did, but we can't change those things right? ;) ). In fact if you were to know me 3 years ago you never would in a million years think that I was going to end up attempting to go into a science related career.

I personally would say that it doesn't really matter, I figure that I am on par with most people entering University with interests in science and it only took me about a year of dedicated hard work to repair any damage I did.

How old are you now? How many years until you enter University? Just because you did not participate in competitions does not mean you are not good at math and science.

I think reading science literature as a preteen is easily early enough!

Science fairs mainly just give you an opportunity to do some interesting research and learn more about science. Perhaps some experimental skills like measurement can be practiced during science fairs. But with the amount of labs in University(plus the labs in HS), you get lots of practice with that anyway. If you are good at math and science, there is no reason to worry at all.
 
Last edited:
  • #4
I too have never participated in anything like you have mentioned. I'm from England like cristo and I've neve heard of any here. I don't think it will affect your performance at all as long as you're willing to work hard at what you do.
 
  • #5
I suspect that the vast majority of working scientists have never participated in a science fair as a child. I have judged science fairs, and my impression is that the majority of kids participating are not doing so out of their own interest in science, but because a teacher or parent is pushing them to do so (or it's just plain required for the entire class). Those who advance to regional competitions do have better presentations of their projects, but it takes a lot of questions to ferret out how much is their work and how much is their parents' work. For a lot of students, they don't even have access to such fairs. Not every kid can afford to buy all the supplies to even do a project, and not every school offers an opportunity to participate.

For some kids, it's the experience that inspires them to get more interested in science, but you don't need to do that if you're already interested.
 
  • #6
Benzoate said:
did not participate in science fairs as a child or did not attend math and/or science camps? I only started reading science literature as a preteen and physics literature as a teen. Will this affect my performance as a physics major and later a scientist?

I participated in science fairs from elementary school to high school. I think they were great experiences for other reasons, but they didn't really teach me much about science. In the real world, experimental science is a technique that's best learned in a (university) classroom. You can't just slap something together with glue and scissors, and expect to do a scientifically rigorous project. Looking back on it, most of the science fair projects I did weren't even scientifically accurate. The only exception was the one I did my senior year of high school, when I based my project on mentorship research I had done in the Mayo Clinic's medical physics department.

As has been already said, science fairs might inspire people to study science in college. That was probably the case with me. But most projects I've seen wouldn't actually constitute actual science. So no, you won't be hurt at all by not having had these experiences.
 
  • #7
I went to a science presentation at our college and helped to set up the experiments, but that was mainly because I had the raging horn for a girl who was also in attendance, ahhhh them were the days. Apart from that you would not of seen me dead doing anything extra curricular at all at school, except maybe detention.
 
  • #8
I spent my childhood breaking neighbors windows and terrorizing the neighborhood. I turned out fine as a physics major.
 
  • #9
This will make for an interesting thread: The teenage years of physicists. And you're not disadvatnaged if you're prepared to work to gain ground. In some ways you might even be in a better position learning the material later, you'll bring a more mature brain to bear against the ideas you'll be studying.
 
  • #10
Zeth said:
This will make for an interesting thread:

sure it will be!1:cool::cool:

as regarding the OP, i too never attended any science fair or any science camp. even 1yr b4 joining the college, i didnt knew anything abt my career n all. only cartoons n candies filled up my space. but it hasnt affected anyway my current stiuation(BTW i am doing mechanical engineering).
n yes, as already pointed out, most school kids attend those (:tongue2::tongue2:) shows because of the pressure from school teachers n parents
 
  • #11
Benzoate said:
Will this affect my performance as a physics major and later a scientist?

Not at all. Don't worry.
 
