If you have to choose a song...

  • Thread starter Cozma Alex
  • Start date
  • #1
210
15
To send to a solar system where there is a planet that may have intelligent aliens able to get it, what would you send?
Consider that they are probably not capable to understand the words but just to listen it

(every kind of music you like, pop, rock, love songs and every singer or group, beatles, michael jackson, katy perry, victoria justice and so on)

The choice is up to you
 

Answers and Replies

  • #3
11
48
Well perhaps Beethoven' late quartets. I would prefer Bach's, kunst der fuge. A version for string quartet, or maybe Glen Gould's truncated version on organ.
Second choice, the last chorus from Bach's "Saint Matthews Passion" (assuming they could not understand the words).
 
  • #4
1,562
3,362
Imperial March (Star Wars), no, strike that, they might think we were about to invade. On other days I would probably also choose some classical music like Beethoven, Bach, Mozart. But today I choose
 
  • #5
Borek
Mentor
28,502
2,926
Something that not only sounds great, but also looks quite interesting.

 
  • Like
Likes DennisN and Dr. Courtney
  • #6
6,265
1,280
I don't think it would be a good idea to send music. It is expecting them to be way too much like us to even get the concept. Even assuming they get the concept, they might still not recognize any given genre as music. Their music might have parameters that exclude ours.
 
  • #7
Borek
Mentor
28,502
2,926
I don't think it would be a good idea to send music. It is expecting them to be way too much like us to even get the concept. Even assuming they get the concept, they might still not recognize any given genre as music. Their music might have parameters that exclude ours.
Which is more or less why I thought about something that is interesting in more than one way.
 
  • #8
6,265
1,280
Which is more or less why I thought about something that is interesting in more than one way.
Yes, if you forced me to choose, I'd choose Bach, but I still think that is expecting them to be more like us than we have any good reason to expect.
 
  • #9
210
15
Yes, if you forced me to choose, I'd choose Bach, but I still think that is expecting them to be more like us than we have any good reason to expect.
I think we should send something that all humanity likes so that those aliens could make an idea about us and about what we like, even if they don't get the concept of music or they have different music in ours (whatever the genre) there is a pattern that can be observed, and if they are intelligent they probably gonna appreciate that pattern, at least that's what i think
 
  • #10
6,265
1,280
I think we should send something that all humanity likes so that those aliens could make an idea about us and about what we like, even if they don't get the concept of music or they have different music in ours (whatever the genre) there is a pattern that can be observed, and if they are intelligent they probably gonna appreciate that pattern, at least that's what i think
The problem is that the patterns in music are decorative. If they don't get art, they just won't get music, and might run themselves ragged trying to decipher some deep math insight that isn't there, or some communication of information that isn't there.
 
  • Like
Likes Sophia and Cozma Alex
  • #11
87
568
The problem is that the patterns in music are decorative. If they don't get art, they just won't get music, and might run themselves ragged trying to decipher some deep math insight that isn't there, or some communication of information that isn't there.
so true. But as far as I understand, this thread is more about people than about the aliens.
I'd choose a piece of classical music- Mozart, Beethoven, Chajkovskij (no idea how you spell him in English)
 
  • #12
6,265
1,280
so true. But as far as I understand, this thread is more about people than about the aliens.
A person's answer would reveal some of their assumptions about aliens, yes, but my answer is no different in that regard.
 
  • #13
11
48
so true. But as far as I understand, this thread is more about people than about the aliens.
I'd choose a piece of classical music- Mozart, Beethoven, Chajkovskij (no idea how you spell him in English)
It's spelled Tchaikovsky here in Amurica.
 
  • Like
Likes Sophia
  • #14
11
48
The problem is that the patterns in music are decorative.
Some but by no means all. Many patterns in music are structural, see A Generative Theory of Tonal Music by Lerdahl and Jackendoff, and I think I could go to my book shelves and pull out three or four other volumes on structural patterns in music.
 
  • #15
Astronuc
Staff Emeritus
Science Advisor
18,865
2,131
How about natural sounds, like wind, ocean waves, running streams, bird songs, . . . ?
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2, edward, Sophia and 2 others
  • #16
6,265
1,280
Some but by no means all. Many patterns in music are structural, see A Generative Theory of Tonal Music by Lerdahl and Jackendoff, and I think I could go to my book shelves and pull out three or four other volumes on structural patterns in music.
I threw out the word "decorative" a bit hastily, yes, waving my hand at the distinction between what is done for esthetic purposes and what is done for practical purposes. There's no reason to think aliens would have any esthetic motivations for anything they do, but it would be impossible for them not to have practical ones. And, even if they did have an esthetic sense, there is no reason to think it overlaps with ours.
 
  • #17
11
48
I threw out the word "decorative" a bit hastily, yes, waving my hand at the distinction between what is done for esthetic purposes and what is done for practical purposes.
I am afraid I don't understand what you are trying to say. Would you mind explaining that somewhat.
 
  • #18
11
48
How about natural sounds, like wind, ocean waves, running streams, bird songs, . . . ?
I like that idea very much.
 
  • #19
6,265
1,280
I am afraid I don't understand what you are trying to say. Would you mind explaining that somewhat.
Consider some big abstract sculpture in a city somewhere. It has some structure, but the sculpture is ultimately not practical. No one lives in it, it isn't used for storage, nor are meetings held in it. It's there for purely esthetic reasons. An alien intelligence could easily be unable to grasp that.
 
  • #20
Evo
Mentor
23,147
2,763
To send to a solar system where there is a planet that may have intelligent aliens able to get it, what would you send?
Consider that they are probably not capable to understand the words but just to listen it

(every kind of music you like, pop, rock, love songs and every singer or group, beatles, michael jackson, katy perry, victoria justice and so on)

The choice is up to you
We already did, are you aware of Voyager?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contents_of_the_Voyager_Golden_Record
 
  • Like
Likes 1oldman2, Sophia and collinsmark
  • #21
collinsmark
Homework Helper
Gold Member
2,904
1,272
[Edit: previous post deleted in lieu of this one.]

Wait, my last post might have been premature. On further thought, this might be more appropriate:


It's tough to go wrong there. That song is a safe bet, particularly if the video is transmitted too. Especially.
 
Last edited:
  • #22
87
568
I wonder if they could understand it. But it's the best we can do. I hope that they can understand the music as something created by intelligent beings. Even if they can't appreciate it, perhaps they would be curious to find out who sent it. Provided they have something like ears!
 
  • #23
11
48
Consider some big abstract sculpture in a city somewhere. It has some structure, but the sculpture is ultimately not practical. No one lives in it, it isn't used for storage, nor are meetings held in it. It's there for purely esthetic reasons. An alien intelligence could easily be unable to grasp that.
Thanks, yes, I see what you mean now.
 
  • #25
67
165
Yup, I've heard of it. To be honest I wouldn't know how to make a device to play it back. I would probably break it trying to figure it out. And I follow human logic.

Did they shipped a player with it?
They should have included pictures and diagrams on how to build a simple version of an old Edison hand cranked player.
 

Related Threads on If you have to choose a song...

Replies
1
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
18
Views
11K
Replies
19
Views
2K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
43
Views
5K
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
459
  • Last Post
4
Replies
80
Views
11K
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • Last Post
5
Replies
105
Views
9K
  • Last Post
2
Replies
25
Views
9K
Replies
40
Views
4K
Top