How many photons are reflecting?

  • Thread starter Alvydas
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Photons
In summary, the conversation discusses the number of photons being emitted by a 10mW red laser and how many of them are touching a mirror at a given moment. The experts mention that this is a statistical question and it is difficult to determine the exact number. They also discuss the idea of a photon's length and conclude that it is more accurate to say that a photon does not have a length rather than saying its length is zero. They also touch on the topic of an electron moving faster than the speed of light, concluding that this is not possible due to its mass. The conversation ends with a comment about the meaninglessness of the original question.
  • #36
Alvydas said:
But if photon is a point it can not overlap each other and therefore always acts alone on an atom.
First, as I said above, it is bad to think of a photon as a classical point particle, which appears to be what you are describing. However, because an atom does have size even if photons do not you could still get multiple photons interacting with the same atom at a given time.
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #37
Furthermore, the multiphoton effect has nothing to do with the "size" of the photon, but rather the time scale of the interactions. In multiphoton photoemission, it is the time for an excited state to decay back to its ground state. If a photon can excite a particular electron while it is in an excited (but bound state) of the solid before it decays back to the valence band, then it has a chance to be excited to an even higher state. The factor that affects this includes the photon density per unit area, and the decay rate of the excited state. It has nothing to do with the size of the photon.

Zz.
 
  • #38
So I can send strong infrared beam to a mirror and get reflected visible light ?
But not due surface heating, just because of reemitting photons with double energy by the mirror.
Am I right?
If so what (approximately) power of incoming laser light I need to have at 1 square mm of mirror's surface? (to be effect visible)
 
  • #39
You are referring to Laser Up-converting, which is a process that can be used successfully. Google it - there are a lot of links. Most lasers work with a single 'pumping' wavelength applied and a longer wavelength laser light is produced as atoms return to a lower state. However, it is possible to pump some lasers with more than one wavelength and the resulting EM will have a higher energy than either of the pumping sources because the atoms are pumped to a level equal to the sum of the energies.

This will only happen under rare circumstances where the probability of an atom that has already been 'pumped' once, will decay is less than the probability that another incoming photon will pump it further. In most circumstances, the once-excited atom will decay before this can happen.
 
  • #40
Alvydas said:
So I can send strong infrared beam to a mirror and get reflected visible light ?

That has not been shows to can occur. You are applying different physics to different phenomenology. The multiphoton effect is on a photoemission phenomenon, NOT a "reflection".

There's just something not quite right with what you are thinking and with your question.

Zz.
 
  • #41
ZapperZ said:
That has not been shows to can occur. You are applying different physics to different phenomenology. The multiphoton effect is on a photoemission phenomenon, NOT a "reflection".

There's just something not quite right with what you are thinking and with your question.

Zz.

Yes, I agree it's a bit tenuous but, there again, when light is reflected in a mirror, the interaction isn't just one photo - one atom, in any case, but with the bulk material. Perhaps that should have been emphasised more earlier on.
I thought this up-conversion laser effect occurred in the solid state so the effect would be not 'specular' reflection but would still involve light coming off a surface when illuminated with two other, longer, wavelengths.
 
  • #42
Alvydas said:
So I can send strong infrared beam to a mirror and get reflected visible light ?
But not due surface heating, just because of reemitting photons with double energy by the mirror.
Am I right?
Not to my knowledge, no. Reflection has little, if anything, to do with atomic emission.
 
  • #43
sophiecentaur said:
Yes, I agree it's a bit tenuous but, there again, when light is reflected in a mirror, the interaction isn't just one photo - one atom, in any case, but with the bulk material. Perhaps that should have been emphasised more earlier on.
I thought this up-conversion laser effect occurred in the solid state so the effect would be not 'specular' reflection but would still involve light coming off a surface when illuminated with two other, longer, wavelengths.

I didn't want to get into that because the OP has a lot more issues with other basic understanding.

It is my opinion that this thread is nothing but a jumble of disconnected information that the OP has no ability to process correctly. This is one of those times where I often wish that people would ask just simple, basic question first before attempting to find something beyond what they are capable of understanding.

Zz.
 
  • #44
Yep.
I agree entirely. I think people are reluctant to ask the most basic questions for fear of appearing ignorant.
 
  • #45
Thank you all.
I have got some useful info.
I will try to adjust my style of asking to be more clear.
 

Similar threads

Replies
26
Views
4K
Replies
21
Views
3K
  • Other Physics Topics
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
24
Views
3K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
25
Views
3K
  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • Quantum Interpretations and Foundations
Replies
15
Views
243
Replies
7
Views
4K
Back
Top