  • #12
buster said:
sure it will be!1:cool::cool:

as regarding the OP, i too never attended any science fair or any science camp. even 1yr b4 joining the college, i didnt knew anything abt my career n all. only cartoons n candies filled up my space. but it hasnt affected anyway my current stiuation(BTW i am doing mechanical engineering).
n yes, as already pointed out, most school kids attend those (:tongue2::tongue2:) shows because of the pressure from school teachers n parents

Ugh man, stop tying like that! :mad:

You are in college, right? :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
  • #13
I never attended science fairs or competition, my school neither offered or promoted it in anyway. I went to a school that catered more to the people who didn't care than to the ones who did. I never went to science camps or anything of the like either, there were a few things like that offered around the province but my parents would never allow me to go. I probably wouldn't have wanted to in my younger school years, but when I was in high school I really would have like to go to something like that. That being said I don't think it set me back at all, I suppose I turned out alright :P
 
  • #14
you don't have to be a child prodigy to succeed in life. chill dude.
 
  • #15
cyrusabdollahi said:
You are in college, right? :rolleyes:

didnt u read what i wrote?
yea, i m in college
 
  • #16
Smurf said:
you don't have to be a child prodigy to succeed in life. chill dude.

Oh God now you've just pressurised people into thinking if they were a child prodigy they have to succeed! :rolleyes::tongue2:

To succeed in life you need persistence more than intelligence generally. Mind you how you define success is entirely subjective, say I was a child in the US then I might define success as becoming rich and achieving the American dream, just a general example btw I realize not everyone wants this.

Me I define success as being happy, with one or two added extras, but then I'm a simple person. But I might if I cared about such things define success as having grand children and a happy family. A Buddhist might define success as detaching himself from desire and the physical chains of existence and achieving enlightenment. Success is a very transient concept, it is pretty guaranteed that one man's success might be viewed by another as a waste of time.
 
Last edited:
  • #17
No -- never participated in any competitions or the like.

And, I've never heard of a competition win to help promote anyone's scientific career -- at least not here in Europe!
 
  • #18
buster said:
didnt u read what i wrote?
yea, i m in college

I think he means to stop using the chat room style of writing and use proper coherent English/grammar.
 
  • #19
ranger said:
I think he means to stop using the chat room style of writing and use proper coherent English/grammar.

okayo:)o:) will do that from now on:approve::approve:
sorry for that
 
Last edited:
  • #20
Schrodinger's Dog said:
Oh God now you've just pressurised people into thinking if they were a child prodigy they have to succeed! :rolleyes::tongue2:

are you a child prodigy:confused::confused::confused::biggrin::wink:
 
  • #21
buster said:
are you a child prodigy:confused::confused::confused::biggrin::wink:

No I'm not a child for starters.:smile:
 
  • #22
Schrodinger's Dog said:
No I'm not a child for starters.:smile:

:redface::redface:relax, i was just kidding around:tongue::tongue:
 
  • #23
Schrodinger's Dog said:
No I'm not a child for starters.:smile:

buster said:
:redface::redface:relax, i was just kidding around:tongue::tongue:

You're telling him to "relax" when he had a smiley face in his post in the first place and obviously wasn't agitated. :rolleyes:

EDIT: Being on topic would be good. I participated in precisely two science fairs, on in sixth grade, and the next one not until twelfth grade! In the first one, I built an electromagnet, but my parents helped me out quite a bit (esp with building the backdrop for the poster). The 12th grade project was based on the observations I had made for my I.B. Extended Essay on Cepheid variable stars.

Both science fairs were fun, but they had little or no bearing on my success in scientific study in university. Granted, I may have been at some advantage because I've been interested in science since I was a kid, and passion and motivation are very important, as is thinking scientifically. But if you have developed these traits at a later age, what difference does it make. If anything, you now have the capacity to study things at a higher level than you would have as a child. Furthermore, as has been mentioned already, unlike you, most people don't study outside of school for the sake of learning because they're interested in a subject.
 
