Can adjusting the scale compensate for imperfections in a mercury barometer?

In summary, the author suggests that an "inch" on the scale should be reduced by the factor 29.5/30.0 in order to account for an imperfect vacuum, and that the mercury might be stuck because of dirty tube and/or mercury.
  • #1
ClamShell
221
0
I have noticed that when I fill the 36 inch glass tube of
my mercury barometer, that there are thin bubbles of
air stuck between the mercury and the inside wall of the
tube; can't seem to get rid of them. Maybe a vacuum
needs to be pulled before pouring in the mercury, but
that seems too extreme for my "frugal" means. I'm
thinking that the reason it steadily drops over some
days to less than 30 inches, when the value is being
reported as 30 inches, is because of these bubbles.
I'm thinking that the vacuum has been compromised.
So I wonder...is it OK to just move the inches scale to
the lower point? Does it become temperature sensitive?
Does the length of an inch on the scale need to change
too?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Mercury barometers are temperature sensitive even in the absence of any bubbles.
 
  • #3
Maybe the expansion of the mercury with temperature
would even be counteracted by the expansion of the
imperfect vacuum. Maybe I've got just the right
imperfection to temperature stabilize the beast...
doubt it though.
 
  • #4
Are you sure you want to be messing around with mercury like this? Please tell me you're not doing it in your home. You have to be aware of how dangerous mercury can be for you and, if you lose containment, for the environment. Please be careful.

Chet
 
  • #5
Most likely the tube and/or the mercury is dirty.

As Chestermiller said, messing about with mercury is dangerous if you don't know what you are doing, and a "badly designed" (by modern safety standards) mercury barometer is a permanent health hazard, continuously emitting mercury vapor.

You shoudn't be "pouring" mercury into the tube in any case. http://www.m-p.co.uk/muk/acrobat/0796000115.pdf
 
  • #6
I was hoping that someone could answer my questions
above, so that I would not be tempted to re-do that
antique monstrosity. Thanks for the link Aleph, it was
especially nice to read that the author said "an effective
working reading" could be had without a 100% vacuum.
I have used these techniques on other project barometers
in the past and was never able to get the full height to
agree with the reported value. Never spilled any either;
you just need to go slow.

If I ever do re-do the beast, I'll seriously consider the
vacuum pump method. Have you a link on the vacuum
method?

Still would like to see some numbers though. Something
like "if it's 29.5 inches instead of 30 inches, then moving
the 30 inch mark to the 29.5 inch level will mean..."
That is to say if I could get a feeling for the magnitude of
the error due to imperfect vacuum, and correct it on the
scale, I would be less likely to consider messing with its
guts.

Thanks for the concern, I've always considered mercury
to be highly respected. I read that something like 17 tons
a year ends up in landfills in the USA.
 
  • #7
Somebody out there MUST have a rigorous analysis mercury
barometers...

I'm thinking that there is a simple solution to the problem
of an imperfect vacuum in the top of the tube.

Namely that if 30 inches has been reduced to 29.5 inches,
that an inch on the readout scale should be reduced by the
factor 29.5/30.0. And if the mercury fell to 15 inches, then
an "inch" on the scale would be only a half inch.

Anybody got some better arithmetic?
 

1. What is an Imperfect Mercury Barometer?

An Imperfect Mercury Barometer is a scientific instrument used to measure atmospheric pressure. It consists of a glass tube filled with mercury, which is then inverted into a dish of mercury. The level of mercury in the tube changes according to the atmospheric pressure, and this change can be used to determine the current weather conditions.

2. How does an Imperfect Mercury Barometer work?

The mercury barometer works on the principle of atmospheric pressure. When the atmospheric pressure is high, the mercury in the tube is pushed down, causing it to rise in the dish. Conversely, when the atmospheric pressure is low, the mercury in the tube is pushed up, causing it to fall in the dish. The height of the mercury column in the tube is then measured and used to determine the current atmospheric pressure.

3. What are the advantages of using an Imperfect Mercury Barometer?

One of the main advantages of using an Imperfect Mercury Barometer is its accuracy. It is considered the standard for measuring atmospheric pressure and is still widely used in meteorology and weather forecasting. It is also a relatively simple and inexpensive instrument, making it accessible to a wide range of users.

4. What are the limitations of an Imperfect Mercury Barometer?

An Imperfect Mercury Barometer is affected by changes in temperature and altitude, which can lead to inaccurate readings. It also requires regular calibration and maintenance to ensure its accuracy. Additionally, the use of mercury in barometers raises environmental concerns, leading to the development of alternative instruments.

5. How is an Imperfect Mercury Barometer different from a Perfect Mercury Barometer?

An Imperfect Mercury Barometer is a simplified version of a Perfect Mercury Barometer, which uses a narrower glass tube and a larger dish of mercury. This design allows for more accurate readings, but it also makes the instrument more sensitive to changes in atmospheric pressure. The Imperfect Mercury Barometer is a more practical and commonly used instrument for measuring atmospheric pressure.

Similar threads

  • Advanced Physics Homework Help
Replies
2
Views
3K
  • Mechanics
Replies
1
Views
3K
  • Mechanical Engineering
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
7
Views
7K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
3
Views
799
Replies
1
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
2K
  • DIY Projects
Replies
30
Views
4K
  • Electrical Engineering
Replies
11
Views
7K
  • Beyond the Standard Models
Replies
18
Views
3K
Back
Top