Last edited:
  • #24
Moonbear said:
I suspect that the vast majority of working scientists have never participated in a science fair as a child. I have judged science fairs, and my impression is that the majority of kids participating are not doing so out of their own interest in science, but because a teacher or parent is pushing them to do so (or it's just plain required for the entire class). Those who advance to regional competitions do have better presentations of their projects, but it takes a lot of questions to ferret out how much is their work and how much is their parents' work. For a lot of students, they don't even have access to such fairs. Not every kid can afford to buy all the supplies to even do a project, and not every school offers an opportunity to participate.

For some kids, it's the experience that inspires them to get more interested in science, but you don't need to do that if you're already interested.

It was mandatory for our 7th grade science class. We had to at least complete the project and do a presentation, but didn't necessarily have to enter it into the competition.

I was never that interested in that sort of thing or the diaramas and so on required for history class, etc.

Things like the pinewood derby races, rocket races, etc in cub scouts/boy scouts interested me a lot more. Having a problem to solve was a lot more interesting way to learn than to have to pick out a project I was interested in. For one thing, I was little more focused and knew what I wanted out of it. The rules were the limits and you had the chance to use a little creativity in finding a solution that would still fit within the rules.

Too bad they didn't have those competitions where you have to build a bridge out of toothpicks when I was in school. That would have been exactly the sort of thing that would get me excited.

Similar thing on papers I had to write in English and/or Lit classes. If I had to pick out a subject, the paper usually turned out pretty bad. Generally, the dumber the topic I was given, the better the paper I wrote. It almost became a challenge to see how far I could twist a lousy subject without actually breaking it.
 
  • #25
That reminds me at school we had a competition in TD(Technical Drawing) where we had to build the most solid bridge structure out of a small amount of balsa wood and place heavy metal weights on it until it snapped.

So we all paired off and argued for a while about the best bridge shape, from what we had experienced. Now I knew certain shapes are inherently strong given a certain distance, even at our young ages we knew that, although we didn't know a lot about physics laws as such we were only 12; even so I knew that just making an object that was very dense would be better in this case as the distance was short, single span bridges are better than complex designs, and note we didn't have the time to make perfect arches so they would probably be unstable.

So I just piled the wood together in the shape of a brick with glued cross spans across the bottom to stop it from expanding so much and it won; in fact it only snapped when the fat kid in the class sat on it for five seconds. Everyone else forgot the golden rule in this particular case, KISS. I think maybe that was the first time I really appreciated physics.
 

1. What does it mean for simplicity to win in a technical drawing competition?

When simplicity wins in a technical drawing competition, it means that the entry with the most straightforward and uncomplicated design was chosen as the winner. This usually implies that the drawing was easy to understand and effectively conveyed its intended message.

2. How is simplicity judged in a technical drawing competition?

The assessment of simplicity in a technical drawing competition is often based on the following criteria: the use of minimal lines and shapes, the absence of unnecessary elements, and the overall clarity and organization of the drawing.

3. Why is simplicity important in technical drawing?

Simplicity is important in technical drawing because it allows for easier understanding and interpretation of the drawing. It also helps to convey the intended message or information more effectively, and can save time and effort in the design process.

4. Was simplicity the only factor considered in determining the winner of the technical drawing competition?

No, simplicity was not necessarily the only factor considered in determining the winner of the technical drawing competition. Other factors such as technical skill, creativity, and adherence to the competition guidelines may also have been taken into account.

5. How can I incorporate simplicity into my technical drawings?

To incorporate simplicity into your technical drawings, start by focusing on the essential elements and eliminating any unnecessary details. Use minimal and clean lines and shapes, and make sure the design is well-organized and easy to understand. It may also be helpful to get feedback from others to ensure the drawing conveys its intended message clearly.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
870
  • General Discussion
Replies
4
Views
585
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
17
Views
1K
  • STEM Career Guidance
Replies
33
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
2
Replies
56
Views
6K
  • General Discussion
Replies
1
Views
1K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
2
Views
776
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • STEM Academic Advising
Replies
4
Views
1K
Back
Top